Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy) | Tampa Bay Times
Sorting out the truth in politics

PolitiFact: Fact-checking the claims you've seen on Facebook

In the past two weeks, more than 3,800 people on Facebook have shared a list called "10 Illegal Alien Facts," which includes a claim that more than 43 percent of food stamps go to illegal immigrants.

Except it's not a fact at all. PolitiFact found it stretches the truth into the realm of a mathematical impossibility and rated it Pants on Fire. Two other claims on the list, which suggest illegal immigrants are getting government handouts, earned a rating of Mostly False and a Pants on Fire.

The spread of "10 Illegal Alien Facts" shows how Facebook has become the new town square in American politics, a place where individuals and groups can hang their political posters. Call it JPEG propaganda — image files such as JPEGs that people post on their Facebook walls.

Unlike chain emails, which multiplied during the 2008 campaign and were often a medium for conspiracy theories, the Facebook posters feature everything from individual rants to calculated messages from large industry groups. They're quickly developing a distinctive voice and style.

Last week, a female state representative in Michigan was barred from the House floor after saying "vagina" during debate over an abortion bill. A Facebook group called "A Girl's Guide to Taking Over the World" quickly created a poster that had "Vagina" in huge letters, and said, "Because apparently, saying that word in the Michigan State House of Representatives can get you a two-day ban from speaking on the floor." Democrats and Republicans had differing opinions on the reason for the ban, but the wording of the Facebook post was careful enough to merit a Mostly True rating.

The American Energy Alliance, an advocacy group funded by oil and natural gas interests, has four active Facebook pages, with lots of charts and posters that supporters are encouraged to post on their own Facebook walls. Some examples:

• A $100 bill in which Benjamin Franklin's face is replaced with a logo for the EPA.

• An overhead illustration of a baseball park, identifying products made with oil and gas.

• An iPhone, with the words "Made with Oil" on the screen.

• A simple graphic headlined "EPA regulations," with a down arrow on jobs and an up arrow on energy costs.

Benjamin Cole, a spokesman for the American Energy Alliance, says the Facebook posts are effective because they're interactive or have compelling graphics. "That's just basic advertising," he said.

Some were produced in-house, Cole said, while others are the products of paid advertising campaigns. Either way, creating and disseminating them is a "microscopic fraction of the cost" of the millions the group spent on television ads this spring.

"This is cheap," Cole said. "The pages are free. You can choose to pay for advertising on Facebook, but it's not essential because the higher your interaction rate the more likely you're going to show up on somebody else's page. It's like mice reproducing in a lab."

Catalog of images

They're simple and blunt. Some are inspiring, but more often they're designed to stir outrage.

They cover issues across the spectrum: abortion, the environment, gay rights, the culture wars, energy production, food production, war, peace, guns, education, the economy.

Some are words only, like virtual bumper stickers. "I'm already against the next war," offers one from the Occupy Posters Facebook page.

But images are powerful tools and many groups have stocked their Facebook pages with posters that can be plucked — for free — by their supporters. Occupy Posters couples gas pumps, U.S. maps, scales out of balance, even a drawing of a uterus with statistics and punchy taglines. Some posts simply juxtapose photos of candidates with quotes from their speeches.

Mitt Romney's Facebook page contains mostly videos and photos from his campaign rallies that rarely weave in factual claims. Same goes for his Tumblr, a blogging and photo-sharing site. Barack Obama's re-election campaign, however, is churning out shareable infographics that can be shared, ensuring more eyes see the message.

Not chain emails

In 2008, many people relied on a different form of social media to spread political messages: chain emails. They came largely from the right with suggestions that Obama was unpatriotic and had a suspicious background. One even claimed he fit the Bible's description of the Antichrist, a claim we rated Pants on Fire.

Many chain emails have circulated for years even though they have a dreadful record for accuracy. More than half of the 124 chain emails tested on the Truth-O-Meter earned Pants on Fire ratings.

By contrast, Facebook posters come from both ends of the political spectrum and emerge almost as immediately as the issues they reflect.

"They're often quite up to the minute," said Brendan Nyhan, a professor at Dartmouth College who studies how political messages influence people.

He says Facebook posts have something else chain email lacks — credibility.

