Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PolitiFact Florida | Tampa Bay Times
Sorting out the truth in state politics

PolitiFact: Fact-checking Marco Rubio's immigration claims

One reason the United States needs immigration reform is to bring in more farm workers, says U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla. Rubio is supporting an immigration proposal unveiled last month by a bipartisan group of senators.

Rubio has been defending his framework to conservative audiences, including a Jan. 30 column for the website RedState.com.

"Agriculture has always required a significant workforce from abroad, but we do not have a system through which growers and dairies can bring a workforce legally into the U.S.," Rubio said.

We decided to check his history, as well as if there's a system for bringing in workers now.

Foreign workers

Over the past 15 years, about half of hired workers employed in U.S. crop agriculture were unauthorized, according to research based on the U.S. Department of Labor's National Agricultural Workers Survey.

Rubio's office sent us reports from government agencies and researchers about the history of immigrant workers in agriculture. Most notably, there was the Bracero program, which brought in temporary farm workers mostly from Mexico between 1942 and 1964, peaking at almost a half-million workers.

Braceros primarily farmed vegetables, fruits, cotton and sugar beets, and they were concentrated in seven states: Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, New Mexico, Michigan and Texas. By the 1960s, mechanization reduced the need for these workers for some crops.

We interviewed historians who said it is difficult to generalize about the agricultural workforce, because it differs by time period, location and type of farm.

Paul Conkin, a Vanderbilt history professor emeritus, said that Rubio's claim "is either completely wrong or misleading."

"Through most of our agricultural history, the workforce largely consisted of farm owners, family members, or one or two hired hands from the neighborhood," he said. "Only since World War II have migratory workers become a major component of farm labor."

Several of the historians we interviewed noted that in the South, farms relied on slave labor and later sharecroppers, and many of those people were born in the United States.

System in place?

As for the other part of Rubio's claim, the United States has a system to allow farmers to hire seasonal workers: the H-2A visa program. But it has been widely criticized as inadequate.

Farmers apply for certification from the Labor Department to ensure that U.S. workers aren't available. Employers then submit a petition to the Department of Homeland Security to bring in foreign workers. Foreign workers then apply for visas from the State Department.

Employers must meet a list of requirements, including providing workers with housing, transportation, and workers' compensation insurance.

The number of H-2A visas have soared from about 6,500 in 1992 to about 55,400 H-2A visas issued in 2011, based on preliminary data.

Despite that growth, the program is small relative to total farm employment. For example in 2007, (the most recent Census of Agriculture from the U.S. Department of Agriculture) there were about 2.6 million hired farm workers and about 50,800 H-2A visas granted.

"Critics of the H-2A program cite the low levels of participation as evidence of the program's inadequacy to meet the needs of U.S. agricultural employers," the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service said. "Others, however, attribute the program's low utilization to the availability of unauthorized workers, who are willing to work for lower wages than legal workers."

Many farm groups and a bipartisan group of senators, including Sen. Bill Nelson, D-Fla., have complained that the process is too difficult and doesn't provide enough workers.

Our ruling

In fact-checking Rubio's comments, we found that he overgeneralized when he suggested that throughout American history, all types of farms needed foreign workers. Also, contrary to Rubio's claim, there actually is a system for growers to legally hire foreign workers. However, many farmers have complained that the visa program is inadequate, cumbersome and in dire need of a makeover. Overall, we rate his statement Mostly False.

This article has been edited for print. To read our full version go to www.politifact.com/florida.

The statement

"Agriculture has always required a significant workforce from abroad, but we do not have a system through which growers and dairies can bring a workforce legally into the U.S."

Marco Rubio, in an op-ed for RedState.com

The ruling

Politifact ruling: Mostly False
Some farms have required foreign workers in the past, but not all. Also, though the H-2A visa program is widely criticized as flawed, there is a system for farmers to hire foreign workers. We rate his claim Mostly False.

PolitiFact: Fact-checking Marco Rubio's immigration claims 02/24/13 [Last modified: Sunday, February 24, 2013 9:58pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. World's plastic waste could bury Manhattan 2 miles deep

    Environment

    WASHINGTON — Industry has made more than 9.1 billion tons of plastic since 1950 and there's enough left over to bury Manhattan under more than 2 miles of trash, according to a new cradle-to-grave global study.

    Plastic trash is compacted into bales ready for further processing at the waste processing dump on the outskirts of Minsk, Belarus.
  2. Sen. John McCain's type of cancer did not slow Tampa woman

    Health

    TAMPA —When 35-year-old Beth Caldwell heard about Sen. John McCain's brain tumor this week, she hoped he would stay positive.

    That's what helped her, she said.

    Beth Caldwell, 35, and her sons Gavin, 10, and Triston, 7. Caldwell had surgery to remove an aggressive brain tumor three years ago. [Photo Courtesy of Beth Caldwell]
  3. A week later, the lengthy, costly rebuilding plan for the Pasco sinkhole begins

    Public Safety

    LAND O'LAKES — A week after a massive sinkhole opened in Pasco County, county officials have begun planning the long-term cleanup, which could take months and millions of dollars.

    A sinkhole in Land O'Lakes, Fla., is seen Wednesday, July 19, 2017. The sinkhole ?‘ already one of the largest in Pasco County in decades ?‘ measures about 235 feet in width and 50 feet in depth, with the potential to expand further.
  4. Dade City's Wild Things blocks PETA officials at gates for court-ordered site inspection

    Wildlife

    Times Staff Writer

    DADE CITY — Dade City's Wild Things founder Kathy Stearns refused to let People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals officials enter her facility on Thursday for a court-ordered inspection, court filings show.

    Dade City's Wild Things founder Kathy Stearns refused to let People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals officials enter her facility on Thursday for a court-ordered inspection, court filings show. This comes four days after 19 Wild Things tigers arrived at the Greater Wynnewood Exotic Animal Park in Oklahoma. A judge had granted an emergency injunction July 14, ordering Stearns not remove any tigers pending the upcoming PETA inspection. Photo from Facebook page of the Greater Wynnewood Exotic Animal Park in Oklahoma.
  5. St. Petersburg City Council approves $326 million sewage fix

    Blogs

    ST. PETERSBURG — Last week the City Council learned no criminal charges would result from the up to 200 million gallons of sewage St. Petersburg's sewer system released from …

    [LARA CERRI  |  Times]