Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PunditFact: Fact-checking the April 13 news shows

Another Sunday, another set of misrepresentations about the Affordable Care Act.

On ABC's This Week, a gaggle of pundits discussed the resignation of Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius. That evolved into a debate about the law's effectiveness and the implications for the midterm elections.

Conservative radio host Laura Ingraham argued that the health care law is resulting in higher health care costs and fewer health care choices, claims that got a rise out of liberal pundit James Carville.

"Again, it's working," Carville said. "Y'all said it would collapse. You said no one would sign up. You said it would cost part-time jobs."

"It's costing 2 million jobs, according to the (Congressional Budget Office)," Ingraham said, cutting Carville off.

"You said the risk corridors were going to go broke," Carville continued. "None of it has happened. Get over it. It's working."

Both arguments have some technical flaws. We'll explain why.

'2 million jobs'

Ingraham said the health care law is "costing 2 million jobs" and cited the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office as a source.

The number isn't out of thin air, but Ingraham isn't describing the statistic correctly.

In a February report, CBO projected "a decline in the number of full-time-equivalent workers of about 2.0 million in 2017, rising to about 2.5 million in 2024."

But the losses CBO projected aren't job losses, and they aren't driven by employers laying off employees.

Essentially, some workers are expected to voluntarily dial back their hours, government researchers predict. It's an important distinction. CBO estimated that millions of Americans will probably decide they don't need to work as much because the law makes health insurance more available by offering subsidies on the federal marketplace and by expanding Medicaid eligibility in some states.

Just as important, CBO's 2 million "full-time-equivalent workers" figure is not a dressed-up word for 2 million full-time jobs. CBO did not break down how many full-time jobs would be reduced under the law versus employees simply working fewer hours, dropping a separate part-time job, or leaving the workforce.

PunditFact rates the claim Mostly False.

'Risk corridors'

Carville, meanwhile, pointed to health insurance risk corridors as a sign that the health care law is working.

In reality, the lack of news about the risk corridors — a mechanism that could result in the government subsidizing health insurance companies — is entirely expected and does not speak to the law's performance.

Carville's claim rates Mostly False.

The health care law does a complete number on the insurance game as Americans know it, at least in the individual and small group markets. Instead of companies making a profit through selling policies to the healthy and avoiding the ill, the law aims to pull carriers into a world where they insure everyone and compete based on efficiency and value.

Enter the government and a few tricks to spread both possible losses and windfall profits among insurance companies and between all insurance companies and the government. One of those devices is a temporary program called risk corridors.

Here's how it works: The government sets financial benchmarks for each plan offered on the marketplace. As long as insurers come close to that benchmark, nothing happens. If an insurer overperforms by up to 3 percent, they can keep the extra revenue. If they underperform by up to 3 percent, they are forced to absorb those additional costs.

When the gaps get wider, however, money starts changing hands. If insurers beat their benchmark by 3 to 8 percent, they have to split that extra revenue with the federal government. If insurers beat the mark by more than 8 percent, the government receives 80 percent of that additional money.

On the flip side, when insurers fail to meet their benchmarks the government helps absorb those costs. If insurers underperform by 3 to 8 percent, the government will cover half the extra cost. The government covers 80 percent of losses bigger than that.

Conservatives like Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., and Bill Kristol, editor of the conservative Weekly Standard, have been waving a red flag, warning that the risk corridors program is a built-in bailout for health insurance companies. CBO, meanwhile, says that when coupled with some other programs, risk corridors will actually generate revenue for the federal government.

The fact is, we won't know until insurance companies tally the premiums they collected and compare those to the claims they paid out in 2014. The very earliest they could do that would be January 2015, but they have until the end of July 2015 to submit their data to Washington.

Staff writers Jon Greenberg and Katie Sanders contributed to this report. Aaron Sharockman is the editor of

The statement

Obamacare is "costing 2 million jobs."

Laura Ingraham, on ABC's "This Week"

The ruling

PunditFact ruling: Mostly False
A government analysis says the health care law will cause a decline in the number of full-time-equivalent workers of about 2 million in 2017, but that's not the same as saying the law is costing 2 million jobs. In reality, analysts say some workers are expected to voluntarily dial back their hours because they'll be able to acquire health insurance without working as much. We rate the claim Mostly False.

The statement

The insurance risk corridors aren't going broke like Republicans predicted.

James Carville, on ABC's "This Week"

The ruling

PunditFact ruling: Mostly False
Carville is claiming victory before any numbers are in. We won't know for sure whether government gained, lost or broke even with the risk corridors until 2014 is over. We rate the claim Mostly False.

PunditFact: Fact-checking the April 13 news shows 04/13/14 [Last modified: Sunday, April 13, 2014 9:07pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Largo commissioners raise ceiling on next year's property tax rate

    Local Government

    LARGO — The proposed budget included a recommendation for the property tax rate to remain the same, but city commissioners on Tuesday unanimously voted to increase the maximum rate in a move to give city officials more flexibility.

    City Manager Henry Schubert says the city needs to take a look at its operation.
  2. Allegiant Air reports $400 million in revenue for second quarter

    Allegiant Air CEO Maurice J. Gallagher Jr. | [Courtesy of Tony Jannus Aviation Society]
  3. Dade City's Wild Things touts cub encounters as conservation, but experts say they lead to too many tigers languishing in cages


    DADE CITY — A lifelong animal lover, Lisa Graham was intrigued when she saw photos on social media of friends cuddling and petting baby tigers at zoos.

    A tiger named Andy is seen at Big Cat Rescue in Tampa. Big Cat Rescue is a nonprofit sanctuary committed to humane treatment of rescued animals, often coming from exploitive for-profit operations. LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times

  4. Once close to death in Ukraine, sick girl finds hope in Tampa Bay

    Human Interest

    Everything was packed for Walt Disney World. Clothes for three nights. The pressurized air vest and pump that travel with her. The dress she would wear to meet Cinderella.

    Marina Khimko, 13, pauses for a moment during a walking exercise to test her prosthetic legs at a fitting appointment Dec. 7 at the Shriners Hospital for Children's Pediatric Orthotic and Prosthetic Services in Tampa.  [ANDRES LEIVA   |   Times]
  5. What you need to know for Thursday, July 27


    href=""> Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what you need to know today.

    Marina Khimko, now 14, pauses for a moment during a walking exercise to test her prosthetic legs at a fitting appointment at the Shriners Hospitals for Children's Pediatric Orthotic and Prosthetic Services in Tampa.  [ANDRES LEIVA | Times]