Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Black voters become focus in redistricting fight

TALLAHASSEE — The racial tensions that coursed for years beneath the surface in Florida's redistricting battle came into sharp focus Wednesday as lawyers for each side blasted each other for attempting to use black voters for partisan gain.

The conflict emerged at a hearing called by Leon County Circuit Court Judge Terry Lewis to decide whether the Florida Legislature's redrawn congressional map meets the constitutional standards imposed by voters in 2010.

Lewis said he will decide "as quickly as I can'' whether to accept the new map drawn by legislators last week in a three-day special session. Legislators had until Aug. 15 to revise two congressional districts he ruled invalid — one held by Democratic U.S. Rep. Corrine Brown, and the other held by Republican U.S. Rep. Dan Webster.

At the center of the controversy is Congressional District 5, which has been held by Brown for 22 years since the Legislature linked together African-American communities in North and Central Florida to elect a black lawmaker. In 1992, Brown, along with Alcee Hastings and Carrie Meek, both of South Florida, were the first blacks to be elected to Congress from Florida since Reconstruction.

Lewis ruled the "bizarrely-shaped" district was gerrymandered and unconstitutional under the new Fair Districts because it served to benefit Republicans.

The Legislature made minor changes to the map but kept most of it in place, a decision supported by Brown and the Democrat-leaning NAACP. The votes for the legislative plan reflected the racial divide in the Legislature. Most black legislators from northern Florida aligned with Brown in voting for the plan, while other Democrats in both chambers, including blacks in South Florida, opposed it.

"The map does exactly what the court asked,'' said George Meros, lawyer for the GOP-led House of Representatives.

The judge's ruling, however, left open to interpretation what he will consider an acceptable remedy to the flawed maps. So, faced with uncertain options, both sides are trying to make the case that their proposal helps black voters most.

Lawyers for the voters groups, who filed the lawsuit, argued that while the Legislature's map preserved Brown's black-majority district, the way it is configured actually deprived African-American voters in Central Florida of electing their own congressional representative.

They called Harvard University redistricting expert Stephen Ansolabehere who testified that the legislative map links African-American communities into Brown's district in a way that "interferes" with the communities' ability to elect two blacks to Congress, instead of one.

"They attempt to say that they have to have it this way because they have to protect the minority rights,'' said David King, lawyer for the coalition of voters groups. "That is a hollow claim when what they are really protecting is the Republican interests, and they are constraining more African-American representation by that approach."

The coalition presented the court with an alternative map that would have dismantled Brown's serpentine-shaped district that sprawls from Jacksonville to Orlando, and replaces it with two districts they said are designed to elect two blacks to Congress.

Their map creates a black majority district that stretches from Jacksonville to Tallahassee across North Florida and another that shift's Webster's districts into a district that could favor a black Democrat.

But Meros criticized the plaintiffs' argument as short-sighted and misleading.

He said Congressional District 5 was drawn 22 years ago "to remedy rampant discrimination in Northeast Florida which prevented any black elected to Congress since Reconstruction."

The Fair Districts rules prevent the state from diminishing that voting strength and argued that the discrimination of the past "has not stopped."

Meros cited testimony from NAACP officials from Alachua and Marion counties — who said that their counties still have not elected a black to any countywide office — as proof that voters still engage in bloc voting against blacks.

The plaintiff's alternative map would "yank out" of Brown's district the same communities that have suffered from "racially-polarized voting that prohibits African-Americans to elect representatives of their choice,'' he said.

He argued that the Legislature's plan preserves those communities in a black-majority district, and preserves their voting strength as the Fair District rules require.

Meros also cited testimony from trial depositions that showed the voters groups acted in concert with political operatives from the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee and the National Committee for an Effective Congress, an organization that works to elect Democrats to Congress. The strategy, he said, is to disperse black voters from Brown's sprawling district into new districts that will elect more Democrats.

"It's the national Democratic effort to say it's okay — you might not be able to elect a black, but you'll get a white Democrat to support you. And that's wrong,'' he said. ".…It takes us to a dark day."

Ansolabehere, the redistricting expert, said that if the alternate map proposed by the voters groups had been in place in 2012, Val Demings, a black Democrat, would have defeated Webster in the District 10 race and a black could have been elected to Congress in the east-west North Florida district.

Lewis said he was aware of the "time-sensitive nature of this case" as the contested districts remain in limbo as the primary and general elections draw near but he gave no indication when he will have a ruling.

Meanwhile, the likelihood of a special election before the Nov. 4 general election continues to dim. The Florida Secretary of State presented Lewis with a proposed schedule that would establish a special primary election for the redrawn districts in March and a general election in May. The plaintiffs have offered no alternative to that schedule.

Contact Mary Ellen Klas at Follow @MaryEllenKlas

Black voters become focus in redistricting fight 08/20/14 [Last modified: Wednesday, August 20, 2014 7:14pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Pinellas, Hillsborough to share notes on


    What is this, a crossover episode?

    Hillsborough County school superintendent Jeff Eakins did make an appearance at the Pinellas County School Board workshop Tuesday in a first public move to establish an official partnerships between the two districts.

    Hillsborough County school superintendent Jeff Eakins (center) and Pinellas school superintendent Mike Grego discuss a new partnership between the two districts at a Pinellas County School Board workshop Tuesday in Largo.
  2. NFL players, owners hold 'constructive' talks on issues


    NEW YORK — NFL players and owners met Tuesday to discuss social issues, a session Miami Dolphins owner Stephen Ross called "constructive."

    A coalition of advocacy groups 'take a knee' outside of a hotel where members the quarterly NFL league meetings are being held on Tuesday in New York City.  Owners, players and commissioner Roger Goodell are all expected to attend. The activists spoke of having solidarity with athletes and coaches around the country who have also kneeled in protest of racial injustice, especially in policing.
 [Getty Images]
  3. Marine colonel on temporary duty at CentCom arrested in Polk prostitution sting


    A Marine colonel on temporary duty at U.S. Central Command headquarters at MacDill Air Force Base was among nearly 300 people arrested in a Polk County Sheriff's Office prostitution and human trafficking sting.

    Marine Col. Kevin Scott, 51, was arrested in a Polk County prostitution sting on Oct. 14. Scott, on temporary duty at U.S. Central Command, was charged with a misdemeanor county of soliciting a prostitute. He was released on $500 bond. Photo courtesy of the Polk County Sheriff's Office.
  4. Senator says deal set on restoring ACA subsidies ended by Trump

    WASHINGTON (AP) — A leading Republican senator says he and a top Democrat have reached an agreement on a plan to extend federal payments to health insurers that President Donald Trump has blocked.

    President Donald Trump sits for a radio interview in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building in the White House complex in Washington, Tuesday, Oct. 17, 2017. (AP Photo/Susan Walsh) DCSW104
  5. Pasco delays Irma food distribution after problems elsewhere

    Local Government

    DADE CITY — Pasco County has pulled the plug on a planned Food for Florida distribution at the Land O'Lakes Recreation Center that had been scheduled to open to the public on Sunday.

    Pasco County has postponed a planned Food for Florida distribution at the Land O' Lakes Recreation Center on Collier Parkway and is seeking an alternative site. Last week, commissioners said they feared a repeat of the long lines of traffic that appeared outside Plant City Stadium on Oct. 9. The nutrition program for people affected by Hurricane Irma had been scheduled to come to Land O' Lakes Oct. 18 to 27.  [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]