Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Florida Supreme Court: Death penalty cases finalized before 2002 will stand

TALLAHASSEE — The Florida Supreme Court cemented death sentences for nearly 200 prisoners Thursday, ruling that they are not eligible for lower sentences or rehearings under a revamped death penalty law.

In a 6-1 ruling, the justices said death sentences finalized before a June 2002 U.S. Supreme Court decision would remain in effect, paving the way for executions to begin again in Florida. However, the ruling left open the possibility that more than half of Florida's death row inmates could be resentenced based on rulings this year that threw out the state's death penalty rules.

The court also lifted a stay on the execution of Mark James Asay, originally scheduled for March 17 of this year. It's a signal that executions could begin again after an 11-month hiatus as Florida's death penalty was shrouded in uncertainty.

Asay was convicted in 1988 of killing two men in Jacksonville. If he is executed, Asay would be the first white person put to death for murdering a black person in Florida, Justice James Perry said.

In statements, Gov. Rick Scott and Attorney General Pam Bondi said they were "reviewing the ruling." The state has executed 23 people while Scott has been in office, more than any governor since the death penalty was re-instated in 1976.

Thursday's ruling caps a tumultuous year for Florida's death penalty. The only execution in 2016 was that of Oscar Ray Bolin, Jr. on Jan. 7. He was executed just five days before the U.S. Supreme Court ruled the state's death penalty unconstitutional in Hurst vs. Florida, prompting the Legislature to re-write sentencing laws.

In October, the Florida Supreme Court decided that the Hurst ruling required unanimous votes by juries to make a death sentence. Current law requires a supermajority vote by 10 of the 12 members of a jury.

Figuring out how to apply those rulings to the 384 prisoners on death row has been a "thorny issue," the justices wrote, requiring them to balance fairness and inmates' constitutional rights with the principle that decisions by judges and juries are final.

Critics of Thursday's ruling, including some justices on the deeply divided court, say drawing a line in the sand on the day the U.S. Supreme Court handed down its 2002 decision in Ring vs. Arizona is arbitrary. That case required that juries find specific aggravating factors before sentencing someone to death and called Florida's death penalty laws into question.

While several justices disagreed with parts of the case, just one justice, who retires Dec. 30, dissented entirely. Perry wrote that all death row inmates should have their sentences changed to life in prison.

"(The ruling) creates an arbitrary application of law to two groups of similarly situated persons," he wrote. "Coupled with Florida's troubled history in applying the death penalty in a discriminatory manner, I believe that such an application is unconstitutional."

Justice Barbara Pariente agreed with Perry that the ruling should apply retroactively to all death row inmates but said they should be entitled only to a re-hearing, not guaranteed a lesser sentence.

Justice Fred Lewis argued that inmates whose cases were finalized before the Ring decision but who challenged the lack of unanimity and jury fact finding in Florida's old death penalty rules should be eligible for resentencing.

"Vindication of these constitutional rights cannot be reduced to either fatal or fortuitous accidents of timing," he wrote.

The court's decision could lead to more confusion about Florida's death penalty in the future, said Robert Dunham, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center in Washington.

"That's not a principled basis to decide whether someone should live or die," he said. "And that only adds additional fuel to the cries of death penalty opponents that the United States is incapable of carrying out capital punishment in anything but an arbitrary manner."

Perry made the same point in his dissent, saying he "no longer" thinks the state can constitutionally execute convicted killers.

After Thursday's ruling, the future remains unclear for more than 200 inmates whose cases were not finalized before Ring was handed down.

In other rulings Thursday, the Supreme Court granted new sentencing hearings to death row inmates John F. Mosley, convicted in 2006 of killing his girlfriend and infant son in Jacksonville, and Eric Lee Simmons, convicted in 2003 of kidnapping a woman, then sexually assaulting and stabbing her to death in Lake County. Their sentences were both final after the Ring decision.

The justices wrote in Mosley's ruling that "Hurst should be applied" to cases that became final after Ring. But dozens more appeals from inmates seeking a new sentence could cost the state millions and flood the courts.

Dunham said one option is for the Legislature to step in and convert all 384 death sentences to life in prison.

That's not likely to happen, though.

Asked this week if he thinks the Hurst case should apply retroactively to existing death row inmates, Senate President Joe Negron, R-Stuart, was brief in his reply: "No."

Contact Michael Auslen at Follow @MichaelAuslen.

