Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Supreme Court can't shake faithful skeptics on Obama citizenship

Roger Bredow’s Web site questions Obama’s citizen status.

Roger Bredow’s Web site questions Obama’s citizen status.

WASHINGTON — Roger Bredow insists he's no conspiracy theorist, no "tinfoil hat guy." Indeed, when he arrived outside the U.S. Supreme Court for a vigil Friday morning, he sported a red, white and blue Uncle Sam hat.

Inside, the nine justices were considering whether to take on a question that is roiling some conservative circles, and that has grown into something of an Internet cottage industry for folks like Bredow:

Is Barack Hussein Obama, by virtue of his birth, really eligible to be president of the United States?

Next week, the Electoral College will ratify the results of the November election. Imagine the consequences, Bredow says, if Obama is not supposed to be there. Any law Obama signed, any treaty, any action whatsoever he took while pretending to be president — invalid.

"I believe this decision is potentially bigger than Roe. It's the only time in history that a candidate has been elected and then the court has had to deal with this issue," Bredow said.

"It just infuriates me that a president is going to be put in office with so little transparency."

The case at hand was Donofrio vs. Wells, one of more than a dozen filed alleging that Obama is not a U.S. citizen. Leo C. Donofrio, an East Brunswick, N.J., lawyer, contends that Obama cannot be commander in chief because he is not a "natural born citizen." After losses at every level of the New Jersey courts, he turned to the U.S. Supreme Court. But Justice David Souter — known liberal — denied his appeal.

So Donofrio asked again. In mid November, Justice Clarence Thomas — known conservative —- agreed to bring it to the court's regular Friday conference, a secret meeting at which the justices decide which of the hundreds of appeals they will hear.

The slim chance the Supreme Court might act on this issue was enough reason for Bredow, 49, an affable Internet publisher, to drive 10 hours from Bethlehem, Ga.

He had received hundreds of thousands of hits and messages of encouragement while questioning Obama's citizenship on his Web page,, and in a video he posted on YouTube.

"People started pounding on me, saying, 'What are you going to do?' " Bredow said. "And I said, 'Well, okay, why don't we do a march on the 5th up in Washington?' And so here we are."

All 19 of them.

His fellow skeptics included a mom and her teen daughter from Williamsburg, Va., a retired Marine from Virginia, a pilot from South Florida, and Pam, a young black woman from Texas who said she never bought the story that Obama was from Hawaii. "I have never heard him say 'Aloha,' " she said.

• • •

One of the most remarkable things about Obama's historic run for the White House was that, through nearly two years of campaigning, he was dogged by the suggestion that he is somehow less than American.

As his inauguration nears, it's as if all the things designed to make the case — that he won't put his hand on his heart during the Pledge of Allegiance, that he is actually a Muslim, that he wouldn't wear a flag lapel pin — have congealed here, at the U.S. Supreme Court, to make the ultimate argument: He isn't an American at all.

The root of this accusation lies in persistent allegations, spread mainly through the Internet, that he has refused to show a valid birth certificate, suggesting he was born not in Hawaii, but in his father's native land, Kenya.

The Obama campaign has produced a Certification of Live Birth and the state of Hawaii has verified it. Several independent fact-checking sites, including (a publication of the St. Petersburg Times), and also have dismissed the rumors.

But they live on, in chain e-mails, fundraising pitches for right-wing groups like the U.S. Justice Foundation and lawsuits.

The most famous was filed by Phillip Berg, a Pennsylvania attorney who contends there's enough questions about Obama's birth at least to hold an inquiry, if not keep him from office.

That suit has been dismissed repeatedly, and the Supreme Court declined to hear it.

The Donofrio suit, by contrast, argues that even if Obama was born in Hawaii, he doesn't meet the Founding Father's definition of "natural born citizen" because his father was Kenyan.

