Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

McCollum's lawsuit against Obamacare raises legitimate questions

The score is now 2 to 1.

Two judges have said the federal health care law is constitutional. This week in Virginia, a third judge ruled it was unconstitutional.

This morning in Pensacola, Florida and 19 other states will go before yet a fourth federal judge with yet another challenge to the law.

No matter what, everybody expects the whole thing to end up before the U.S. Supreme Court.

Still, this week's ruling in Virginia proved that the case is not a slam-dunk either way — and it is already a partial vindication for our state's Republican attorney general, Bill McCollum.

When McCollum sued last March to block the health care law, quite naturally, many Democrats said it was only a political stunt meant to help his race for governor (which he later lost anyway).

Dan Gelber, then a Democratic candidate for attorney general, called McCollum's lawsuit a "political frolic" and "an ideological escapade" that would be thrown out of court.

Deborah Wasserman-Schultz, a Democratic House member from South Florida and a fixture on cable-TV news, called the lawsuit "a waste of taxpayer money."

And yet, the score today is 2 to 1.

In other words, there is at least one sitting U.S. district judge in the country (so far) who agrees the law is unconstitutional.

Maybe he is a nut, and the other two are right. Or maybe he is the smart cookie and the other two are wrong.

No matter what, there is a federal court ruling on the books that goes the other way. As my country cousins used to say, that's not nothin'.

Here is the main issue in the case:

Can Congress force Americans to get health coverage and punish us if we don't?

The fact is that Congress can't just pass any durn-tootin' law that it wants. Everybody agrees on that.

Congress only has certain powers. They are laid out in Article I, Section 8 of the U.S. Constitution.

One of these powers is to regulate "interstate commerce." Is that what this health care law does?

Critics like McCollum say Congress is trying to punish Americans for doing nothing. Hey, you want to live your life without health insurance, that's your business — and it sure as heck ain't "interstate commerce."

The opposing argument is that Americans who don't get health coverage aren't really "doing nothing." They are just putting off the day that they show up at the emergency room, or go on Medicare or Medicaid, and then become a burden on society, paid for by taxpayers across the nation.

So by this argument, Americans without coverage are making a decision that affects everybody else after all. Congress is entitled to bring them into the system now.

Now, who is right? Two judges say one thing; a third says another. Personally, I buy the argument that everybody comes into the system sooner or later, so it's legit to make 'em come in sooner. Hey, we all have to pay Social Security and Medicare taxes from the get-go.

But I am not a federal district judge, and besides, I still think McCollum raises a legitimate question. And I most definitely am not John Roberts, Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito or any other U.S. Supreme Court justice. If you want to predict breezily that they are gonna uphold this law, you go right ahead.

McCollum's lawsuit against Obamacare raises legitimate questions 12/15/10 [Last modified: Thursday, December 16, 2010 4:29pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Rays beat Orioles, but tough stretch looms that could change their plans (w/video)

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — Even with their losing streak extending to five the night before, Rays officials were continuing Tuesday on their same track in trade talks leading up to Monday's deadline seeking a proven reliever and a right-handed bat.

    Looking to buy.

    The Rays’ Tim Beckham celebrates with Mallex Smith after hitting a three-run homer in the second inning for a 5-0 lead.
  2. Diaz, Taddeo win easily in special Miami Senate primaries


    Two Miami state Senate candidates who raised and spent the most in their respective primaries — Republican Rep. Jose Felix Diaz and Democratic businesswoman Annette Taddeo — notched easy victories in a special election Tuesday night.

    Republican candidate Jose Felix Diaz is surrounded by supporters after he won the primary for Florida’s Senate District 40 race. Democrat Annette Taddeo, right, celebrates her victory with supporter Venus Lovely at BJ’s Restaurant in The Falls.
  3. In live debate, Kriseman and Baker ask St. Pete: Is the city better off?



    Mayoral candidates Rick Kriseman and Rick Baker made their best pitch to voters in front of a live television audience on Tuesday night. The candidates essentially asked this: Is the city better off now than it was four years ago?

    Incumbent Mayor Rick Kriseman, left, and former Mayor Rick Baker debate in front of a live television audience Tuesday at the Palladium Theater in St. Petersburg. The event was sponsored by the Tampa Bay Times and Bay News 9.
  4. Romano: It all comes down to sewage in this mayoral race

    Local Government

    Well, poop.

    Nothing else really matters, does it?

    Schools, economic development, public safety? Pfft. The Rays stadium, affordable housing, the pier? Ack. When it comes to the St. Petersburg mayoral election, sewage is the yin, the yang and the yuck.

    At Tuesday’s debate, incumbent Mayor Rick Kriseman said responsibility lies on him regarding the sewage crisis.
  5. Shooting sends man to hospital in St. Pete


    ST. PETERSBURG — Police were investigating a shooting that occurred around 4:40 p.m. on Tuesday and sent a man to the hospital.