Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PolitiFact Florida | St. Petersburg Times
Sorting out the truth in state politics

PolitiFact: Comparison of Marco Rubio, Barack Obama's experience Barely True

Former House Speaker Marco Rubio hasn't been elected to the U.S. Senate — he hasn't even won the Republican primary — but already his name is being floated as a possible 2012 presidential contender.

One of the latest mentions comes from Richard Land, a national conservative figure and president of the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention.

"The longer nobody catches fire, the more space there is for Marco," Land recently told Politico. "It wouldn't be unheard of for a freshman senator from Florida to be the nominee — particularly one who was speaker of the (Florida House).

"He's got more experience than Obama had," Land continued. "There are a lot of Hispanics in this country who would find someone with Marco's ethnic background very appealing. Although I like Sarah (Palin), I think Sarah's got a lot more impediments to a nomination than Marco Rubio does."

Rubio has tried to dismiss the Internet buzz of a possible run.

But that doesn't mean PolitiFact Florida can't dream. Which raises a real question: If the fresh-faced Rubio did run in 2012, would he have more experience than Obama did when he was elected in 2008?

To answer that question, we have to first presuppose Rubio 1) gets elected in November 2010 to the U.S. Senate and 2) decides to run for president in 2012.

If that happens, Rubio will have two years in the Senate plus nearly 11 previous years of political experience — a little less than two years as a part-time West Miami city commissioner (April 1998 — January 2000), and almost nine years in the Florida House of Representatives. (He was elected in a special election in early 2000 and served through 2008.) While in the House, Rubio served in the Republican leadership as whip, majority leader and eventually speaker.

All together that adds up to 13 years of political experience.

Before that, however, Rubio's work experiences are thin.

According to his official biography, Rubio attended South Miami Senior High School and graduated in 1989. He went to three colleges, eventually graduating from the University of Florida in 1993 with a bachelor of science, and then from law school at the University of Miami in 1996.

He then began to work for the private Miami law firm Tew Cardenas. He has worked as a lawyer with private firms on and off ever since. In 2008 and 2009, he co-instructed a class on Florida politics at Florida International University.

Contrast that with Obama.

During the 2008 presidential campaign, PolitiFact extensively researched Obama's work and political experiences.

Obama had 12 years of political experience prior to being elected president — nearly four years in the U.S. Senate (2005-2008) and eight years in the Illinois state Senate (1997-2004). Like Florida, Illinois' Legislature is considered part-time work.

That's in addition to his work before being elected to the state Senate. After graduating from Columbia University in 1983, Obama worked for a year as a financial analyst, then three years as a community organizer in Chicago before going to Harvard Law School. He graduated from law school in 1991, then ran Illinois Project Vote, a voter registration drive, for much of 1992. After that, he accepted a position with the Chicago firm Miner, Barnhill & Galland and also began teaching at the University of Chicago in 1993. He taught while in the Illinois Senate.

PolitiFact determined that Obama had at least 20 years of work and political experience. By the same calculation, Rubio would have 16 years of work and political experience if he were elected president in 2012.

Rubio would have one more year as a public official, but less work experience overall.

And all experience is not equal.

Obama, when elected president, had four years in the U.S. Senate. Rubio would just have two. Of the 16 U.S. senators to have been elected president, all served at least four years in the Senate, and most served at least one full term.

Then there's Rubio's time in West Miami (pop. 5,533). Being a city commissioner in a small town certainly doesn't have the complexities of state or federal government.

That said, Obama and Rubio's state experiences certainly are comparable — Rubio served almost nine years in Florida's state House, including two years as House speaker, to Obama's eight in Illinois' state Senate.

If elected in 2012, Rubio would be the country's youngest-ever president at age 41.

In making a hypothetical argument that Rubio could be elected president in 2012, Land said that Rubio — while young — would have more experience than Obama when he was elected in 2008 at age 47.

Rubio spent slightly more time in state government than Obama and had a more prominent role, so by that measure he has more experience than Obama did.

But if you look at time in the U.S. Senate (Obama's four years to what would be Rubio's two) and overall work and political experience (Obama's 20 years to Rubio's 16), Obama outmatches Rubio. And Obama has worked in a variety of roles, while Rubio has only been a lawyer.

As such, we rate Land's statement Barely True.

The statement

Rubio's "got more experience than Obama had."

Richard Land, in an April 7 interview with Politico

The ruling

Obama had at least 20 years of work and political experience when elected president in 2008, while Rubio would have 16 if he were elected president in 2012. Also, Rubio would have fewer years in the Senate and already has less varied work experience. We rule this Barely True.

PolitiFact: Comparison of Marco Rubio, Barack Obama's experience Barely True 04/18/10 [Last modified: Sunday, April 18, 2010 9:05pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Anna Maria City Pier to close for year after 'extensive damage' from Hurricane Irma


    ANNA MARIA — While Hurricane Irma's last-minute shift helped spare large swaths of Florida cities from catastrophic damage, the Anna Maria City Pier didn't fare so well.

    A damage assessment following Hurricane Irma suggests repairs for the Anna Maria City Pier can take at least 12 months. [LUIS SANTANA for Visit Florida]
  2. Photo of the Day for September 26, 2017 - Flying gecko on glass

    Human Interest

    Today's Photo of the Day comes from Wayne Rayburn of Tarpon Springs, FL. He calls it "Flying gecko on glass."

  3. Candidate in East Hillsborough House primary didn't vote in primaries


    TAMPA — Personal voting histories show a sharp difference between Yvonne Fry and Lawrence McClure, the two candidates in the Republican special election primary Oct. 10 for East Hillsborough's District 58 state House seat.

    Yvonne Fry, Republican candidate for state House District 58, has voted in 34 elections at all levels since 1994. She likes to vote on election day, she said, and considers it a national holiday. [Courtesy of Yvonne Fry]
  4. Water and some food scarce as Puerto Rico emerges from storm


    SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico — Supermarkets are gradually re-opening in hurricane-ravaged Puerto Rico but the situation is far from normal and many customers are going home disappointed.

    People wait in line outside a grocery store to buy food that wouldn't spoil and that they could prepare without electricity, in San Juan, Monday, Sept. 25, 2017. Most stores and restaurants remained closed Monday. Nearly all of Puerto Rico was without power or water five days after Hurricane Maria. [Associated Press]
  5. Tampa-based vXchnge secures $200M loan to expand operations


    TAMPA — Tampa-based vXchnge, which operates data centers in 14 metro areas, has secured a loan for roughly $200 million for "major expansions and enhancements."

    Tampa-based vXchnge, a data center provider, secured a $200 million loan. Pictured is CEO Keith Olsen. | [Courtesy of vXchnge]