Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

'Tax Swap' axed from November ballot

TALLAHASSEE — A state judge stripped a controversial "tax swap" from the November ballot Thursday, saying it would mislead voters about the future of school funding.

Gov. Charlie Crist and other backers pledged a swift appeal. But the decision leaves state leaders again grappling to meet public demand for lower property taxes.

The decision, secured by a powerful and diverse coalition of opponents, was also a preview of the battle ahead if an appellate court returns Amendment 5 to the ballot.

The proposed amendment to the state Constitution called for eliminating most school property taxes, resulting in at least a 25 percent tax cut for all property owners. The Legislature would have to replace the money, an estimated $9-billion to $11-billion, by increasing the sales tax, eliminating sales tax exemptions or cutting the budget.

Many critics felt it was an impossible calculation, since a 1-cent sales tax increase would raise just $4-billion.

The lawsuit argued that voters were being led to believe all lost school funding would be replaced. In fact, the guarantee was only for one year, 2010-2011, after which the Legislature would have discretion on how much money to spend on education.

"The ballot title and summary give no indication of this significant limitation on the 'hold harmless' provision," Leon County Circuit Judge John C. Cooper wrote in a 13-page decision. "To the contrary, (they) convey the distinct impression that the balance of lost revenue and replacement revenue are continuing."

It is the second time in a year that a judge has dismissed a property tax plan, and it is one of a string of recent court decisions against tax proposals, highlighting their complexity.

Last summer, a legislative plan to offer a much larger homestead exemption was thrown out because a judge found it did not fully inform voters that Save Our Homes, the wildly successful 3 percent annual assessment cap, would be phased out. The Legislature opted not to appeal that decision but instead passed a new tax cut plan, Amendment 1, which voters approved in January.

The appeal of Thursday's decision will likely bypass the 1st District Court of Appeal and go immediately before the Florida Supreme Court, as has happened with other ballot measures challenged this year.

Crist, who just last week said he would push to pass Amendment 5, had a cool reaction Thursday, saying the final court decision is what counts, "not the first." He said the tight ballot language is akin to a newspaper headline.

"A headline is supposed to give you an idea about what's in the body of the story," Crist said. "It didn't seem inaccurate to me."

The Florida Association of Realtors viewed the plan as a panacea to an ailing housing market. "We are shocked that the court decided to deny property owners the ability to dramatically lower their property tax rates," said the group's president, Chuck Bonfiglio.

Yet some legislative leaders were relieved at the potential of not inheriting the divisive task of finding replacement revenue. Business groups not only resist a higher sales tax but also fear a return of the ill-fated tax on services, such as accountants and dry cleaning, that was passed in 1987 and quickly repealed.

School officials and unions were equally fearful about losing funding, mindful of past promises that have gone unfulfilled.

"This amendment is a bad deal for Florida and a bait-and-switch proposal of the worst kind," said state Sen. Mike Haridopolos, an Indialantic Republican in line to be Senate president in 2010.

The amendment was the product of the Taxation and Budget Reform Commission, a 25-member panel appointed by the governor, House speaker and Senate president.

A former Senate president, John McKay, led the commission's charge for Amendment 5. Thursday marked the third time the Bradenton real estate developer has seen a court cast aside his plans for revamping the state's tax structure. In 2002 and 2004, his efforts to review the state's sales tax exemptions were rejected by the courts.

"It's disappointing but it doesn't really change a whole lot," McKay said of the decision, noting that either side would have appealed.

He said supporters would offer a better argument in court why the funding guarantee is limited to one year. Student enrollment changes annually, he said, so a rigid funding formula is not prudent.

"I'm confident we'll prevail," McKay said. "People want high property taxes eliminated and they'd like special interest tax breaks eliminated."

Allan Bense, a former House speaker who chaired the taxation commission, said he was disappointed. "However, I do know that there are three branches of government."

One option — barring a successful appeal — would be for the panel to reconvene and craft a new plan. But Bense said he was not sure that would happen, in part because the Legislature would have to provide funding.

The Florida Chamber of Commerce, part of the opposition, cast the decision as an opportunity to work on a better property tax plan. It urged Crist to call a special legislative session after the November elections.

The governor said he wanted to focus on the appeal. "I hope it stays on the ballot. Most important to me is that the people have the opportunity to make the call. It's their Constitution."

>>fast facts

What's next

Thursday's court decision is not the end of the road for Amendment 5. Proponents plan to appeal. The matter will most likely be decided by the Florida Supreme Court.

>>fast facts

Amendment 5

Ballot title: Eliminating state required school property tax and replacing with equivalent state revenues to fund education.

Ballot summary: Replacing state required school property taxes with state revenues generating an equivalent hold harmless amount for schools through one or more of the following options: repealing sales tax exemptions not specifically excluded; increasing sales tax rate up to one percentage point; spending reductions; other revenue options created by the Legislature. Limiting subject matter of laws granting future exemptions. Limiting annual increases in assessment of non-homestead real property. Lowering property tax millage rate for schools.

'Tax Swap' axed from November ballot 08/14/08 [Last modified: Wednesday, August 20, 2008 11:47am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Review: Arcade Fire open hearts, play with passion at the USF Sun Dome in Tampa


    Gloves off, hearts open and disco balls glittering, Arcade Fire scaled the stage for the first time ever in Tampa, pouncing and flailing and performing with all the passion that’s made them one of the world’s most celebrated rock bands this century.

    Arcade Fire performed at the USF Sun Dome in Tampa on Sept. 22, 2017.
  2. Lightning's Steven Stamkos looks close to top form in first game since November

    Lightning Strikes

    TAMPA — The wait felt like forever for Lightning captain Steven Stamkos, having gone 10 months without playing in a game.

    A scramble in front of the Lightning goal has Matthew Peca, far left, and Erik Cernak, middle, helping out goalie Andrei Vasilevskiy during the third period of a 3-1 win against the Predators. Vasilevskiy, who made 29 saves, was “exceptional,” coach Jon Cooper says.
  3. Rays journal: Alex Cobb may have pitched last game in Rays uniform (w/video)

    The Heater

    BALTIMORE — RHP Alex Cobb pitched well enough to lead the Rays to an 8-3 win over the Orioles on Friday.

    Wilson Ramos gives thanks after hitting a grand slam during the second inning, putting the Rays up 4-0.
  4. Steven Souza Jr. vindicating big trade for Rays

    The Heater

    BALTIMORE — There was a time when the three-team, 11-player transaction the Rays orchestrated to get Steven Souza Jr. from the Nationals looked liked a bad deal.

    The Rays’ Steven Souza Jr. has 30 home runs this season while improving his defense and baserunning but wants to improve on his .236 batting average.
  5. Fennelly: Lightning's Manon Rheaume made history 25 years ago Saturday

    Lightning Strikes

    The name is part of Lightning history, hockey history, sports history.

    Lightning goalie Manon Rheaume became the first woman to play in an NHL game 25 years ago today.