Since Kenya was then under British rule, and Britain grants citizenship to children of its subjects, the suit argues that Obama has dual citizenship and "therefore, having been born with split and competing loyalties, candidate Obama is not a 'natural born citizen' as is required by the … Constitution"

Eugene Volokh, a constitutional law scholar at the University of California at Los Angeles, said the standard is set by the 14th Amendment, which says anyone born on U.S. soil is a citizen. It makes no differentiation for "natural born citizen."

• • •

Outside court, Bredow and a dwindling band of supporters faced the cold, awaiting a sign.

He says he voted for Obama, but turned on him for cozying up to Hillary Rodham Clinton, the nominee for secretary of state.

He and the others said it means nothing that questions about Obama's birthplace or citizenship have been debunked.

The mainstream media have ignored the issue, they say, investing none of the horsepower they harnessed to dig into the life of Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, Republican John McCain's running mate.

By 1 p.m., the justices had adjourned without saying anything about Donofrio.

• • •

The word came down midmorning Monday: denied. No explanation, no comments.

Bredow got the news back in Bethlehem. He spent a couple of hours reading the court's rules, in search of an explanation.

"Donofrio wasn't what you would call a constitutional lawyer. He might have just goofed something up on the application," Bredow suggested.

Members of Congress still could call for hearings, he said. And he has heard about some anonymous fraternity brothers in Hawaii on the hunt for Obama's birth records.

"According to these guys — I guess they have to protect themselves legally — but according to these guys, they went to all nine hospitals in Honolulu, and they have not found Obama's name," he said. "So there's still other little things floating around there."

Monday afternoon, he received some good news from the Supreme Court as well: Justice Antonin Scalia agreed to take another case challenging Obama's citizenship, Wrotnowski vs. Bysiewicz, to conference on Friday.

Wes Allison can be reached at or (202) 463-0577.

Supreme Court can't shake faithful skeptics on Obama citizenship 12/08/08 [Last modified: Monday, December 15, 2008 2:33pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. For starters: Rays vs. Angels, with Cobb leading the way


    Rays veteran RHP Alex Cobb had a lot to say Monday about the team needing to focus on getting past .500 and building a winning record.

    And after the disappointing 3-2 loss that …

  2. Tampa murder suspect told police he wanted to stop neo-Nazi roommates from committing acts of domestic terrorism


    TAMPA — After he admitted to shooting two roommates and led police to their dead bodies, Devon Arthurs said he committed the killings to prevent the pair from carrying out terrorist acts, according to a new court filing.

    Devon Arthurs, 18, told police  he shared neo-Nazi beliefs with his roommates, Jeremy Himmelman and Andrew Oneschuk, until he converted to Islam, according to a police report.
[Tampa Police]
  3. Pinellas School Board approves plan that aims to close achievement gap


    After months of behind-the-scenes negotiations, the Pinellas County School Board on Tuesday unanimously approved a plan that aims to tackle the achievement gap in 10 years and settles a long-running lawsuit over the education of …

    "I'm an optimist. I think this is going to work," Pinellas School Board member Linda Lerner said Tuesday after the board was presented with a plan that aims to settle a long-running lawsuit over the education of black students and close the achievement gap. The board voted 7-0 to approve the plan. [DIRK SHADD   |   Times]
  4. With big concerts approaching, Tampa Bay venues remain vigilant after Manchester attack

    Public Safety

    In the aftermath of an explosion that killed at least 22 people — including children — moments after a pop concert ended in England on Monday night, local venues are assuring the public that security will continue to be tight at the Tampa Bay area's upcoming big-ticket shows.

    Fans cross Himes Avenue in Tampa toward Raymond James Stadium before the start of Beyonce's Formation World Tour in Tampa on April 29, 2016. [LUIS SANTANA | Times]
  5. Kahwa Coffee to open second drive-thru store in St. Petersburg


    Kahwa Coffee will open its 12th location and fourth with a drive-thru in a former "farm store" in St. Petersburg.

    Kahwa Coffee will open its 12th location and fourth with a drive-thru in a former "farm store" in St. Petersburg.
[Times file photo]