Tampa Bay area cases in limbo

The Florida Supreme Court ruled Thursday that death penalty cases finalized after June 2002 could be eligible for resentencing. Here are some of the high-profile local cases that could be affected:

Hillsborough County

• William Deparvine, 54, was sentenced to death Jan. 9, 2006, in an 8-4 jury vote. After a two-week trial, Deparvine was convicted of killing a Hillsborough County couple. Prosecutors said he murdered Richard and Karla Van Dusen in November 2003 and took their vintage pickup truck. Deparvine maintained his innocence throughout the trial and even fought for ownership of the truck, which he said he purchased legally.

• Kenneth Jackson, 34, was sentenced to death on June 5, 2015, in an 11-1 vote. It took jurors 90 minutes to decide. Jackson was convicted of raping and murdering a Seffner mother of three in September 2007. Prosecutors said Jackson abducted Cuc Thu Tran while she was on an early morning jog. He stabbed Tran in the throat then lit a stolen van on fire with her inside.

• Khalid Pasha, 73, was sentenced to death for murdering his wife and stepdaughter in 2001. The jury first voted 7 to 5 for Pasha's execution, meaning one vote made him eligible for the death penalty. He was retried in 2013 and jurors voted 11-1 for the death penalty. Police found Pasha driving away from the crime scene in a white van with a knife and jumpsuit covered with his family's blood inside.

Pinellas County

• John Lee Hampton, 42, was sentenced to death for murdering 25-year-old Clearwater woman Lashonda McKinnes. During the 2007 investigation, Hampton said he killed the woman by accident. Prosecutors said he raped her, slit her throat and then tried to wash his DNA off of her body with cleaning chemicals and lighter fluid. His defense argued he struggled with mental issues. The jury voted to put him to death on Feb. 19, 2010, 9 to 3.

• Richard T. Robards, 49, was sentenced to death after he murdered a Clearwater couple in a failed attempt to steal their safe. Robards used to work as a personal trainer for the couple, Linda and Frank Deluca, and learned they stored thousands of dollars in a safe. He stabbed the Delucas repeatedly, slitting their throats and puncturing Frank Deluca's lung. But he never got the safe open. A jury voted 7-5 to put him to death on Oct. 29, 2010.

Pasco County

• John Sexton, 53, raped and murdered 94-year-old Ann Parlato in September 2010. Prosecutors said he mutilated her body and then set it on fire. Sexton did yard work for Parlato. Police found Sexton at his Port Richey home wearing clothes stained with the elderly woman's blood. The jury voted to put him to death, 10 to 2, on Dec. 13, 2013.

Compiled by Times staff writers Sara DiNatale and Dan Sullivan.

Florida Supreme Court: Death penalty cases finalized before 2002 will stand 12/22/16 [Last modified: Thursday, December 22, 2016 7:41pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Observations from a liberal, gay, Latino, feminist Florida House freshman


    State Rep. Carlos Guillermo Smith, D-Orlando,  rocked the Florida LGBTA Democratic Caucus dinner at Tallahassee's Hotel Duval Satursday night with his unabashedly liberal and passionate take on the myriad issues he said are key to LGBTQ Floridians. Among them: Access to guns, Reproductive rights, home …

    Carlos G. Smith
  2. Delta Sigma Theta honors outgoing national president

    Human Interest

    During her four years as national president of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority, Inc., Paulette Walker said she always focused on the comma between "Sorority" and "Inc."

    Paulette Walker, the former director of undergraduate programs and internship in the College of Education at the University of South Florida, will be honored on Saturday for her leadership in the Delta Sigma Theta sorority.
  3. 10 sailors missing, 5 hurt in collision of USS John S. McCain

    SEOUL —Ten U.S. Navy sailors are missing and five have been injured after the USS John S. McCain destroyer collided with an oil tanker near Singapore early Monday morning.

    In this Jan. 22, 2017, photo provided by U.S. Navy, the USS John S. McCain patrols in the South China Sea while supporting security efforts in the region. The guided-missile destroyer collided with a merchant ship on Monday, Aug. 21, in waters east of Singapore and the Straits of Malacca. Ten sailors were missing, and five were injured, the Navy said. [James Vazquez/U.S. Navy via AP]
  4. Pasco County Fire Rescue fighting a two-alarm fire started by an explosion


    Two houses are on fire and one victim has been critically burned and taken to a trauma center following an explosion at a home at 8652 Velvet Dr, in Port Richey.

  5. Rays see the Blake Snell they've been waiting for in win over Mariners

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — It was a one-run game Sunday when the Mariners' Robinson Cano singled with one out in the seventh inning, bringing the dangerous Nelson Cruz to the plate.

    Tampa Bay Rays starting pitcher Blake Snell (4) throwing in the third inning of the game between the Seattle Mariners and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Fla. on Sunday, Aug. 20, 2017.