Thursday, April 19, 2018
Politics

PolitiFact: FISA court not transparent, as President Barack Obama claimed

President Barack Obama has taken a lot of criticism from both friend and foe for recent disclosures that the U.S. government monitors telephone and Internet traffic.

In a Monday interview with Charlie Rose, Obama defended the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, which hears government requests for warrants related to national security investigations. He said he was comfortable with the programs because the FBI has to go to the FISA court with probable cause and ask for a warrant.

Rose: "But has FISA court turned down any request?"

Obama: "First of all, Charlie, the number of requests are surprisingly small, No. 1. No. 2, folks don't go with a query unless they've got a pretty good suspicion."

Rose: "Should this be transparent in some way?"

Obama: "It is transparent, that's why we set up the FISA court. . . . My concern has always been not that we shouldn't do intelligence gathering to prevent terrorism but rather are we setting up a system of checks and balances?"

Did Obama have justification for saying that the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court "is transparent?"

The court was established in 1978 to provide oversight of a system that many observers believed had been widely abused by prior administrations. National Security Agency requests for warrants must have certification from Justice Department officials that the target of surveillance is either a foreign power or the agent of a foreign power. These applications are heard by federal judges who serve on the court on a rotating basis. All hearings and decisions are conducted in secret. Public disclosure of the court's activities is sharply limited, consisting of an annual letter sent to Congress that provides statistics on applications for surveillance.

According to the most recent letter, about 98 percent of the 1,856 applications for surveillance and searches in 2012 were approved, with one withdrawn and 40 others modified. The government made 212 applications for business records. The government modified 200 of these applications, but none was denied.

The letter doesn't offer any details about these applications, only the raw numbers.

The White House argues that this system provides checks and balances that come as close to transparency as national security needs permit. Experts say there are good reasons for this secrecy.

"If we required that the public be permitted to take a peek at these classified proceedings, we'd be giving that information to foreign powers and terrorists as well, which would be lunacy," said Molly Bishop Shadel, a University of Virginia law professor who once worked for the Justice Department representing the United States before the surveillance court.

Still, is Obama justified in calling the kind of disclosure the court makes "transparency"? We asked a range of experts on secrecy and public access, and most agreed that Obama is wrong to take credit for any reasonable degree of "transparency" in the court's operations. While Congress has a degree of oversight over the court, that doesn't mean there's transparency — a word that we think the ordinary person assumes to mean a nontrivial amount of disclosure to the public and the press.

"On occasion, parts of the court's opinions will be declassified and released to the public, but this is the exception to the rule," said Nathan Sales, a law professor at George Mason University. "The FISA court certainly serves as an important check on the executive branch, but — usually — it's not accurate to call the court 'transparent.' "

Jim Harper, director of information policy studies at the libertarian Cato Institute, agreed. For one of his projects, Harper has assembled a list of four tenets of transparency. The court, he said, doesn't even meet the first and most important one of these: providing authoritative sourcing for information. "I don't know of any plausible meaning of 'transparent' that encompasses the 'oversight behind closed doors' concept."

Freedom of Information advocates seconded this view. "Checks and balances may be related, but they are not the same thing as 'transparency,' " said Kenneth F. Bunting, executive director of the National Freedom of Information Coalition. "A court system that has proceedings that are secret and makes secret rulings that are often based on secret interpretations of law cannot fit my definition of the word 'transparent.' "

We should note that Obama himself signed a memorandum about "transparency and open government." While this memorandum was intended to apply to nonclassified government information, the court doesn't come close to upholding the principles for transparency outlined in it.

"Transparency promotes accountability and provides information for citizens about what their government is doing . . ." Obama wrote. "My administration will take appropriate action, consistent with law and policy, to disclose information rapidly in forms that the public can readily find and use."

We don't doubt that there are good reasons for secrecy at the court, but if you're going to operate a mostly secret court, you don't get to crow about how "transparent" it is. We rate his claim Pants on Fire.

