Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Legislature seeks to saw off the judicial branch

Why do we need three branches of government, anyway? What an old-fashioned idea, that they should serve as a check and balance on each other!

Nope. If you get elected governor of Florida, or if you have the most votes in the Legislature, you should be able to do whatever you want. To the victor, you know.

And so not surprisingly, for its next trick, the Legislature this year intends to play 52-card pickup with the judicial branch of Florida's government.

Several ideas for "reforming" the courts were heard in Tallahassee last week and are moving right along. Some are dramatic. Some are unwise. Some are goofy. A couple, meh, maybe not so bad.

Fortunately, voters would have to approve most of these changes in 2012.

For starters, the Legislature proposes to split the seven-member Florida Supreme Court into two Supreme Courts of five members each, one for civil cases and the other criminal. The immediate effect would give Gov. Rick Scott three quick appointments that will suit him and the Legislature better than the current bunch.

Next, the Legislature proposes to end the last vestige of "merit selection" of Florida judges, and make the system completely political.

It used to be that committees made up of members of the public and the Florida Bar screened judicial nominees and sent a list of finalists to the governor to choose from.

But as soon as Florida had both a Republican Legislature and a Republican governor in Jeb Bush, lawmakers gave the governor more power over the nominating councils. The result was a series of nakedly political appointees by Bush, including the hacks on the 1st District Court of Appeal who stole that "Taj Mahal" courthouse from the taxpayers.

This year's Legislature proposes to finish the job by giving the governor total control of judicial nominations, cutting out the Bar and everybody else. For appeals judges, there would be no longer be screening at all — the governor could nominate anybody he wanted.

I laughed at this quote published by the House:

Nominations and appointments to the judicial branch of our government should not be effected (sic?) or influenced by third parties who do not have to answer to the citizens of Florida and this legislation simply codifies that principle into law.

No, heaven forbid that "third parties" such as the public itself, or anybody who knows anything about the law, should have a say in judicial selection!

Wait, there's more. Since we are getting rid of merit selection, the Legislature would require all Supreme Court and appeals judges to be approved by the state Senate.

Here is an ominous twist. The proposal gives the Senate six months, 180 days, after an appointment to decide whether to confirm a judge.

Every appeals judge in Florida would be on probation for half a year, subject to being fired if he or she ruled against the Legislature. And if you think that is paranoid, remember that the Senate performed exactly such an assassination last year, when it booted two new members of the Public Service Commission who had dared to vote against big electric rate hikes.

As one more cannonball (!) fired in the courts' direction, the Legislature wants to give itself final approval of all the rules of procedure, evidence and conduct that govern Florida's judicial branch.

Hey, it's not all bad. There's a single, delightful sentence deep in the text of the Legislature's bill splitting the Supreme Court in half:

The Supreme Court Building shall be at 2000 Drayton Drive, Tallahassee, Florida.

That's the address of the "Taj Mahal" and the 1st District appeals court. Presumably, by splitting the Supremes and moving them out there, the Legislature intends to evict those bums.

Overall, though, it is a grim business.

Two state Supreme Courts, newly packed with the governor's buddies. A totally political nominating system with no check on the governor's choices. Appeals judges subject to being removed on the spot if the Legislature doesn't like a ruling. The Legislature controlling the rules of evidence, of procedure, and operation of the judicial branch.

It is revolution. It is constitutional usurpation. It is practically a whole new form of government.

But I'll tell you what it ain't. It ain't "conservative."

Legislature seeks to saw off the judicial branch 03/19/11 [Last modified: Sunday, March 20, 2011 1:35pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Study: Tampa Bay a top market for homebuyers on the move

    Real Estate

    The Tampa Bay area is among the top markets for homebuyers who are likely to move in the next few months, ATTOM Data Solutions says.

    The Tampa Bay area is among the top markets for homebuyers who are likely to move in the next few months, a survey found.
[Associated Press file photo]
  2. Tampa lawyer Fred Ridley to be new chairman of Augusta National, Masters' home (w/ video)


    AUGUSTA, Ga. — Fred Ridley first came to Augusta National to compete in the 1976 Masters as the U.S. Amateur champion, and he played the opening round in the traditional pairing with the defending champion, Jack Nicklaus.

  3. Rays send down Chase Whitley, Andrew Kittredge; add Chih-Wei Hu, activate Alex Cobb


    After having to cover more than five innings following a short start by Austin Pruitt, the Rays shuffled their bullpen following Wednesday's game, sending down RHPs Chase Whitley and Andrew Kittredge,

    The Kittredge move was expected, as he was summoned to add depth to the pen Wednesday in advance of RHP Alex …

  4. MLB commissioner Rob Manfred moves closer to wanting a decision on Rays stadium

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — Major League Baseball commissioner Rob Manfred called Wednesday for urgency from Tampa Bay area government leaders to prioritize and move quicker on plans for a new Rays stadium.

    MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred talks with reporters at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Fla. on Wednesday, Aug. 23, 2017.
  5. Six home runs doom Rays in loss to Blue Jays (w/video)

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — A curve that didn't bounce was the difference Wednesday as the Rays lost 7-6 to the Blue Jays in front of 8,264, the smallest Tropicana field crowd since Sept. 5, 2006.

    Tampa Bay Rays shortstop Adeiny Hechavarria (11) greets center fielder Kevin Kiermaier (39) at the plate after his two run home run in the third inning of the game between the Toronto Blue Jays and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Fla. on Wednesday, Aug. 23, 2017.