Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PolitiFact Florida | Tampa Bay Times

PolitiFact Florida: Rick Scott misrepresents the bipartisan origins of Obamacare

Donald Trump's White House win gave Florida Gov. Rick Scott a powerful ally in his fight against Obamacare.

The former hospital executive reiterated his 2010 campaign pledge to fight for repeal of the federal health care law in a recent USA Today op-ed.

"Other than President Obama and a few stragglers, everyone now realizes that Obamacare was a terrible notion," Scott wrote. "It was sold on a lie. It was invented by liberal academic theorists who have no interaction with real families and businesses, and therefore it doesn't work."

Scott's piece misleads readers about the origins of the Affordable Care Act of 2010. It is based on ideas from not just Democrats, but also Republicans.

"Scott's comment is so sweeping that it's hard for it to be anything other than an exaggeration," said Gail Wilensky, who ran Medicare and Medicaid under President George H.W. Bush.

The "liberal academic theorists" in question, Scott's spokeswoman said, are MIT economist Jonathan Gruber, Harvard economist David Cutler and Ezekiel Emanuel, who is now chairman of the Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy at the University of Pennsylvania.

We interviewed all three about their role in the health care law and with President Barack Obama.

Gruber developed the economic model for the law, earning him the most media attention of the three. He was instrumental in helping Massachusetts create its law, and the federal government contracted with Gruber to provide technical assistance.

The national law was patterned after the Massachusetts version. Both require everyone to have health insurance or pay a penalty, leave the current insurance system in place, and expand coverage for the uninsured through subsidies or Medicaid.

Media reports often refer to Gruber as the "architect" of the Affordable Care Act, but others who worked on the legislation dispute that characterization. Gruber's involvement with his economic model was important, but he didn't determine what policies made the cut, said John McDonough, a Harvard health policy professor who was a senior adviser to the Senate Health and Education Committee when the law was written.

As for Cutler, he appears to have had the least to do with the law. Scott's spokeswoman pointed to an October article in Politico referring to him as a "key architect" of Obamacare. But most articles we found described him as a health care adviser on Obama's 2008 campaign and an advocate of the law.

Cutler told us that he did speak with members of the Obama administration, Congress and interest groups, but "I did not serve in the administration and never wrote a line of the ACA."

Emanuel was more involved in the law as a paid special adviser for health policy to the director of the federal Office of Management and Budget from 2009 to 2011.

Emanuel now works at the University of Pennsylvania, but he wasn't working in academia while he worked for OMB. (His brother Rahm was Obama's former chief of staff.)

Emanuel worked on a lot of the details of the bill, he said, including subsidy levels.

Bipartisan roots

The fact that two of the three experts Scott had in mind have ties to the law does not change the inaccuracy of his point.

The backbone of Obamacare started forming amid earlier attempts to overhaul the health system, including by Bill and Hillary Clinton.

Their proposal for universal health care prompted Republicans to come up with an alternative in 1993. While as a party Republican senators never reached consensus, Republican Sen. John Chafee of Rhode Island introduced a bill with 18 Republican co-sponsors (although some later withdrew) and two Democrats as co-sponsors.

Chafee's bill had similarities to Obamacare. It included an individual mandate, created purchasing pools, standardized benefits, vouchers for the poor and a ban on denying coverage due to pre-existing conditions.

Another key player was the conservative Heritage Foundation, which advocated for health insurance exchanges including when Massachusetts, led by a Democratic Legislature and Republican Gov. Mitt Romney, crafted its own law in 2006.

Jonathan Oberlander, a health care policy specialist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, said some, but definitely not all, of the federal health law's creators were liberal academics.

"There were many cooks in this kitchen and these ideas were generated over a long period over time," he said. "In many respects the ACA's design and some of its major policies embodied what used to be core tenets of GOP philosophy on health care."

Scott's statement contains an element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression. We rate the claim Mostly False.

Edited for print. Read the full version at PolitiFact.com/florida.

The statement

Obamacare "was invented by liberal academic theorists."

Gov. Rick Scott, Nov. 30, in an op-ed in USA Today

The ruling

PolitiFact ruling: Mostly False Scott cherry-picked three advisers supportive of the law with Obama ties. He ignores that many people over several decades from both parties developed the ideas for what would eventually become Obamacare, including the contributions of Republican Mitt Romney, the former Massachusetts governor. We rate the statement Mostly False.



The statement

Obamacare "was invented by liberal academic theorists."

Gov. Rick Scott, Nov. 30, in an op-ed in USA Today

The ruling

PolitiFact ruling: Mostly False Scott cherry-picked three advisers supportive of the law with Obama ties. He ignores that many people over several decades from both parties developed the ideas for what would eventually become Obamacare, including the contributions of Republican Mitt Romney, the former Massachusetts governor. We rate the statement Mostly False.

PolitiFact Florida: Rick Scott misrepresents the bipartisan origins of Obamacare 12/11/16 [Last modified: Sunday, December 11, 2016 6:49pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Trump: Not 'that far off' from passing health overhaul

    National

    WASHINGTON — Making a final push, President Donald Trump said he doesn't think congressional Republicans are "that far off" on a health overhaul to replace "the dead carcass of Obamacare." Expressing frustration, he complained about "the level of hostility" in government and wondered why both parties can't work …

    President Donald Trump speaks during a bill signing event for the "Department of Veterans Affairs Accountability and Whistleblower Protection Act of 2017" in the East Room of the White House, Friday, June 23, 2017, in Washington. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci) DCEV208
  2. Erin Andrews, ex-NHL player Jarret Stoll marry in Montana

    Celebrities

    NEW YORK — Sportscaster Erin Andrews and former NHL player Jarret Stoll have tied the knot.

    FILE - In this Oct. 30, 2016 file photo, Fox Sports broadcaster Erin Andrews, left, speaks with Atlanta Falcons wide receiver Julio Jones after an NFL football game against the Green Bay Packers in Atlanta. Jennifer Allen, a publicist for Andrews, confirms Sunday, June 25, 2017, that the 38-year-old Fox Sports sideline reporter and ???‚??“Dancing with the Stars???‚?? co-host married the 35-year-old Stoll over the weekend.  (AP Photo/David Goldman, File) NYSP103
  3. Amid FBI probe of Tallahassee, Gillum says GOP trying to 'put as much dirt on me as they can'

    Blogs

    Tallahassee mayor and candidate for governor Andrew Gillum might like his supporters to think a federal investigation into development deals in his city is political – but …

    Andrew Gillum
  4. Tampa pedestrian struck, killed near Temple Terrace

    Accidents

    A Tampa woman was killed Saturday night after she was hit by a car while walking near Temple Terrace.

  5. Snell to rejoin rotation Wednesday

    Blogs