Clear73° WeatherClear73° Weather
<PolitiFact Florida | Tampa Bay Times
Sorting out the truth in state politics

PolitiFact Florida: George LeMieux's attack ad against Connie Mack is False

Judging from his latest Web ad, George LeMieux thinks his rival for the Republican nomination for U.S. Senate is a loser on par with Hollywood bad boy Charlie Sheen.

LeMieux's ad parodies Two and a Half Men — the show Sheen infamously quit in a snit — to target U.S. Rep. Connie Mack, whom the ad mockingly calls "Half Mack." It shows an animated "Half Mack" in a series of buffoonish outfits as the ad makes its stinging charges.

PolitiFact Florida decided to fact-check a claim from the ad that Mack "failed to pay his child support." The ad shows many notices sailing by, each stamped "urgent," "overdue," or "past due."

Here's the background on the claim:

Mack — whose real name is Cornelius Harvey McGillicuddy IV — filed for divorce from his wife, Ann McGillicuddy, in August 2005 in a Lee County court.

On July 12, 2006, the lawyer for the congressman filed a response to his estranged wife's motion for contempt. The document states that Mack agreed to pay $1,700 a month in temporary support to his estranged wife starting May 1, 2006. His annual congressional salary in 2005 was $162,100.

That payment was apparently late. When we asked LeMieux's campaign for evidence, they referred us to the Miami Herald's reporting on Mack's divorce. The documents included a single late payment in connection with the $1,700.

The court record filed by Mack's attorney showed he transferred $400 to his wife's account July 3 while on vacation. Once he realized he made a mistake, according to the court filing, he transferred $1,000 on July 10, $164.49 on July 11, and $135.51 on July 12, as well as $175 on July 12 to cover any returned checks.

We should note that the document said "temporary support" and "temporary alimony," and not child support, though news reports from the time indicated Mack had two children, ages 3 and 5.

The LeMieux campaign said the money should count as child support. "Financial support of the children is part of family support, and Connie Mack did not make the payment on time," LeMieux spokeswoman Anna Nix said in an email.

Mack campaign spokesman David James said this was an alimony payment — not child support.

James told PolitiFact that the divorce wasn't final on the dates in question, and negotiations were still ongoing. "The terminology of 'late' is one attorney's interpretation of the facts."

We were unable to reach Mack's ex-wife or her attorney. We did speak with Carolyn Swift, the congressman's attorney. She said the $1,700 was agreed upon for temporary alimony, in addition to him paying other expenses, including the mortgage on their Virginia residence. She also sent us a copy of a May 2006 order that described the $1,700 payment as "temporary alimony."

The marital settlement agreement filed in late July said that Mack would pay the mortgage in lieu of child support until the home was sold, Swift said. An addendum in 2007 set child support at $1,645 a month.

LeMieux's ad said that Mack "failed to pay his child support," and the visuals of multiple "past due" notices suggest a pattern. But LeMieux can't prove that charge.

Instead, LeMieux points to a court document that showed Mack was once 12 days late in paying for part of a $1,700 "temporary alimony" payment. LeMieux's campaign argued that Mack's late alimony payment could have been used to pay for their children's expenses.

We think saying that Mack "failed" to pay his child support is a stretch. It's based on a single partial late payment of less than two weeks, and the payment was classified as alimony by the courts. We rate this claim False.

For complete sources and more rulings, go to PolitiFact.com/Florida.

The statement

Says Connie Mack "failed to pay his child support."

George LeMieux in a campaign Web ad on Feb. 27, 2012

The ruling

PolitiFact ruling: False

The claim is based on a single partial late payment of less than two weeks, and the payment was classified as alimony by the courts. We rate this claim False.

PolitiFact Florida: George LeMieux's attack ad against Connie Mack is False 03/04/12 [Last modified: Monday, March 5, 2012 10:42pm]

© 2014 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...