"Chain emails have become stigmatized as a form of communication," said Nyhan. "So I would say people are more circumspect about forwarding things in email because there have been so many crackpot theories in these things. I think many people who wouldn't forward a chain email would click the (share button) on Facebook. It's a lower form of commitment."

(The PolitiFact record for Facebook posts is mixed. Of the 14 we've checked, six have earned a rating of False or Pants on Fire.)

On Facebook, people are also more careful about who they might offend — relatives, kids' teachers, fellow church members.

While chain emails often take on a dark, conspiratorial tenor, Facebook posts aren't meant to stay out of the mainstream. They're intended to spread what Ben Smith, editor of the news site BuzzFeed, calls "partisan, shareable content."

Said Cole, from the energy alliance, "You can proliferate your Facebook presence. It's really only limited by your ability to manage it."

The statement

"More than 43 percent of all food stamps are given to illegals."

A post on Facebook

The ruling PolitiFact ruling: Pants on Fire
It isn't mathematically possible given the number of illegal immigrants in the United States, and illegal immigrants cannot receive food stamps legally. We rate this claim Pants on Fire.

The statement

"Less than 2 percent of illegals are picking crops, but 41 percent are on welfare."

A post on Facebook

The ruling PolitiFact ruling: Mostly False
The picking crops statistic is pretty close to correct, but the welfare figure is highly misleading. The "welfare" isn't going directly to illegal immigrants, rather it's going to U.S. citizens who live in illegal immigrant households. We rate this claim Mostly False.

The statement

"Nearly 60% of all occupants of HUD properties in U.S. are illegals."

A post on Facebook

The ruling PolitiFact ruling: Pants on Fire
The real number appears to be less than 1 percent. We rate this claim Paints on Fire.

The statement

"Vagina. Because apparently, saying that word in the Michigan State House of Representatives can get you a two-day ban from speaking on the floor."

A post on Facebook

The ruling PolitiFact ruling: Mostly True
It was one day, not two, and there is some disagreement whether it was the use of the word vagina that led to the punishment. We rate this claim Mostly True.

PolitiFact: Fact-checking the claims you've seen on Facebook 06/24/12 [Last modified: Monday, June 25, 2012 12:07am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. A historic Tampa family saves a historic Tampa home built by an ancestor

    Human Interest

    The Knight family has replaced their roof and people are celebrating.

    The Peter O. Knight historical cottage, located in Tampa's Hyde Park neighborhood, is seen Thursday, July 20, 2017. The cottage fell into disrepair in recent years, but the Knight family stepped up with financial support to help stabilize the structure.
  2. Miami woman, 74, admits to voter fraud. Does jail await, or will she go free?

    State Roundup

    MIAMI — An 74-year-old woman pleaded guilty Monday to filling out other people's mail-in ballots while working at Miami-Dade's elections department.

    Gladys Coego
  3. In Twitter rant, Bucs' Gerald McCoy says he's unappreciated


    Gerald McCoy is feeling underappreciated again. He says somebody has crossed the line this time. He's speaking out and suggesting he might be gone "soon enough" from Tampa Bay.

    Photo Illustration RON BORRESEN   |   Photo by LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times 
Gerald McCoy may be upset that Ronde Barber said a defensive leader “has to have a huge personality’’ like Warren Sapp’s. Monday, Barber walked that back.
  4. Bigger ships carry Georgia ports to record cargo volumes

    Economic Development

    SAVANNAH, Ga. — Bigger ships arriving through an expanded Panama Canal pushed cargo volumes at Georgia's seaports to record levels in fiscal 2017, the Georgia Ports Authority announced Monday.

    The Port of Savannah moved a record 3.85 million container units in fiscal 2017, the state said, benefiting from the larger ships that can now pass through an expanded Panama Canal.
  5. Photo gallery: Nine years later, library attack victim Queena works at learning to walk again


    Slowly, Queena Phu is learning the act of walking again through exercises in locomotion, strength and balance.
    She practiced her steps once again Monday afternoon with trainer-technician Mike Lopez at the nonprofit Stay In Step Spinal Cord Injury Recovery Center near the University of South Florida.
    Queena …

    Activity based exercise trainer George Palang, 33, and trainer technician Mike Lopez, 22, help Queena Phu during physical therapy at the Stay In Step Spinal Cord Injury Recovery Center on Monday, July 24, 2017, in Tampa, Fla.