Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Romano: Florida's abortion con artists put on notice by Supreme Court

The full Supreme Court ruling on a Texas abortion case is now available online in 107 pages filled with formal language and meticulous detail.

The shorthand version reads something like this:

Texas lied.

When legislators in the Lone Star State said they were trying to make the world safer and better for women seeking abortions, they were actually doing the opposite.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, in a concurring opinion, went so far as to warn other states that the court will not look kindly on similar abortion laws built on bogus health claims.

And why is Ginsburg's brief interjection important?

Because Florida lied, too.

State legislators have been slowly dancing around the edges of Roe vs. Wade for several years, passing bills they say benefit women but clearly appear to be politically motivated.

A law requiring a 24-hour waiting period was temporarily suspended by the Florida Supreme Court in April, and a challenge to another law that changes the definition of a pregnancy's first trimester, along with other provisions, will be heard in a district court Wednesday.

And you might want to pay attention to that case.

Because, if the courts don't intervene, Florida will continue to see more laws that make it increasingly difficult to obtain an abortion. That might not sound like a bad thing to someone opposed to abortion, but these laws also include a lot of collateral damage.

For example, a bill signed earlier this year by Gov. Rick Scott restricts state funding for clinics that provide abortions. Since the state already had a law banning funding for the actual abortion, this new law would basically eliminate funding for procedures like cancer screenings, vasectomies or HIV tests.

Who could possibly think that's a good idea?

Apparently, most of the state Senate and House who voted for the bill, including every GOP lawmaker around here.

Essentially what they're doing is playing a glorified shell game. Politicians distract your attention with dubious claims, and then slip in an unnecessarily restrictive law.

What the Supreme Court ruled in the Texas case was the arguments for oversight were vastly overblown, and the practical realities were extremely chilling.

"Many medical procedures, including childbirth, are far more dangerous to patients, yet are not subject to … (hospital) requirements,'' Ginsburg wrote. "When a state severely limits access to safe and legal procedures, women in desperate circumstances may resort to unlicensed rogue practitioners.''

The Florida laws are similar in spirit, but not identical to the Texas laws swatted aside by the Supreme Court on Monday. That means the Florida laws are in serious trouble, but not necessarily doomed.

Justices cited statistics showing that half the abortion clinics in Texas were forced to shut down because of the laws, leading to overcrowding, delays and lengthy commutes for women in rural communities. Basically, the laws led to more dangerous conditions.

Since Florida laws have yet to go into effect, it may be more difficult to prove they will have the opposite effect of their supposed intentions.

"The Texas clinics were decimated, so it was a pretty easy case from the standpoint of creating an undue burden on women," said Stetson University law professor Louis Virelli. "If you had asked me what was the best-case scenario for the clinics in Florida, it would have been this exact decision.

"But something to keep an eye on is that variable of meeting the standard of an undue burden."

It's up to judges to parse the constitutionality and ramifications of the laws passed in the Legislature. It's up to you and me to decide whether the politicians we send to represent us in Tallahassee are being honest and sincere.

In this case, I have no problem saying Florida lied.

Romano: Florida's abortion con artists put on notice by Supreme Court 06/27/16 [Last modified: Monday, June 27, 2016 9:12pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. NATO rolls out the red carpet, buffs its image for Trump


    BRUSSELS — NATO is not only rolling out the red carpet for U.S. President Donald Trump in Brussels Thursday, the military alliance — which Trump once declared obsolete — has been busy repackaging its image and is ready to unveil a new headquarters worth more than 1 billion euros.

    U.S. President Donald Trump and his wife Melania arrive at Fiumicino's Leonardo Da Vinci International airport, near Rome, Tuesday, May 23, 2017. Trump is in Italy for a two day visit, including a meeting with Pope Francis at the Vatican, ahead of his participation in a NATO summit in Brussels on Thursday. [Associated Press]
  2. Taiwan becomes first in Asia to recognize same-sex marriage


    TAIPEI, Taiwan — In a first for Asia, Taiwan's Constitutional Court ruled in favor of same-sex marriage on Wednesday, punctuating a yearslong campaign by advocates for gay rights in one of the continent's most liberal democracies.

    Same-sex marriage supporters wave rainbow Taiwan flags after the Constitutional Court ruled in favor of same-sex marriage outside the Legislative Yuan in Taipei, Taiwan, Wednesday, May 24, 2017. Taiwan's Constitutional Court ruled in favor of same-sex marriage on Wednesday, making the island the first place in Asia to recognize gay unions. [Associated Press]
  3. 'Top Gun' sequel? Tom Cruise says it starts filming soon


    Tom Cruise is once again feeling the need for speed.

    Tom Cruise starred in "Top Gun" in 1986, and said he'll begin work on a sequel within the next year.
  4. Trump presents Pope Francis with sculpture made by Florida artist


    An artist from Stuart, Florida, made a bronze sculpture that President Trump presented today to Pope Francis.

    The artist and his work
  5. What could have been the game-winning blast turned into a long single for Colby Rasmus.