Overcast74° FULL FORECASTOvercast74° FULL FORECAST
Make us your home page
Instagram
PolitiFact.com | Tampa Bay Times
Sorting out the truth in politics

PolitiFact Florida: As tax collections grow, Scott gives undue credit to his policies

Florida is set to collect more tax money next year than ever before, state officials say. And not only is Florida Gov. Rick Scott proud of the accomplishment, but he is taking credit.

"After right-sizing government and cutting taxes, this year we had our first budget surplus in six years," Scott told conservatives recently. "It gets better: Our state revenue estimating conference says we will have the highest general revenue in state history next year. Conservative pro-growth policies work in our state."

Scott is right: State economists (the wonkishly called revenue estimating conference) say tax collections in the 2014-15 fiscal year will be higher in sheer dollars than ever. But crediting "conservative pro-growth policies" for the extra flow of money is a conclusion that ignores trends nationwide, as PolitiFact Florida found out.

Future tax collections

The state's revenue estimating conference meets throughout the year to come up with a best guess for how much money the state can spend.

It's an important job because Florida is required to balance its budget each year, so lawmakers need to have a good accounting of how much money is available.

Amy Baker, the director of the Office of Economic and Demographic Research and a member of the estimating conference, confirmed Scott's claim about general revenue for fiscal year 2014-15. According to projections, the state is expected to collect a record $27.3 billion.

The pot has not been that large since the 2005-06 budget year, when collections totaled $27.07 billion.

However, it's not a record when adjusted for inflation.

Revenue projections for 2014-15 are significantly lower than revenues in the 2005-06 fiscal year and slightly lower than revenues in the 2007-08 fiscal year, said Chris Mai, a research assistant at the State Fiscal Project at the left-leaning Center for Budget Policies and Priorities.

"That same amount of money in nominal terms is not enough to provide the same services — education and health care — as in 2008," said Elizabeth McNichol, a senior fellow at the center.

Where does that money come from?

Most states collect an income tax, but Florida does not. It leans heavily on its 6 percent base sales tax, which is climbing primarily because of growth in personal income, population and tourism, Baker said.

In an attempt to associate that tax revenue growth with Scott's conservative policies, the governor's office directed us to a Moody's Investors Service report that praised Florida's fiscal management, including building up rainy-day reserves. The report predicted the state would likely outpace the nation in long-term growth because of its climate and low cost of living.

Yet, Moody's said, the construction and real estate markets remain a drag on Florida's economy, and the state is more vulnerable than the rest of the country if a new housing bubble emerges from outside investors.

"Florida's difficulty in the last few years doesn't stem from its tax code," said Lyman Stone, a state tax economist at the business-backed Tax Foundation. "It stems from having a real estate- and construction-driven economy in a real estate- and construction-driven recession."

Who gets credit?

Collecting a record amount of money is a sign Florida's economy is en route to normalcy, which in Florida translates to more people moving into the state and good tourism figures.

But in the larger picture, Florida is not that special. The slow-and-steady recovery story is the same for most of the country, experts told us. In fact, several other states — and plenty run by Democrats — are doing better.

Most states returned to or exceeded 2008 revenue levels by the 2012-13 fiscal year, said Todd Haggerty, policy analyst for the fiscal affairs program at the National Conference of State Legislatures. The growth continued for 33 states in 2013-14, though at a more modest clip.

Not every state has released 2014-15 revenue expectations. Of those that have, 26 states and Washington, D.C., project revenue growth between 0.1 and 5 percent, Haggerty said. That's where Florida falls, along with New York and Texas.

That is behind a group of 11 states — Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Idaho, Maine, North Dakota, Ohio, Oregon and Vermont — that expect growth between 5 and 10 percent.

The NCSL does not examine in-depth why revenue is growing in each state, Haggerty said, though he noted some states (California) increased tax rates while others benefited from an energy boom (North Dakota).

No one can fault Scott for talking up the state successes in attracting tourism and business. But could he bring about record-setting tax collections through a toolbox of tax cuts and shrinking government, or as he put it, "conservative pro-growth policies"? Even economists on the conservative side are skeptical.

"We think certainly he's doing the right things from an economic standpoint," said Kurt Wenner, vice president of tax research at Florida TaxWatch. "But it's certainly hard to dial a direct relationship between how much revenue comes from that."

Stone of the Tax Foundation pointed to a few examples of tax breaks passed under Scott that are "straight-up revenue losses," such as the four-day sales tax holidays and an assortment of tax credits.

Other longer-lasting, pro-business cuts are more likely to have economic benefits in the future, he said, such as temporarily removing a sales tax on machinery and equipment for manufacturers, removing businesses from the corporate income tax roll, and reducing unemployment compensation taxes. (The temporary tax cut for manufacturers won't even take effect until 2014.)

"I'm skeptical that these changes drove a big enough economic recovery in revenue changes," Stone said.

Our ruling

Scott said that Florida "will have the highest general revenue in state history next year. Conservative pro-growth policies work in our state."

Scott's statistic is wrong if you account for inflation. But the bigger issue is that Scott overreaches by connecting the revenue resurgence with conservative policies. The trajectory is not unique to Florida, or conservatives.

There's an element of truth to this statement but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression. We rate this claim Mostly False.

This fact-check has been edited for print. Read the full version at PolitiFact.com/Florida.

The statement

"We will have the highest general revenue in state history next year. Conservative pro-growth policies work in our state."

Gov. Rick Scott on Aug. 30, in a speech at the Americans for Prosperity Foundation summit

The ruling

PolitiFact ruling: Mostly False

Scott's statistic is wrong if you account for inflation. But the bigger issue is that Scott overreaches by connecting the revenue resurgence with conservative policies. The trajectory is not unique to Florida, or conservatives. We rate this claim Mostly False.

PolitiFact Florida: As tax collections grow, Scott gives undue credit to his policies 09/08/13 [Last modified: Monday, September 9, 2013 10:47am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2014 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...