Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Making sense of the Florida House's free-market health care ideas

Reps. Richard Corcoran, R- Land O Lakes, and Jose Oliva, R- Miami Lakes, huddle on the floor of the Florida House before the House left for the regular session in 2015. The two House leaders are spearheading efforts to overhaul the state's health care system into more of a free-market model. (SCOTT KEELER  |  Times)

Reps. Richard Corcoran, R- Land O Lakes, and Jose Oliva, R- Miami Lakes, huddle on the floor of the Florida House before the House left for the regular session in 2015. The two House leaders are spearheading efforts to overhaul the state's health care system into more of a free-market model. (SCOTT KEELER | Times)

TALLAHASSEE — Lawmakers this year are looking to free-market economics to shape the future of health care in Florida.

Republican leaders in the Florida House are pushing for an array of new laws that would cut regulations and negate insurance hurdles — from letting patients negotiate payment plans directly with their doctors to eliminating a statewide licensing program for hospitals.

"Our work here is to tear down a lot of these contraptions we've created that have really barred people from getting the kind of care they need at the cost they should be able to access it at," Rep. Jose Oliva, R-Miami Lakes, said in November. He's leading the health care reform effort for House members.

Their argument: Competition in the marketplace often leads to lower prices, higher quality and more innovation in other industries. Think about all the options for buying a car or a new smartphone.

But can that approach work in health care?

Some economists and political scientists aren't convinced.

"As a general rule, I'd say it's kind of a pipe dream that you're going to make this competitive," said William Weissert, a political scientist at Florida State University whose work focuses on health policy.

"It's unlikely that it will ever operate as a completely free market," said David Newman, executive director of the Health Care Cost Institute, which advocates for price transparency. "The impact is still potentially uncertain until we move ourselves closer to the end point where the market is functioning in all its glory."

Florida, he said, could be an interesting experiment.

The political backdrop to the push for health care reform is a heated Medicaid expansion debate last year that pitted the Florida Senate against House Republicans and Gov. Rick Scott. While senators proposed using federal money to fund health insurance for poor Floridians, House leadership backed a series of ideas they said would lower costs and increase access.

Now, with six weeks left in this year's regular legislative session, those same proposals are gaining momentum. With the support of leaders like Oliva and House Speaker-designate Richard Corcoran, R-Land O'Lakes, many of the ideas are likely to gain support from the House, and some could pass the Senate. They include:

• Eliminating a state licensing program called certificate of need, which limits the number of hospital beds in a given area of the state.

• Allowing surgical centers to keep patients for a full 24 hours and creating new recovery centers that can care for them 72 hours after surgery.

• Giving people the option to negotiate and contract directly with a doctor, rather than buying insurance for primary care.

• Letting nurse practitioners and physicians' assistants prescribe narcotics and other drugs.

• Requiring hospitals and surgical centers to publish the cost of procedures.

Taken together, they would allow more facilities to spring up in some parts of the state, particularly areas with unmet demand and a large number of insured people. They could also change how people pay for some of their health care, letting them shop around.

Will opening the door to competition backfire?

But competition will only go so far, said Weissert. And loosening too many regulations could worsen the quality of care.

"The structure of the market is such that it is not going to be competitive," he said.

Health care markets are hyper-local because very few people are willing to leave their communities for treatment.

To make matters worse, Weissert said, it's expensive and difficult to open a new health care facility. In most places, it might not be profitable for competing hospitals or surgery centers to set up shop. Even big cities have limited demand for facilities.

Weissert says reducing the government's role may ultimately make American health care more expensive and less effective.

"Taking away the government regulation, are the insurance companies just going to say 'Okay, we're going to pay for everything you send us?' " he said. "We did that in the 1950s. It didn't work."

Newman of the Health Care Cost Institute advocates free-market economics in health care, but he said, it's entirely possible opening the door to more competition will have little effect.

"In some markets, like Miami and Jacksonville and others it might prove interesting," he said "but probably at the margins."

Even greater price transparency, which his institute lobbies for, may not work, Newman said. A more informed consumer may not lead to lower prices. Rather, publishing how much competing hospitals or surgery centers charge for the same product could lead some on the low end to increase rates over time.

"What happens is the range of prices narrows and the average price goes up," he said.

Why the House could be right

Still, some experts say there's merit to the House's plans. Marshall Kapp, director of FSU's Center for Innovative Collaboration in Medicine and Law, calls our current health care system "a hodgepodge mixture of government control and private industry."

"It doesn't do a very good job," he said. "We don't know whether a free-market system would work in health care because we haven't truly tried it."

Kapp advocates for giving consumers more responsibility. That, he said, would give them an incentive to consider cost as they make decisions about their health care. That requires people to be smart about what insurance they buy and where they go for procedures to avoid being stuck with a big bill.

"You make the patient a true consumer who's got the ability and incentive to shop around," he said.

But consumer ignorance is among the reasons Weissert says freeing up the market might not work well. Consumers aren't used to shopping for health care like they do for most products.

"The biggest problem you've got to deal with is the fact that the consumer just doesn't know what they're buying," he said. "They're probably buying this product for the first time. They just don't have any market power."

Contact Michael Auslen at Follow @MichaelAuslen.

Making sense of the Florida House's free-market health care ideas 01/29/16 [Last modified: Saturday, January 30, 2016 10:41pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Observations from a liberal, gay, Latino, feminist Florida House freshman


    State Rep. Carlos Guillermo Smith, D-Orlando,  rocked the Florida LGBTA Democratic Caucus dinner at Tallahassee's Hotel Duval Satursday night with his unabashedly liberal and passionate take on the myriad issues he said are key to LGBTQ Floridians. Among them: Access to guns, Reproductive rights, home …

    Carlos G. Smith
  2. Delta Sigma Theta honors outgoing national president

    Human Interest

    During her four years as national president of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority, Inc., Paulette Walker said she always focused on the comma between "Sorority" and "Inc."

    Paulette Walker, the former director of undergraduate programs and internship in the College of Education at the University of South Florida, will be honored on Saturday for her leadership in the Delta Sigma Theta sorority.
  3. 10 sailors missing, 5 hurt in collision of USS John S. McCain

    SEOUL —Ten U.S. Navy sailors are missing and five have been injured after the USS John S. McCain destroyer collided with an oil tanker near Singapore early Monday morning.

    In this Jan. 22, 2017, photo provided by U.S. Navy, the USS John S. McCain patrols in the South China Sea while supporting security efforts in the region. The guided-missile destroyer collided with a merchant ship on Monday, Aug. 21, in waters east of Singapore and the Straits of Malacca. Ten sailors were missing, and five were injured, the Navy said. [James Vazquez/U.S. Navy via AP]
  4. Pasco County Fire Rescue fighting a two-alarm fire started by an explosion


    Two houses are on fire and one victim has been critically burned and taken to a trauma center following an explosion at a home at 8652 Velvet Dr, in Port Richey.

  5. Rays see the Blake Snell they've been waiting for in win over Mariners

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — It was a one-run game Sunday when the Mariners' Robinson Cano singled with one out in the seventh inning, bringing the dangerous Nelson Cruz to the plate.

    Tampa Bay Rays starting pitcher Blake Snell (4) throwing in the third inning of the game between the Seattle Mariners and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Fla. on Sunday, Aug. 20, 2017.