Comments
Everybody loses in a trade war, Canadian chamber CEO warns Tampa officials

Everybody loses in a trade war, Canadian chamber CEO warns Tampa officials

TAMPA — President Donald Trump has tweeted "trade wars are good, and easy to win."Don’t believe it, the president of the Canadian Chamber of Commerce told Tampa business and political leaders on Wednesday."We share more with you than with anybody els...
Published: 04/19/18
Hernando clerk of the court announces resignation to run for judicial seat

Hernando clerk of the court announces resignation to run for judicial seat

BROOKSVILLE — Clerk of the Circuit Court and Comptroller Don Barbee this week submitted his resignation — effective Jan. 7 — to run for an open circuit judge seat.Barbee, who is in the middle of his second term, said he made the move "with a tremendo...
Published: 04/17/18
Poll: Democrats’ advantage in midterm election support is shrinking

Poll: Democrats’ advantage in midterm election support is shrinking

Democrats hold an advantage ahead of the midterm elections, but a Washington Post-ABC News poll shows that edge has narrowed since January, a signal to party leaders and strategists that they could be premature in anticipating a huge wave of victorie...
Published: 04/16/18
Spokesman: Former first lady Barbara Bush in failing health

Spokesman: Former first lady Barbara Bush in failing health

HOUSTON — Former first lady Barbara Bush is in "failing health" and won’t seek additional medical treatment, a Bush family spokesman said Sunday. "Following a recent series of hospitalizations, and after consulting her family and doctors...
Published: 04/15/18
Trump assails Comey in tweetstorm, calls for ex-FBI director to be imprisoned

Trump assails Comey in tweetstorm, calls for ex-FBI director to be imprisoned

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump attacked James Comey in a fusillade of tweets Sunday morning, calling for the former FBI director to be imprisoned as Trump served up a number of his favorite theories and alleged misdeeds without evidence.Trump’s ...
Published: 04/15/18
President Trump’s approval rating is back near first-100-day levels

President Trump’s approval rating is back near first-100-day levels

President Donald Trump’s approval rating stands at 40 percent in a new Washington Post-ABC News poll, slightly more than his 36 percent approval rating when last measured in January. It’s also the highest he’s enjoyed in Post-ABC polling since his fi...
Published: 04/15/18
Gun rights advocates holding rallies at state capitols in US

Gun rights advocates holding rallies at state capitols in US

DOVER, Del. — Gun rights supporters — many carrying rifles and ammunition — gathered at state capitols across the U.S. on Saturday to push back against efforts to pass stricter gun-control laws that they fear threaten their constitutional right to be...
Published: 04/15/18
Trump, Abe to meet as U.S.-Japan relationship shows strains over N. Korea, trade

Trump, Abe to meet as U.S.-Japan relationship shows strains over N. Korea, trade

President Donald Trump will welcome Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe to Mar-a-Lago this week in an effort to shore up their relationship amid strains in the U.S.-Japan alliance ahead of Trump’s potential summit with the leader of North Korea.Abe is...
Published: 04/14/18
Haley warns that US forces ‘locked and loaded’ if Syria stages another chemical attack

Haley warns that US forces ‘locked and loaded’ if Syria stages another chemical attack

The U.S. ambassador to the United Nations told the Security Council on Saturday that the United States is "locked and loaded," ready to launch another military strike if the Syrian government ever uses chemical weapons again."I spoke to the president...
Published: 04/14/18
Trump uses phrase that haunted Bush: ‘Mission Accomplished!’

Trump uses phrase that haunted Bush: ‘Mission Accomplished!’

WASHINGTON — As he declares the U.S.-led airstrikes against Syria a success, President Donald Trump is adopting a phrase that a previous president came to regret — "mission accomplished." On Saturday, Trump tweeted: "A perfectly executed strike last ...
Published: 04/14/18