Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PolitiFact Florida | Tampa Bay Times

PolitiFact Florida: Fact-checking attack ad against GOP health care bill

President Donald Trump talks with House Speaker Paul Ryan in the Rose Garden of the White House on 
May 4 after the House pushed through a health care bill.

Associated Press

President Donald Trump talks with House Speaker Paul Ryan in the Rose Garden of the White House on May 4 after the House pushed through a health care bill.

A health care advocacy group targeted two dozen House Republicans who voted for the American Health Care Act, including Florida Reps. Carlos Curbelo of Miami and Brian Mast of the Treasure Coast, in a new ad.

The mostly digital ad by Save My Care says the health care bill will lead to skyrocketing costs for older consumers.

"Congressman Curbelo just voted for a disastrous health care repeal bill opposed by the American Medical Association, AARP and the American Cancer Society," the ad says. "Curbelo voted to raise your costs and cut coverage for millions, to let insurance companies deny affordable coverage for cancer treatment and maternity care, and charge five times more for people over 50."

Formed in 2016, Save My Care is affiliated with Eric Kessler, a former White House appointee who helped to manage conservation issues during Bill Clinton's administration.

For this fact-check, we wanted to hone in on whether the American Health Care Act allows insurance companies to "charge five times more for people over 50."

This line is partially accurate but leaves out important details. We rate it Half True.

There is a provision that allows insurance companies to charge five times more for consumers ages 50 to 64 buying insurance on the individual market.

Some viewers might assume the five-fold increase starts from zero. What the ad doesn't tell you is that insurers can already charge older people more than younger adults — three times as much.

Also, this doesn't apply to seniors on Medicare, or people between 50 and 64 years old with employer-sponsored coverage.

Rate banding happens

The House bill increases the 3-to-1 "rate banding" ratio under current law up to five times starting in 2018, unless states set a different age ratio.

Before the Affordable Care Act, nicknamed Obamacare, premiums for older adults were typically four or five times the premiums charged to younger adults, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.

That more accurately reflects the actual higher costs spent for older adults' health care, said Linda Blumberg, an Urban Institute health policy expert.

The lower age ratio in President Barack Obama's health care law was a better deal for older adults. The goal was to make coverage cheaper for older adults regardless of health status.

The Rand Corporation, which evaluated an earlier version of the American Health Care Act, found that older adults would pay more than current law if the House bill with the 5-to-1 rate banding becomes law. (The research was funded by the Commonwealth Fund, which aims to increase health care access for the poor.)

The increased costs would occur, according to Rand, as a result of tax credits in the House bill not increasing with age as steeply as premiums.

Young people, however, would get a break on premiums.

Other cost drivers

The change in age ratios is just one provision of the House proposal that affects costs for older adults.

Here's another: The legislation would replace the current income-based tax credits with a credit based on age.

For adults over 60, that would mean a $4,000 credit.

For adults under 30, the credit would be $2,000.

The legislation phases out tax credits for individuals who make more than $75,000 annually (or a couple who files jointly earning $150,000).

Older, lower-income residents and people who live in high-premium states such as Alaska and Arizona would generally receive less financial assistance in the House proposal, according to a Kaiser analysis.

A Congressional Budget Office analysis of an earlier version of the American Health Care Act, or AHCA, concluded that it would disproportionately increase the number of uninsured ages 50 to 64 with incomes less than 200 percent of the poverty limit. (The final legislation has not yet received a CBO score.)

For example: Under current law, a 64-year-old with an income of $26,500 would pay a net premium of $1,700 after factoring in a tax credit.

Under the House bill, according to CBO, that person's premium rises to $14,600.

Older Americans could see more changes if states choose to redefine essential health benefits for coverage in the individual market.

"I cannot imagine a scenario where the AHCA is not worse for older adults than the ACA," Blumberg said.

Curbelo's spokeswoman told us Curbelo has called for revisions to the bill that he voted for that increase tax credits for low-income Americans and for people approaching retirement.

Read more rulings at PolitiFact.com/florida.

The statement

U.S. Rep. Carlos Curbelo voted for a health care bill that will let insurance companies "charge five times more for people over 50."

Save My Care, in a digital ad

The ruling

PolitiFact ruling: Half True A provision in the bill allows insurance companies to charge five times more for consumers ages 50-64 buying insurance on the individual market. What the ad leaves out is that insurers can already charge older people three times more than younger adults, and this change does not apply to seniors on Medicare or older adults with employer-sponsored coverage. We rate this claim Half True.

PolitiFact Florida: Fact-checking attack ad against GOP health care bill 05/15/17 [Last modified: Sunday, May 14, 2017 8:26pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Deputies: Wimauma teacher's aide sexually molested teen, 13

    Crime

    A Wimauma teacher's aide faces charges lewd or lascivious molestation after Hillborough County deputies say he inappropriatly touched a 13-year-old girl.

    Sonny Juarez, 29, a teacher's aide in Wimauma, faces charges lewd or lascivious molestation after Hillborough County deputies say he inappropriatly touched a 13-year-old girl on several occasions while working at the RCMA Wimauma Academy, 18236 U.S. 301 S, between November 2016 and March 2017. [Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office]

  2. Tampa Bay deputies head to UF to assist with Richard Spencer's speech

    Public Safety

    Local deputies are heading up to Alachua County in preparation of white nationalist Richard Spencer's speech in Gainesville on Thursday.

    Law enforcement is stepped up in Gainesville on Oct. 18, 2017, ahead of Richard Spencer's appearance. [WILL VRAGOVIC | Times]
  3. Gymnast McKayla Maroney alleges sexual abuse by team doctor

    Olympics

    Two-time Olympic medalist McKayla Maroney says she was molested for years by a former USA Gymnastics team doctor, abuse she said started in her early teens and continued for the rest of her competitive career.

    U.S. gymnast McKayla Maroney poses after completing her routine on the vault during the Artistic Gymnastic women's qualifications at the 2012 Summer Olympics in London. Maroney posted a statement on Twitter Oct. 18, 2017, in which she said she was molested for years by former Team USA doctor Larry Nassar. [Associated Press]
  4. Top 5 at Noon: Facts on Richard Spencer's Florida visit; Column: Jameis, don't be a hero; Locale Market changes again

    News

    Here are the latest headlines and updates on tampabay.com:

    White nationalist Richard Spencer (C) and his supporters clash with Virginia State Police in Emancipation Park after the "Unite the Right" rally was declared an unlawful gathering August 12, 2017 in Charlottesville, Virginia. Spencer is set to speak at the University of Florida. [Getty]
  5. Bucs Cannon Fodder podcast: Uncertainty surrounds Jameis Winston's health

    Bucs

    Greg Auman talks about the Bucs' quarterback situation, with uncertainty around Jameis Winston's health, in his latest Cannon Fodder podcast.

    Jameis Winston takes the field for warmups before the Bucs' game against the Cardinals Sunday in Glandale, Ariz. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]