Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Is the goal more prison cells or fewer criminals?

The way to deal with crime is to put criminals in prison. If we need more prisons, we will build them.

The purpose of prison is to punish and to protect society — not to rehabilitate.

For the past quarter-century or so, this has been the stated policy of Florida.

Florida was a leader among the states in rejecting the liberal philosophy of the 1960s and 1970s that crime was foremost a "social problem" that needed sociological solutions.

You know what? It worked.

Without question, a guy sitting in prison is not free to break into your house or mine. He is not free to stick up a convenience store, or to deal drugs on the street corner.

So as Florida rapidly expanded its prison system starting in the 1980s, the crime rate fell steadily. There were other reasons, but having so many people behind bars certainly helped.

But there is a cost, too.

As of Friday, there were 99,845 inmates in the Florida system, the nation's third-largest, housed in 60 prisons, 41 work or forestry camps, and assorted work-release centers and road prisons.

The Department of Corrections has an annual budget of $2.3-billion. The average cost of keeping an inmate for one year is more than $19,000.

On top of that, the department's secretary, Walter McNeil, predicts the state will need to build another 19 prisons over the next five years at a capital cost of another $2-billion, even if we stack 'em and rack 'em. Incidentally, this is close to the size of the state's current budget deficit.

A lot of the department's customers are repeat offenders. About 33 percent of inmates come back to prison within three years of their release. Of the current inmate population, 46 percent have been there before.

But when inmates successfully complete a substance abuse program, their three-year rate of recidivism is only 6.7 percent, according to the department.

Furthermore, for each additional year of education they achieve, their chance of coming back to prison drops 3 to 4 percentage points.

And so there has been a subtle and interesting trend in the rhetoric of the Department of Corrections under Gov. Charlie Crist, who once advocated prison chain-gangs.

No one is resurrecting the old R-word, "rehabilitation." But a new R-word is coming into use: "re-entry."

"Re-entry is a cost-saving measure," says department spokeswoman Gretl Plessinger, who says 88 percent of inmates eventually get out.

"It's also an anti-crime measure, because if they have the tools to succeed, they are less likely to victimize again."

Plessinger estimates that two-thirds of all admitted inmates have a substance-abuse problem, but the department's resources allow only about 20 percent to go through a program.

Wrestling with the state budget, the Legislature has cut the department's programs. Next spring the department will ask for some of those cuts to be restored.

No one is talking here about crime being "society's fault." No one is wringing hands and boo-hooing over the fact criminals are in prison. No one is talking about being soft.

The question instead is whether it becomes cheaper in the long run to attack recidivism, so that fewer crimes are committed, than to wait until they are committed and warehouse the offenders.

The question is which approach is more "conservative."

Is the goal more prison cells or fewer criminals? 12/13/08 [Last modified: Monday, December 22, 2008 11:57am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Police plan community meeting as search for Seminole Heights killer continues


    TAMPA — With people in Seminole Heights on edge following three related shooting deaths on their streets, police have planned a community meeting for Monday.

    The three Seminole Heights victims, from left: Benjamin Edward Mitchell, 22; Monica Caridad Hoffa, 32; and Anthony Naiboa, 20. [Facebook, family photos]
  2. Bucs-Bills: Tampa Bay's fatal habit of falling behind


    TAMPA — Okay, all you road scholars, why do the Bucs keep falling behind in games not played at Raymond James Stadium?

    Arizona Cardinals quarterback Carson Palmer (3) recovers a fumble during the first half of an NFL game between the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Arizona Cardinals at University of Phoenix Stadium in Glendale, Ariz., on Sunday, Oct. 15, 2017.
  3. Hudson man, 19, killed by hit-and-run driver while walking in street, FHP says


    A 19-year-old Hudson man walking in the street Friday night was struck and killed by a pickup truck that fled the scene, the Florida Highway Patrol said.

  4. Road Ranger hurt after truck catches fire in crash at I-275, Busch


    TAMPA — A Road Ranger was seriously injured when a drunk driver ran into the back of his truck on Interstate 275 and both vehicles burst into flame, the Florida Highway Patrol said.

    Brian Nelson Barrett, 42, of Wimauma, was headed north on I-275 in his Road Ranger truck Saturday morning 10/21/17 when a car hit him from behind, causing both vehicles to erupt in flames.
  5. Nicked-up Lightning vs. Penguins tonight