Sunday, December 17, 2017
Politics

Florida Supreme Court strikes down workers' comp fee law

TALLAHASSEE — In a major victory for injured workers and stinging defeat for businesses, the Florida Supreme Court on Thursday struck down a law limiting attorney's fees in workers' compensation cases.

The 5-2 ruling is a setback for business groups who say legal fees drive up the cost of workers' compensation insurance and threaten Florida's economy and they must seek help from a reliably pro-business Legislature.

The long-awaited decision puts pressure on lawmakers to call a special session in an election year to referee a high-stakes battle between Republican-aligned businesses and Democrat-leaning law firms, two deep-pocketed rivals that are among the biggest contributors to legislators' political campaigns.

The case before the high court involves a Miami man, Marvin Castellanos, who suffered head, neck and shoulder injuries while working for Next Door Co., a maker of doors and door frames in Miami.

The company waged an aggressive defense, but Castellanos won and received benefits of $822.70.

His lawyer, who worked on the case for 107 hours, sought a fee of $36,817.50.

He received a fee of $164.54, the equivalent of $1.53 per hour under a fee system the Legislature approved in 2009.

Under that law, attorneys who successfully represent injured workers are paid 20 percent of the first $5,000 in benefits obtained and 15 percent of the next $5,000 in benefits.

Writing for the majority, Justice Barbara Pariente said the law violates workers' due process rights under the state and U.S. Constitution because it prevents challenges to the "reasonableness" of legal fees in workers' compensation cases.

"Without the likelihood of an adequate attorney's fee award, there is little disincentive for a carrier to deny benefits or to raise multiple defenses, as was done here," Pariente wrote. "Virtually since its inception, the right of a claimant to obtain a reasonable prevailing party attorney's fee has been central to the workers' compensation law."

By replacing the former "reasonable" standard with a sliding scale of legal fees, Pariente said, "the Legislature has thus eliminated any consideration of reasonableness."

The ruling reflected the court's ideological split.

Pariente was appointed to the state's high court by Lawton Chiles, Florida's last Democratic governor, who died in 1998. She was supported by Chief Justice Jorge Labarga and justices Fred Lewis, James Perry and Peggy Quince.

The dissenters were the court's two conservative members, Ricky Polston and Charles Canady. Both were appointed by former Republican Gov. Charlie Crist, who also appointed Perry and Labarga.

Canady said the law involves a "policy determination" by the Legislature that there should be a relationship between the amount of benefits obtained in workers' compensation cases and the amount of attorney's fees awarded. The law has a formula that links benefits and attorney's fees.

"The definition assumed by the majority categorically precludes the legislative policy requiring a reasonable relationship between the amount of a fee award and the amount of the recovery obtained by the efforts of the attorney," Canady wrote. "Certainly, this legislative policy may be subject to criticism. But there is no basis in our precedents or federal law for declaring it unconstitutional."

Workers' compensation rates in Florida are regulated by the Office of Insurance Regulation, run by Kevin McCarty, who has resigned effective May 2 but who has offered to stay on with no permanent successor in place. Gov. Rick Scott said he wants to appoint McCarty's successor today.

McCarty said that until the Legislature acts, the state will base attorney's fees on the "reasonable" standard defined in a 2008 case, Murray vs. Mariner Health.

"Limiting attorney's fees has been an important factor in reducing workers' compensation rates," McCarty said. "A legislative remedy will be required to prevent significant increases in rates, and we look forward to working with all parties affected to bring about a sensible solution."

Rep. David Simmons, R-Altamonte Springs, said the ruling is not a crisis.

"The sky is not falling," he said.

Simmons said legislators must find a compromise between outrageous attorney's fees and the "absurd" $1.53 an hour in Thursday's decision.

"It can be fixed," Simmons said.

The effect on rates businesses pay for workers' comp insurance will be clearer in about a month when the National Council on Compensation Insurance, a federal clearinghouse, is expected to submit a proposed rate filing with McCarty's office.

The impact on Florida's workers' compensation system costs is expected to be significant," said Chris Bailey, a spokesman for NCCI.

Trial lawyers praised the decision.

Debra Henley, executive director of the Florida Justice Association, said she hoped companies "will change their claims handling practices and start promptly paying meritorious claims from injured workers so they can get the care they need, get back to work and support their families."

