Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Florida Supreme Court sides with a Legislature that often criticizes it

When folks complain about "activist" judges, it usually just means they don't like the outcome of a case.

Nobody ever says, "The side that I like won — but the judge was wrong."

For example, two federal judges so far have ruled that the national health care law is constitutional. Two have ruled it is not.

Which two were "activist"? The two who agreed that Congress has the power to penalize Americans for not buying health insurance? Or the two who ruled Congress lacks any such power under the U.S. Constitution?

Here in Florida there's a running battle between our state Supreme Court and the Legislature. The Legislature's leaders often use the A-word to criticize the court.

Sometimes it's true — the court goes out on a limb to come up with a ruling. But sometimes it's the Legislature that tries something kooky, and the court that sticks to the letter of the law.

I'm bringing this up because the Florida Supreme Court issued a ruling recently that got little attention, but which was a model of deference to the Legislature.

The case involved a ruling from a lower-level trial judge that threw out Florida's system of "filing fees" for lawsuits and appeals.

The Legislature passed a law saying the first $80 of every filing fee in a court case goes into the state's "general revenue." The Legislature can spend the dough as it chooses.

Yet our state Constitution says:

The courts shall be open to every person for redress of any injury, and justice shall be administered without sale, denial or delay.

A lawsuit claimed that by tacking on an extra $80 to court fees to raise money for the state, the Legislature was violating this provision. A Leon County circuit judge agreed and struck the law.

This was no small potato. Last year these fees were worth $187 million. So former Gov. Charlie Crist and former Chief Financial Officer Alex Sink appealed.

Given the chance to sock it to the Legislature, however, the Supreme Court … sided with the Legislature.

In the first place, the court ruled, the Legislature spends a lot more money on courts and justice than the amount raised by these filing fees.

It doesn't matter that the fees are first put into the state's general revenue — more money than that comes back to the courts.

One dollar is just as good as another. (As the court put it, "Money is fungible.") The Legislature is perfectly entitled to do it this way.

The Supreme Court even criticized the trial judge for his finding that the laws "deny the citizens of this state the right to have their courts adequately funded."

The court asked: Where is the evidence?

"The trial judge," the Supreme Court noted, "simply took judicial notice of underfunding based upon the fact that he had recently received a two-percent reduction in his salary."

In general, the Supreme Court said, it must give the Legislature "a presumption of constitutionality" and to find the Legislature's laws constitutional "whenever possible."

Well! Will the Legislature send the court a nice thank-you card now? Doubtful. In fact, one of the top priorities of this year's Legislature is to do something to rein in that "activist" Florida Supreme Court.

Florida Supreme Court sides with a Legislature that often criticizes it 02/14/11 [Last modified: Monday, February 14, 2011 6:39pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Twins eventually cash in as Rays lose, fall back to .500 (w/video)

    The Heater

    MINNEAPOLIS — The Rays could only battle their way out of trouble for so long Saturday afternoon before succumbing in a 5-2 loss to the Twins.

    Minnesota Twins pitcher Adalberto Mejia, right, makes the tag at the plate on Tampa Bay Rays' Steven Souza Jr. who attempted to score on a runner's fielders' choice in the second inning of a baseball game Saturday, May 27, 2017, in Minneapolis. AP Photo/Jim Mone) MNJM103
  2. Rays Tales: The stories behind Corey Dickerson's ascension

    The Heater

    The 25 pounds DH/LF Corey Dickerson lost during the winter through diet and exercise are considered the primary reason for his ascension to one of the American League's most productive hitters, going into the weekend leading in hits, multi-hit games and total bases, and ranked in the top five in average, runs and …

    Tampa Bay Rays designated hitter Corey Dickerson (10) connects for a sac fly, scores Tampa Bay Rays first baseman Steve Pearce (28) in the fourth inning of the game between the Seattle Mariners and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Fla. on Wednesday, June 15, 2016.
  3. Gregg Allman of The Allman Brothers Band dies at age 69

    Music & Concerts

    SAVANNAH, Ga. — Music legend Gregg Allman, whose bluesy vocals and soulful touch on the Hammond B-3 organ helped propel the Allman Brothers Band to superstardom and spawn Southern rock, died Saturday, a publicist said. He was 69.

    This Oct. 13, 2011 file photo shows Gregg Allman performs at the Americana Music Association awards show in Nashville, Tenn. On Saturday, May 27, 2017, a publicist said the musician, the singer for The Allman Brothers Band, has died. (AP Photo/Joe Howell, File)
  4. Hall of Fame pitcher Jim Bunning, a former senator, dies at 85


    LOUISVILLE, Ky. — Jim Bunning, a former Hall of Fame pitcher who went on to serve in Congress, has died. He was 85.

    In this June 21, 1964 file photo, Jim Bunning of the Philadelphia Phillies pitches a perfect game against the New York Mets at Shea Stadium in New York.  The Phillies beat the Mets, 6-0.  Bunning retired all 27 batters who faced him in the first game of a doubleheader to become the first pitcher in 42 years with a perfect game in regular season play.   (AP Photo/File)
  5. Trump to decide next week whether to quit Paris climate agreement


    TAORMINA, Italy —President Donald Trump declined to endorse the Paris climate accords on Saturday, saying he would decide in the coming days whether the United States would pull out of the 195-nation agreement.

    President Donald Trump, right, arrives to a G7 session with outreach countries in Taormina, Italy, on Saturday. Climate and trade were sticking points at the two-day summit in Taormina, Sicily. (AP Photo/Salvatore Cavalli)