Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Trayvon Martin case fuels intense political debate on left and right

Both sides have 24-hour cable channels, websites and Twitter armies that push their narrative on what happened in the Trayvon Martin shooting.

Both sides have 24-hour cable channels, websites and Twitter armies that push their narrative on what happened in the Trayvon Martin shooting.

From suspect to victim to cultural symbol, Trayvon Martin has metamorphosed into a political point of departure over race.

When President Barack Obama spoke about how his son could have looked like the 17-year-old, his white Republican rivals quickly accused him of being racially divisive.

When Gov. Rick Scott established a task force to investigate the "stand your ground" gun law connected to Martin's shooting, a state Democratic leader rebuked him for wanting to wait until the case is adjudicated.

Liberal and left-leaning media have taken up Martin's case, with calls to arrest his shooter, George Zimmerman. Conservative and right-leaning media have called for a get-the-facts first approach, while some have published images of Martin portraying him as a thug.

Groups from the NAACP to the National Council of La Raza, to white and black supremacist groups, have entered — or been drawn into — the political fray as well.

"It's campaign time, and unfortunately, it has come to that. But that's what we get these days, unfortunately," said Lt. Gov. Jennifer Carroll, the only elected black Republican in Florida's Capitol.

Carroll, who's chairing Gov. Scott's task force on stand your ground, said the group needs to take its time and not interfere with the investigation. She also wants to avoid partisan and racial politics.

But Carroll noted that race infuses the case and our justice system, especially with the high-incarceration rates of African-Americans. But she still wanted to focus on whether the state's stand your ground law, authorizing the use of deadly force, needs to be tweaked. The National Rifle Association is sure to fight that, while gun-control advocates are trying to get the law stripped from the books.

The Florida Senate's incoming Democratic leader, Chris Smith, criticized the decision by Scott and Carroll to hold off on investigating the law. But Carroll said the task force needs time to gather facts for the "emotional" and increasingly partisan case.

The politics won't go away.

"Once the story went national, we first dealt with the tragedy but very quickly you saw political questions starting to be asked,'' said James B. Peterson, a professor of Africana Studies and associate professor of English at Lehigh University in Pennsylvania. "Race is a powerful political tool.''

"Immediately, you have the right and left at the table. It's unfortunate that this case has become such a hotbed. Both sides can easily go back to their stock characters,'' he said. "On the left, it's marching and protesting and talk about institutional racism. On the right, it's talk about rushing to judgment and accusations of race-baiting. The irony is both sides are demanding justice.''

And both sides have 24-hour cable channels, websites and Twitter armies that push their narrative about what happened.

State Rep. Alan Williams, D-Tallahassee, has changed his Twitter avatar to depict him wearing the type of hoodie sweatshirt the unarmed Martin wore on his last night. U.S. Rep. Bobby Rush, D-Ill., wore a hoodie on the House floor, prompting Florida's highest-profile black Republican, U.S. Rep. Allen West, to criticize the action as "gimmickry."

Meantime, the Internet's atwitter over the decision of the Daily Caller, a conservative website, to obtain and publish apparent tweets from the teen's now-closed Twitter account. The messages depict fairly typical rap-fueled, sex-obsessed misogynistic lingo common to urban and suburban youth in Miami Gardens.

A New York Times blogger criticized the Daily Caller and others for "cherry picking" images about Martin to make him seem more threatening. It failed to mention that the paper's liberal columnist Charles Blow has said little of Martin's school suspensions and his dalliance with pot in favor of discussing his "cherubic" countenance.

When the nation's first black president said, "If I had a son, he'd look like Trayvon," the political floodgates over race broke open again in the presidential election.

"Is the president suggesting if it had been a white who had been shot, that would be okay because it wouldn't look like him?" Fox News Channel personality Sean Hannity wondered. "That's just nonsense. I mean, dividing this country up, it is a tragedy this young man was shot."

Republican presidential candidates Rick Santorum and Newt Gingrich echoed the sentiments.

In Florida, Lt. Gov. Carroll can personally relate to having a child who looks like Martin. She has two grown sons and a daughter, and she pointedly declined to criticize the president.

"That's his personal interpretation and how he feels. So that's nobody else's business to interpret what he is saying," Carroll said at an event with her 25-year-old son Nolan Carroll, a Miami Dolphins defensive back.

"As old as Nolan is, I still call him. Are you home safe? It's night time, I'm going to sleep," said Carroll, who initially didn't want her son to play football as a kid.

But now that her son plays professional football, how can she worry?

"Even at that," she says. She still calls and asks, "Are you home?"

Miami Herald staff writer Audra D.S. Burch contributed to this report.

Trayvon Martin case fuels intense political debate on left and right 04/01/12 [Last modified: Wednesday, April 4, 2012 3:20pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Romano: Why flood insurance might not be enough to save your home

    Local Government

    Irma is gone, and Maria never came.

    And yet this is as good a time as any to worry.

  2. Tampa's streetcar system looks to expand north through downtown


    TAMPA — The TECO Line Streetcar system that runs from Ybor City to the Channel District could be extended north through downtown all the way to Tampa Heights, according to the latest update of a $1.7 million study aimed at expanding the streetcar system.

    Riders take in the last few stops of the streetcar route in Ybor City during the tenth anniversary celebration of the TECO line streetcar system in Tampa in 2012. Now officials are looking for ways to expand the service north through downtown to Tampa Heights. [EVE EDELHEIT  |  Times]
  3. Interview: Steve Martin, Martin Short bringing 'best version' of their show back to St. Petersburg


    Hot celebrity-spotting tip: Stop by the Salvador Dalí Museum on Jan. 19. You might catch a glimpse of Steve Martin.

    Steve Martin, left, and Martin Short will bring “An Evening You Will Forget for the Rest of Your Life” to the Mahaffey Theater on Jan. 19.
  4. Report: Well-being of black and Hispanic children continues to lag in Florida


    Despite making progress in health care access and parental employment, Florida has not improved its poverty rate for children over the past five years, a newly released national report shows.

    Students line up in the courtyard at predominantly black Lakewood Elementary in St. Petersburg. A new report by the Annie E. Casey Foundation finds that Florida ranks 28th in the nation on an index that measures the well-being of black children. [DIRK SHADD   |   Times]
  5. Second lady Karen Pence to speak at Tampa art therapy summit


    TAMPA — Second lady Karen Pence will visit The David A. Straz Jr. Center for the Performing Arts on Tuesday to address advocates of art therapy programs for military members and families.