The Florida Chamber of Commerce chose its words carefully in responding to the ruling.

"The potential impact of the high court's ruling could threaten Florida's improving business climate," Chamber CEO Mark Wilson said in a statement.

Business groups won a partial victory Thursday when the court declined to rule in another workers' compensation case brought by a former Hialeah Hospital nurse, Daniel Stahl.

Times/Herald Tallahassee Bureau reporters Mary Ellen Klas and Jeremy Wallace contributed to this report and information from the News Service of Florida was used. Contact Steve Bousquet at [email protected] or (850) 224-7263. Follow @stevebousquet.

Comments
Trump says he isn’t considering firing Mueller

Trump says he isn’t considering firing Mueller

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump said Sunday that he is not considering firing special counsel Robert Mueller even as his administration was again forced to grapple with the growing Russia inquiry that has shadowed the White House for much of his ...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Trump defends tax plan, proclaims economy set ‘to rock’

Trump defends tax plan, proclaims economy set ‘to rock’

WASHINGTON — Closing in on the first major legislative achievement of his term, President Donald Trump on Saturday defended the Republican tax cut as a good deal for the middle class while boldly suggesting it could lead to explosive economic growth....
Published: 12/16/17
Romano: Some bullies survive beyond the schoolyard

Romano: Some bullies survive beyond the schoolyard

Sometime soon, members of the Florida House will be asked to consider a solution for bullying in public schools. It’s a dubious idea based on the premise that students should flee their tormenters, and use voucher funds to attend a private school of ...
Published: 12/16/17
CDC gets list of forbidden words: ‘fetus,’ ‘transgender,’ ‘evidence-based’

CDC gets list of forbidden words: ‘fetus,’ ‘transgender,’ ‘evidence-based’

Trump administration officials are forbidding officials at the nation’s top public health agency from using a list of seven words or phrases - including "fetus" and "transgender" - in any official documents being prepared for next year’s budget.Polic...
Published: 12/16/17
Female congressional candidate leaves race after sexual harassment allegations resurface

Female congressional candidate leaves race after sexual harassment allegations resurface

A Democratic candidate hoping to flip a hotly contested congressional seat in Kansas has dropped out of the race after allegations that she sexually harassed a male subordinate resurfaced amid her campaign.Andrea Ramsey, 57, who was running to unseat...
Published: 12/16/17
Highlights of GOP compromise bill to overhaul tax code

Highlights of GOP compromise bill to overhaul tax code

WASHINGTON — Republicans in Congress have blended separate tax bills passed by the House and Senate into compromise legislation that seeks to achieve a sweeping overhaul of the nation’s tax code. GOP leaders are looking toward passage of the final pa...
Published: 12/15/17
Updated: 12/16/17
With Rubio, Corker back on board, GOP speeds ahead with tax plan

With Rubio, Corker back on board, GOP speeds ahead with tax plan

WASHINGTON — Republican lawmakers on Friday secured enough votes to pass the most sweeping tax overhaul in decades, putting them on the cusp of their first significant legislative victory this year as party leaders geared up to pass a $1.5 trillion t...
Published: 12/15/17
Experts chart path for Hillsborough to grow smarter before sprawl takes over

Experts chart path for Hillsborough to grow smarter before sprawl takes over

TAMPA — Nearly 600,000 more people will live in Hillsborough County by 2040, and if elected officials and county planners don’t take bold steps now, the population boom will turn the county into the soulless sprawl of Anywhere, U.S.A.That’s the messa...
Published: 12/15/17
Tillerson retreats on offer of unconditional N. Korea talks

Tillerson retreats on offer of unconditional N. Korea talks

WASHINGTON — America’s top diplomat stepped back Friday from his offer of unconditional talks with North Korea, telling world powers that the nuclear-armed nation must earn the right to negotiate with the United States. Secretary of State Rex Tillers...
Published: 12/15/17
Judge signals release of ex-Trump chair Paul Manafort to Florida home under curfew and GPS monitoring

Judge signals release of ex-Trump chair Paul Manafort to Florida home under curfew and GPS monitoring

A federal judge Friday said a bail package has been put together that would release former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort from home confinement in his condominium in Virginia and allow him to reside at his house in Palm Beach Gardens, but unde...
Published: 12/15/17