Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PolitiFact Florida | Tampa Bay Times
Sorting out the truth in state politics

PolitiFact Florida: Charlie Crist touts per-pupil spending vs. Rick Scott

Charlie Crist has gone on the offensive against Gov. Rick Scott, launching a TV ad campaign and pulling no punches in interviews.

In one free-wheeling discussion with the Tampa Bay Times editorial board last week, former Gov. Crist attacked Scott's education spending.

"I can only imagine how nice it would be to serve as governor when you have a surplus of almost $3 billion. That's what this guy has right now," Crist said. "And in spite of it, he still hasn't matched what I did during the recession for per-pupil funding for kids. In fact, he's about $200 less."

PolitiFact Florida has done many checks on claims about school spending by these two candidates, but we wanted to know if Scott really budgeted $200 less per student than Crist. Good thing both governors have permanent records for us to check.

Budget crunch

As a quick overview, the Florida Education Finance Program is the main source of dollars for K-12 education. By law, it's a combination of state and local funding. Each school district must contribute property tax dollars, called the "required local effort," in an amount dictated by the state. In recent years, the state has also received federal stimulus dollars.

Scott has been touting the $18.9 billion K-12 education spending budget he signed this year as the largest in state history. We rated that Half True, because it was the largest in terms of dollars spent, but not after inflation and not per pupil.

When we break down the most recent budget, it works out to $6,937 in spending per pupil. Even though the budget is higher, Florida schools now have a higher enrollment, roughly 90,000 more students than in 2007, according to state projections at the start of the 2014-15 school year.

Crist has been contending that his per-pupil spending was higher, referring to the $7,126 per student allocated in his $18.7 billion education budget for 2007-08. That works out to an $189 difference.

But considering both governors' terms as a whole, there's more to the story. Education budgets declined during Crist's administration, with a corresponding drop in per-pupil spending, save for a slight bounce his last year in office.

Scott, meanwhile, came into office looking to slash $3.3 billion out of the education budget, resulting in a $700 per pupil cut. But lawmakers balked. He settled for knocking $1.3 billion out of the budget, dropping per-student dollars by $540, due in part to a loss in federal stimulus money that had been shoring up spending for Crist's last two budgets. Then Scott's numbers started to steadily rise (See accompanying box).

In context, Crist said Scott "still hasn't matched what I did during the recession for per-pupil funding for kids." Crist signed his first budget in 2007, a year before the Great Recession began. In 2008, education funding dropped to less than what the 2014 budget now offers. If you compared the 2008-09 budget with Scott's current budget, Crist is actually behind.

However, these numbers don't account for inflation. If they did, that 2007-08 number would equal $8,176 in 2014 dollars, $1,200 more than what is currently budgeted per student.

Even at the lowest spending during Crist's tenure in 2009-10, the inflation-adjusted total in state and local funding would be around $7,209, still a higher value than Scott's last budget.

Our ruling

Scott's current budget does spend almost $200 less per student than Crist did in 2007, but that was before the recession really hit. Spending was less during the other three years of Crist's term — although still higher than some of Scott's years.

It's worth noting that Scott cut school funding when he came into office, but has gradually increased it to a level that's currently higher than what Crist signed off on during the Great Recession.

When you account for inflation, though, Crist's per-pupil spending outpaces Scott's for every year. We rate the statement Mostly True.

Read more fact checks at PolitiFact.com/florida.

The statement

Says Rick Scott's per-pupil education spending is "about $200 less" than what it was under Charlie Crist during the recession.

Charlie Crist, Wednesday in a Tampa Bay Times editorial board interview

The ruling

PolitiFact ruling: Mostly True
Scott's current budget does spend almost $200 less per student than Crist did in 2007, but that was before the recession really hit. Spending was less during the other three years of Crist's term — although still higher than some of Scott's years. When you account for inflation, though, Crist's per-pupil spending outpaces Scott's for every year. We rate the statement Mostly True.

Per pupil spending for Crist and Scott

Fiscal yearK-12 budget (total)Spending, per pupil
2007-08 (Crist)$18.7 billion$7,126
2008-09 (Crist)$17.9 billion$6,846
2009-10 (Crist)*$18 billion$6,846
2010-11 (Crist)*$18.2 billion$6,897
2011-12 (Scott)$16.6 billion$6,217
2012-13 (Scott)$17.2 billion$6,376
2013-14 (Scott)$18.3 billion$6,761
2014-15 (Scott)$18.9 billion$6,937

The two years with an asterisk were years when the state received about $900 million in federal stimulus money.

PolitiFact Florida: Charlie Crist touts per-pupil spending vs. Rick Scott 07/20/14 [Last modified: Sunday, July 20, 2014 7:11pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Tampa Bay Times journalists wins 17 Green Eyeshade Awards

    Human Interest

    Tampa Bay Times journalists placed first in seven categories of the prestigious Green Eyeshade awards, which honors outstanding journalism in the Southeast.

  2. What you need to know for Tuesday, May 23

    News

    Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what you need to know today.

    A manatee swims near the entrance to Three Sisters Springs on Kings Bay, some of many springs that feed the Crystal River in Citrus County. The Southwest Florida Water Management District is considering a proposal that would allow a decrease to the amount of fresh water flowing in the Crystal River so that water can be diverted to fuel development. Critics say similar proposals around the state could threaten Florida's environmental health. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD | Times (2014]
  3. Ailing Florida springs could be tapped further to fuel development

    Water

    BROOKSVILLE — Efforts by state officials to set a minimum flow for its iconic springs have stirred up a wave of public opposition. Opponents contend the state is willing to destroy its springs in order to justify continuing to provide water for new development.

    A manatee swims near the entrance to Three Sisters Springs on Kings Bay, one of many springs that feeds the Crystal River in Citrus County. The Southwest Florida Water Management District is considering a proposal to decrease the amount of fresh water flowing in Crystal River so that water can be diverted to fuel development. Critics say similar proposals around the state could threaten Florida's environmental health. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD | Times (2014
  4. Canned by lawmakers, PTC staff say they are now forgotten

    Transportation

    TAMPA — After roughly 20 years in the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office, Mike Gonzalez got another job with a uniform and badge when he was hired in 2015 as an inspector for the Public Transportation Commission.

    The badge that PTC inspectors carry while on duty. State lawmakers voted to abolish the agency this year leaving its remaining employees fearing for their future.
  5. Ferries from Florida not a priority for Cuban government

    Tourism

    Cruises and commercial flights now link Tampa and Havana, but before the U.S. government approved either for such journeys, ferries had the nod.

    Baja Ferries was among a handful of companies the U.S. government approved to service Cuba two years ago.
But Cuba's ambassador to the United States recently said the wait may be long. Ferries are not a high priority for Cuba.
This is an example of one of the overnight passenger ferries the  Baja Ferries wanted  to use to reach Cuba from Florida.


Photo Credit: Baja Ferries USA LLC