Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PolitiFact.com | Tampa Bay Times

PolitiFact: Ted Cruz off the mark in attacking Trump on economy, Planned Parenthood

GOP presidential hopeful Ted Cruz of Texas criticized rival Donald Trump on taxes and Planned Parenthood.

New York Times

GOP presidential hopeful Ted Cruz of Texas criticized rival Donald Trump on taxes and Planned Parenthood.

Sen. Ted Cruz is using this week's pivotal Indiana primary to make a last stand of sorts against Republican presidential front-runner Donald Trump.

Cruz trails Trump by more than 400 delegates and is unable to win a majority of delegates prior to the GOP convention. Cruz's best hope is to keep Trump from hitting that delegate mark himself, and Indiana presents a favorable battleground.

In interviews that aired Sunday on NBC's Meet the Press and ABC's This Week, Cruz dodged questions about what happens if he loses in Indiana on Tuesday.

But he said the choice should be simple for Indiana Republican voters.

Cruz told NBC's Chuck Todd that Trump's "only economic agenda is imposing massive taxes on the American people with a 40 percent tax hike of a giant tariff." He also accused Trump of being a clone of Democratic presidential front-runner Hillary Clinton.

"I believe if the Republican Party nominates Donald Trump we will lose to Hillary, because when we offer Democrat-lite, Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton on the ballot, they support the same social policy, they support the same economic policy," Cruz said.

"Donald can't criticize Hillary Clinton on Planned Parenthood, because he agrees with her. They both say it's terrific and — and that it should keep taxpayer funding," he added.

We at PolitiFact decided to fact-check Cruz's claims about Trump's economic plan and Trump's position on Planned Parenthood.

Economic agenda

Cruz said on Meet the Press that his top priority will be "bringing jobs back to America, bringing manufacturing jobs back to Indiana, raising wages across this country."

He then said Trump's "only economic agenda is imposing massive taxes on the American people with a 40 percent tax hike of a giant tariff. That would send us into a recession. It would drive jobs overseas. It would kill small businesses."

Cruz's claim about Trump's economic agenda rates Half True.

First, Trump has outlined a few other economic proposals beyond tariffs like declaring China a currency manipulator, upholding intellectual property law, ending China's export subsidies and lowering the corporate tax rate to incentivize American companies to stay at home. He has also suggested renegotiating or pulling out of the North American Free Trade Agreement, and stopping the Trans-Pacific Partnership.

But Cruz has a point that Trump has talked at length about imposing tariffs on imported goods as a remedy for trade imbalances and lost American jobs. He has specified a 35 percent tariff on some goods coming from Mexico and a 45 percent tax on all Chinese products, which he said in the last Republican debate is a "threat" that he'd only enact it if "they don't follow the rules."

Trump's tariff proposals have been called "uneducated" and "worrisome" and many economists (though not all) say they would hurt Americans. However, Cruz may be overstating the impact.

"The biggest losers would be U.S. consumers and companies," said Scott Lincicome, an international trade law and policy expert at the libertarian Cato Institute.

Tariffs at the level Trump is suggesting would cause prices of cheap products like air conditioners and intermediate goods like auto parts to soar and could kill millions of U.S. jobs. But as some of the costs would be absorbed by Chinese and Mexican exporters, a 40 percent tariff doesn't translate directly into a 40 percent tax hike.

"You would have to do some analysis to determine how much of a tax hike it is, but it is probably significantly less than 40 percent," said Joel Trachtman, a trade law specialist at the University of Maryland.

Planned Parenthood

Cruz also said that Trump and Clinton have the same position when it comes to Planned Parenthood. "They both say it's terrific and — and that it should keep taxpayer funding," Cruz claimed.

That rates Mostly False.

There's no question about Clinton's support for Planned Parenthood. Throughout the campaign, she has frequently attacked Republicans' pledge to defund the organization. And Planned Parenthood endorsed Clinton in July, its first-ever presidential primary endorsement.

"I am not only against defunding Planned Parenthood, but I would like to see Planned Parenthood even get more funding," Clinton told Fusion in January.

Trump's position is more nuanced.

Regarding abortion generally, Trump has several times raised both Republicans' and Democrats' eyebrows by changing position. Today, Trump says he's antiabortion.

As it pertains to Planned Parenthood, Trump has been fairly consistent since October 2015. He has praised some of the work the organization does but not with respect to abortion services.

Trump has said Congress should stop providing the group with federal funding as long as it provides abortions.

