Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Romano: Hillsborough County is the nation's no-partisan zone

Turns out, Main Street USA is not just a marketing ploy at Disney parks.

It exists a few blocks from the neighborhood where they've rolled Cuban cigars for more than a century. It's near a bay, close to strawberry fields and down the road from a collection of strip clubs.

It looks diverse, it sounds moderate and it feels increasingly relevant.

So where is Main Street USA?

Apparently, somewhere in Tampa.

How else would you explain Hillsborough County's uncanny ability to reflect the mood of America when it comes to presidential elections? Hillsborough is not reliably Republican, nor reliably Democratic.

It is reliably accurate.

In 21 of the last 22 presidential elections, Hillsborough has supported the candidate who has gone on to win.

That means Hillsborough went for John F. Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson before pivoting to two terms of Richard Nixon. It means Hillsborough believed in George W. Bush's conservative views for eight years before turning its fortunes over to Barack Obama's progressive vision for the next eight years.

Of the 40 most populous counties in the nation, none can match Hillsborough's knack of discerning which candidate, and which party, has tapped into the nation's consciousness since 1928.

Question: Which election did Hillsborough misfire on?

(We'll get to that later.)

Better question: What makes Hillsborough unique?

The simple, and accurate, answer is the county's diverse demographics. Nearly 16 percent of the county's voters are African-American, and nearly 17 percent are Hispanic. Non-whites, overall, make up more than 40 percent of the electorate in Hillsborough.

But that doesn't explain everything. Other markets have a similar mix of Democrats in the urban core, and Republicans in the suburbs.

What makes Hillsborough different is a lack of roots. There is no generational stronghold because the county continues to grow and change every year. The number of votes in Hillsborough increased nearly 500 percent from 1960 to 2012. And a diverse influx contributes to a diversity of views.

In this case, the lack of an identity actually is an identity.

"I don't know if it's still accurate, but it certainly was for a lot of years, other than tropical fish, the second-highest volume of cargo going out of (Tampa International Airport) is bodies,'' said Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn. "That tells you if someone is going home to be buried, this is not their original home.''

That transient nature translates to unpredictability. Residents are less ideological and more pragmatic when it comes to elections, Buckhorn said. Voters are more willing to listen to candidates than follow party policies.

"Literally, the road to the White House runs through Tampa,'' Buckhorn said. "If you can win here, you can win anywhere in the country.''

(And, in case you're still wondering, Hillsborough's only miss was voting for George H.W. Bush instead of Bill Clinton in 1992. Ross Perot getting 20 percent of the vote might have had something to do with that.)

Voter registration numbers say Hillsborough leans left, but the majority of county commissioners veer right. So what is the county's true nature? Apparently, on either side of Main Street.

Times researcher John Martin contributed to this column.

Romano: Hillsborough County is the nation's no-partisan zone 11/05/16 [Last modified: Friday, November 4, 2016 7:04pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. The Killers coming to Hard Rock Live in Orlando


    They're reliable festival headliners, and they're about to embark on a North American arena tour.

    The KIllers
  2. Back to School 2017: What you need to know


    With the start of classes less than three weeks away, the Tampa Bay Times' back-to-school special report debuts today.

    The Times' annual back-to-school coverage debuts today with information families can use to start the new year. [Times files]
  3. Hillsborough and Pinellas to keep park entry fees, while Pasco makes them free again

    Local Government

    One thing stands between Mark Crawford and the mackerel schooling in the topaz saltwater around the pier at Fort De Soto Park: a toll booth. And even if the lady inside is as sweet as orange blossom honey, she still wants his five dollars.

    Jermaine Ferguson takes the $5 entry fee from a visitor at Fort De Soto Park on Wednesday. Pasco County has done away with recession era park fees, but Hillsborough and Pinellas county plan to continue to charge people to use parks like Fort De Soto and Lettuce Lake Park. LARA CERRI   |   Times

  4. Oldsmar promotes Al Braithwaite to city manager

    Local Government

    OLDSMAR — He's a self-proclaimed "numbers guy,'' who holds a master's degree in public administration from the University of South Florida. Al Braithwaite is also a basketball fan who played hoops at Eckerd College while earning his bachelor's degree in management with a minor in finance, and he is a native New …

    Al Braithwaite  has 18 years of experience with Oldsmar City Hall.
  5. Senate Obamacare effort dies; Rubio in favor of repeal, Nelson against


    WASHINGTON - The Senate Republican effort to Obamacare failed early Friday, with John McCain providing a decisive vote.

    The Senate vote