Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

As debate swirls over legality of gay adoption, bills could make court ruling moot

As gay-rights advocates and religious groups queue up in an effort to influence the outcome of a Miami appeals court case that will help decide whether gay people can adopt children in Florida, a state lawmaker has quietly introduced two bills that could render the dispute moot.

State Sen. Nan Rich, a Weston Democrat who is co-chair of the Senate Children, Families and Elder Affairs Committee, has filed a bill to repeal the 1977 Florida law that prohibits gay men and lesbians from adopting children. A second bill would specify that judges would determine adoptions based solely on "the best interests'' of children.

"Someone who is a good parent — whether they are heterosexual or homosexual — that's what we should be basing decisions on, not sexual orientation," Rich said. "We need to be looking at what's in the best interests of children."

Sen. Ronda Storms, a Republican from Brandon who chairs the Children, Families and Elder Affairs Committee, would not discuss the bills at length with a reporter. "I'm considering it," she said.

Florida's adoption law has been stirring controversy since last summer, when a Monroe County judge, David John Audlin Jr., declared the law unconstitutional, allowing a Key West lawyer and his longtime partner to adopt a boy they had raised in foster care for several years.

Neither the Department of Children & Families nor the state Attorney General's Office objected to the adoption, saying the child already had been in a permanent guardianship with the foster dad and the state child welfare agency had no jurisdiction over the case. The agencies declined to appeal.

Then, in November, Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Cindy Lederman also declared the law unconstitutional in a case in which she approved the adoption of two half-brothers, then ages 4 and 8. The boys, identified only as John and James Doe, had been living with foster father Frank Gill since December 2004.

DCF, which had custody of the children Gill adopted, has appealed Lederman's order to the Third District Court of Appeal in Miami. Gill's attorneys tried to move the case directly to the Florida Supreme Court, but the Miami appeals court judges declined to relinquish jurisdiction.

Advocacy groups interested in the outcome of the court case already are lining up on both sides of the issue.

Hilarie Bass, a partner at Greenberg Traurig who represents Gill's foster children, said "the politics in this case result from the fact that everybody, in their heart of hearts, wants what's in the best interests of the children. Unfortunately, very few legislators will stand up and make this their cause."

"There is no doubt in my mind," Bass added, "that psychologists have determined what the key factors are to successful parenting. Those characteristics are not limited to any demographic group. People are just as likely to be good parents whether they are single gay parents or in a married, traditional family."

The Florida Bar Board of Governors voted on Jan. 30 to allow the group's Family Law Section to file a "friend of the court'' brief supporting Lederman's ruling in the case.

Scott Rubin, a Miami family attorney who chairs the section, said, "The facts of this case make it apparent that what is best for these children is to be able to be adopted by'' Gill.

But if Liberty Counsel, a Maitland-based conservative advocacy group, prevails in its effort to get an injunction from the Florida Supreme Court, the Bar's brief will never be read.

On Feb. 25, Liberty Counsel's founder and chairman, Mathew D. Staver, asked the high court, which oversees the Bar, to halt the filing of any brief in support of Lederman's ruling.

The group is arguing that taking a stand on gay adoption "places the Bar in direct conflict with its constituents," since some attorneys feel just as strongly that the 32-year-old law should be upheld. All lawyers in Florida must belong to the Bar and pay dues for their membership.

"This action by the Florida Bar is completely out of step with the member attorneys it represents and with the vast majority of Floridians," Staver wrote in a Feb. 9 letter to two Bar officials. "Homosexual adoption is nothing less than a policy which says that moms and dads are expendable."

The American College of Pediatricians, an industry association formed in 2002 after the 75-year-old American Academy of Pediatrics issued a statement supporting adoption by gay men and lesbians, also has submitted a friend-of-the-court brief opposing Gill's adoption of his two foster children.

"The college recognizes that the basic father-mother unit is the optimal setting for childhood development," the association wrote in its brief. "The college believes that the Florida Legislature (had) sound scientific bases for passing (the 1977 law) and that the lower court should have deferred to the Legislature's judgment."

Times/Herald Tallahassee Bureau staff writer Marc Caputo contributed to this report.

As debate swirls over legality of gay adoption, bills could make court ruling moot 03/11/09 [Last modified: Monday, November 7, 2011 5:07pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Tampa Bay small businesses give Tampa B+ for regulatory climate


    In a recent survey about small business sentiments toward state and local government policies that affect them, Tampa Bay ranked at No. 25 out of 80 — a B+ overall.

    Tampa Bay ranked No. 25 out of 80 in a recent survey about how small business owners feel about state and local government policies that affect them. | [Times file photo]
  2. Dirk Koetter to Bucs: Take your complaints to someone who can help


    TAMPA — It was just another day of aching bellies at One Save Face.

    Dirk Koetter: “All of our issues are self-inflicted right now.”
  3. Seminole Heights murders: fear and warnings, but no answers


    TAMPA — Interim Tampa police Chief Brian Dugan elicited loud gasps from the crowd of about 400 who showed up at Edison Elementary School on Monday night to learn more about the string of unsolved killings that have left the southeast Seminole Heights neighborhood gripped by fear.

    Kimberly Overman, left, comforts Angelique Dupree, center, as she spoke about the death of her nephew Benjamin Mitchell, 22, last week in Seminole Heights. The Tampa Police Department held a town hall meeting Monday night where concerned residents hoped to learn more about the investigation into the three shooting deaths over 11 days in southeast Seminole Heights. But police could give the crowd at Edison Elementary School few answers. [OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times]
  4. Juvenile justice reform seen as help for teen car theft problem


    ST. PETERSBURG — One of Tampa Bay's largest religious organizations has decided to make reforming the juvenile justice system one of its top priorities for next year.

    One of Tampa Bay's largest religious organizations, Faith & Action for Strength Together (FAST), voted Monday night to make reforming the juvenile justice system one of its top priorities for next year. FAST believes civil citations could help Pinellas County?€™s teen car theft epidemic by keeping children out of the juvenile justice system for minor offenses. [ZACHARY T. SAMPSON  |  Times]
  5. U.S. general lays out Niger attack details; questions remain (w/video)


    WASHINGTON — The U.S. Special Forces unit ambushed by Islamic militants in Niger didn't call for help until an hour into their first contact with the enemy, the top U.S. general said Monday, as he tried to clear up some of the murky details of the assault that killed four American troops and has triggered a nasty …

    Gen. Joseph Dunford said much is still unclear about the ambush.