Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Court signals doubt on tax 'swap' ballot item

TALLAHASSEE — The Florida Supreme Court on Wednesday strongly signaled it would permanently remove a property tax "swap" from the November ballot.

It also cast doubt on two other controversial ballot questions related to school vouchers. Rulings are expected by Friday so the statewide ballot can be finalized.

The property tax proposal, known as Amendment 5, was discarded by a Circuit Court judge last month on the grounds that it could mislead voters into thinking school funding would be guaranteed after the first year the plan would take effect, 2010-11.

But that guarantee is good for the first year only. "It's not a lifetime warranty, it's a limited warranty," Justice Charles Wells said.

After that, the Legislature would have to come up with a way to replace revenue lost by eliminating most school property taxes, for an average property tax cut of 25 percent. Options include a 1-cent sales tax increase.

"As I'm going to vote, I read this and I say, 'Well, why shouldn't I do this?' " said Justice Harry Lee Anstead. "Then I find out the fine print says they only have to do that for one year. After that, we have a problem. Why isn't that misleading?"

Mark Herron, one of the lawyers defending the measure, called the ballot title a "caption" and said voters would read it along with the 75-word summary to grasp the idea.

"We're not hiding the ball here," Herron asserted. "This amendment does exactly that: It eliminates and it replaces."

Proponents have argued that the Legislature would need flexibility to adjust funding as school populations change. They point to assurances from lawmakers that schools will be fully funded, something critics say is not enough.

Amendment 5 was placed on the ballot this spring by the Taxation and Budget Reform Commission, which meets every 20 years.

While the plan has gotten the most attention, the commission also stirred controversy by passing plans to amend the state Constitution to allow for private-school vouchers.

Those amendments, 7 and 9, were also before the Supreme Court on Wednesday and drew equal skepticism from justices, mostly about whether the commission had authority to veer past issues dealing with taxes and the budget.

Amendment 7 would repeal a constitutional ban on state financial aid to churches and religious organizations. Amendment 9 would remove language from the state Constitution that the Florida Supreme Court used in 2006 to bar then-Gov. Jeb Bush's Opportunity Scholarship program. The measure also has language requiring that 65 percent of school budgets be spent in the classroom.

The same Circuit Court judge who threw out Amendment 5 ruled that Amendments 7 and 9 could stay on the ballot. That drew an appeal from a coalition of school and religious groups concerned about a breakdown in the separation of church and state.

Though the ballot title for Amendment 7 — dealing with "religious freedom" — was not under challenge, Justice Barbara Pariente called it "about as far afield as you can get" from the taxation commission's duties.

Likewise, Justice Anstead questioned how the 65 percent provision fit with the commission's duties. If the authority to direct expenditures was taken too broadly, he asked, why couldn't the commission propose 100,000 new police officers?

But Scott Makar, the state solicitor general, argued that the commission has a "broad and remedial" purpose and that voucher amendments were germane.

"In the end," he said, "it's a funding issue."

Court signals doubt on tax 'swap' ballot item 09/03/08 [Last modified: Wednesday, September 3, 2008 2:22pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. PolitiFact: Fact-checking Samantha Bee on Florida felonies

    State Roundup

    Comedian Samantha Bee traveled to Florida, where she says "retirees and democracy go to die," to shed light on how the state makes it difficult for felons to regain the right to vote.

    Samantha Bee hosts Full Frontal with Samantha Bee on TBS. Bee portrayed some of Florida’s felonies as not so serious on her show.
  2. For some, Memorial Day comes around more than just once a year

    Military

    ST. PETERSBURG — It is shortly before nine on a Friday morning, and the heat is already approaching unbearable levels at Bay Pines National Cemetery.

    Iles carefully digs up the St. Augustine grass so that it will continue to grow when it is placed back on the gravesite. He tries not to disturb the root base.
  3. State budget uncertainty has school districts 'very concerned'

    K12

    While waiting for Gov. Rick Scott to approve or veto the Legislature's education budget, the people in charge of school district checkbooks are trying hard to find a bottom line.

    It has not been easy.

    The unsettled nature of Florida’s education budget has left school districts with questions about how they will make ends meet next year. [iStockphoto.com]
  4. Ernest Hooper: Removing Confederate symbols doesn't eliminate persistent mindset

    Human Interest

    The debate has begun about removing a Confederate statue from outside the Hillsborough County Courthouse, and its removal is long overdue.

    Robert E. Lee Elementary, 305 E. Columbus Drive in Tampa, originally opened its doors in the early 1910s as the Michigan Avenue Grammar School. [Times file]
  5. What you need to know for Monday, May 29

    News

    Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what you need to know today.

    In the weeks before Memorial Day, cemetery caretaker Gary Iles and the staff at Bay Pines National Cemetery are busy preparing the sprawling property for the annual ceremony honoring the fallen. Iles, an Army veteran who started out as a volunteer at Bay Pines, says working at the cemetery is a way for him to continue serving those who died for their country. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]