Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Dueling bills on teaching of evolution may not survive

TALLAHASSEE — The Florida Legislature may not weigh in on the state's new standards for teaching evolution after all.

Chalk it up to a difference of words between two lawmakers' bills, and the reality that there might not be enough time left this session to negotiate a compromise.

The House on Monday voted 71-43 for a controversial evolution bill (HB 1483) that adds to required public school curriculum a "scientific critical analysis" of the theory of evolution.

But the Senate rejected similar language last week, instead passing Brandon Republican Sen. Ronda Storms' "Evolution Academic Freedom Act," a more broadly worded bill (SB 2692) that spells out protections for teachers and students who question evolution.

Storms' bill expressly says that it "does not promote any religious doctrine."

And Rep. Alan Hays, R-Umatilla, insists his legislation "has nothing to do with religion."

"A true scientist is searching for the truth, and that's what we should be encouraging," Hays said. "This bill does not promote the teaching of religion."

But critics say that if passed into law, it would open the door for the teaching of religious theories like creationism and intelligent design.

Critics also argue the legislation isn't necessary because science standards inherently encourage critical thinking and discussion.

"This is silly legislation," said Rep. Keith Fitzgerald, D-Sarasota. "It corrects a problem that does not exist. It's the nature of science that all theories are subject to critical analysis."

But Monday's lengthy debate on the House floor might have been all for naught anyway.

Legislative procedure requires that the House bill now go back to the Senate for consideration.

Unless lawmakers there accept it, the bill cannot go to the governor to sign into law.

Storms said Monday that she knows her chamber won't pass Hays' proposal, so she will ask the House to consider and vote on her version.

"I have no choice," she said. "And I believe in miracles."

Hays said he'll try to get Storms' bill heard before session ends Friday, but he conceded it will take "a lot of lifting."

Rep. Ellyn Bogdanoff, House majority whip, said there is "not much appetite" in the House for Storms' proposal.

"I think we made our position clear already," she said. "The members are uncomfortable with the Senate version."

Shannon Colavecchio-Van Sickler
can be reached at or (850) 224-7263.

Dueling bills on teaching of evolution may not survive 04/28/08 [Last modified: Sunday, May 4, 2008 11:39am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Pinellas receives two charter school applications


    Following a two-year dry spell, the Pinellas County school district has received two new applications to open charter schools in St. Petersburg.

    Windsor Preparatory Academy in St. Petersburg could be home to Pinellas Academy of Math and Science's St. Petersburg campus. The Pinellas County school district received a charter school application from that school's leadership this fall to open in 2018.
  2. Southern Heritage group draws fire for posting personal information of Confederate statue opponents


    TAMPA — Curtiss Wilson is an 89-year-old Tampa resident who fought in the civil rights movement.

    A report by Save Southern Heritage Florida includes the "affiliation" of more than 100 people who spoke at the July 19 commission meeting in favor of removing  the Confederate monument from in front of the old county courthouse in Tampa. People on the list say the report was meant to intimidate and harrass opponents of the monument. Save Southern Heritage director Doug Guetzloe said the report is "opposition research" meant to to inform elected officials about who was speaking on the issue.
[Save Southern Heritage Florida]
  3. Gen. Votel interview: 'A bit of a stalemate' in Afghanistan, but a chance to optimize gains there


    In developing the plan for the war in Afghanistan that he announced Monday night, President Donald Trump consulted with advisers including his military leaders throyugh their chain of command.

  4. Water Street Tampa unveils illustrations showing downtown's transformation


    TAMPA — Water Street Tampa, the sweeping, 50-plus acre redevelopment project in Tampa's urban core, has unveiled new images and video of what the downtown district will look like upon completion.

    Strategic Property Partners released a conceptual image of what the Tampa skyline will look like once its redevelopment of 50-plus acres of downtown will look like. [Photo courtesy of  of SPP]
  5. Bill Nelson shares Rick Scott's cautious stance on Confederate monuments


    On the issue of Confederate monuments, Sen. Bill Nelson is taking the cautious route of Gov. Rick Scott.