"Planned Parenthood does a lot of good jobs, a really good job in a lot of different areas. But not on abortion. So I'm not going to fund it if it's doing the abortion. I am not going to fund it," Trump said in February.

"Millions of women have been helped by Planned Parenthood," Trump said in March. "But we're not going to allow, and we're not going to fund, as long as you have the abortion going on at Planned Parenthood, and we understand that and I've said it loud and clear."

Aaron Sharockman contributed to this report. Read the full fact-checks at PolitiFact.com.

The statement

Says both Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton say Planned Parenthood is "terrific ... and that it should keep taxpayer funding."

Ted Cruz, on "Meet the Press"

The ruling PolitiFact ruling: Mostly False

Trump and Clinton seem to agree that Planned Parenthood does some positive work as it pertains to things like cancer prevention. However, Clinton supports their abortion services, and Trump does not. He thinks Planned Parenthood should not receive taxpayer dollars as long as they provide abortions. We rate Cruz's claim Mostly False.

The statement

Says Donald Trump's "only economic agenda is imposing massive taxes on the American people with a 40 percent tax hike of a giant tariff."

Ted Cruz, on "Meet the Press"

The ruling PolitiFact ruling: Mostly False

Tariffs are not Trump's "only" economic proposal. But Trump has trumpeted taxing Mexican and Chinese imports by 35 and 45 percent respectively. Most economists agree that American consumers and manufactures would bear some of the cost of these tariffs, though it's not entirely clear if prices would increase by 40 percent, as Cruz says. We rate this claim Half True.

PolitiFact: Ted Cruz off the mark in attacking Trump on economy, Planned Parenthood 05/01/16 [Last modified: Sunday, May 1, 2016 10:47pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. After fraught debate, Trump to disclose new Afghanistan plan

    War

    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump will unveil his updated Afghanistan policy Monday night in a rare, prime-time address to a nation that broadly shares his pessimism about American involvement in the 16-year conflict. Although he may send a few thousand more troops, there are no signs of a major shift in …

    U.S. soldiers patrol the perimeter of a weapons cache near the U.S. military base in Bagram, Afghanistan in 2003. Sixteen years of U.S. warfare in Afghanistan have left the insurgents as strong as ever and the nation's future precarious. Facing a quagmire, President Donald Trump on Monday will outline his strategy for a country that has historically snared great powers and defied easy solutions.  [Associated Press (2003)]
  2. Trial begins for man accused of threatening to kill Tampa federal judge

    Criminal

    TAMPA — Jason Jerome Springer was in jail awaiting trial on a firearms charge when he heard inmates talking about a case that had made the news.

    Jason Jerome Springer, 39, is accused of threatening to kill a U.S. District Judge Elizabeth Kovachevich, according to a federal indictment.  |Hernando County Sheriff's Office photo]
  3. Editorial: Tampa Electric customers should not pay for utility's fatal misjudgments

    Editorials

    There will be financial fallout from the terrible miscalculations that resulted in five workers being killed in June at Tampa Electric's Big Bend Power Station. State and federal regulators should ensure those costs are borne by the company's shareholders, not its customers. Monetary considerations will not begin to …

    LUIS SANTANA   |   Times
There will be financial fallout from the terrible miscalculations that resulted in five workers being killed in June at Tampa Electric's Big Bend Power Station. State and federal regulators should ensure those costs are borne by the company's shareholders, not its customers.
  4. Superior Uniform acquires Los Angeles-based PublicIdentity

    Corporate

    SEMINOLE — A subsidiary of Seminole-based Superior Uniform Group has acquired Los Angeles-based branded merchandise company PublicIdentity Inc.

    Superior Uniform Group CEO Michael Benstock
[Courtesy of Superior Uniform Group]
  5. Money is the issue as Hillsborough strains to fix school air conditioners

    K12

    TAMPA — With more than 200 repair requests tumbling in every day, school officials in Hillsborough County are broadening their circle of air conditioning mechanics as they struggle to control a debilitating cycle of breakdowns and sweltering classrooms.

    Hillsborough school officials want to expand the number of contractors who work on broken school air conditioning systems. But it all gets rolled into a workload that has increased by 40 percent since 2011. "With no increase in budget, no increase in equipment and no increase in manpower, and as the equipment gets older and needs more maintenance, this is going to continue to grow," said Robert Weggman, general manager of maintenance." [iStockphoto.com
]