Tuesday, October 16, 2018
Politics

Supreme Court denies stay in Florida gay marriage case; couples could marry after Jan. 5

The U.S. Supreme Court on Friday chose not to meddle in Florida's tug-of-war over marriage equality, declining to delay the Jan. 6 start of same-sex vows.

Attorney General Pam Bondi had asked the court to block gay marriage while Florida fights to protect a 2008 constitutional amendment that allows only heterosexual couples to wed. In a one-paragraph order, the court decided not to step into the Florida case.

Same-sex marriage advocates immediately cheered the court's ruling as a step toward marriage equality.

"We are ecstatic what the Supreme Court has done today," said Daniel Tilley, an attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union of Florida, which filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of same-sex couples and the LGBT-rights group SAVE. "We are so happy for our plaintiffs and all our same-sex couples who can go ahead and get married and have their marriages recognized in their home states."

Reaction was more muted from Bondi, who issued a statement:

"Tonight, the United States Supreme Court denied the state's request for a stay in the case before the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals. Regardless of the ruling, it has always been our goal to have uniformity throughout Florida until the final resolution of the numerous challenges to the voter-approved constitutional amendment on marriage. Nonetheless, the Supreme Court has now spoken, and the stay will end on January 5."

In August, U.S. District Judge Robert Hinkle of Tallahassee ruled in favor of nine same-sex couples suing for Florida to recognize their out-of-state marriages and declared the state's gay marriage ban unconstitutional.

Hinkle said in his ruling that years from now the arguments supporting the ban will be viewed as an "obvious pretext for discrimination."

Anticipating that his decision would be appealed, he put a stay on the same-sex vows through Jan. 5.

The state previously asked the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to extend the stay, without success.

Most federal judges and appeals courts have ruled against state bans, and gay marriages are occurring in about three dozen states. Like many other judges and appellate courts, Hinkle ruled the state's gay marriage ban violates the U.S. Constitution's guarantee of equal protection.

Bondi sought to keep the stay in place at least until the Supreme Court decided whether take up cases from Ohio's 6th Circuit. The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati has upheld the right of four states to decide whether to allow gay marriage.

Friday's decision by the court does not resolve the larger legal battles still brewing over same-sex marriage in Florida.

Tilley said he's anticipating oral arguments early next year before the 11th Circuit on his clients' lawsuit against the state's 2008 constitutional amendment.

Additionally, this week a law firm for the association representing Florida's 67 court clerks issued an advisory opinion that said Hinkle's ruling applies only to Washington County and not to the rest of Florida.

That opinion complicates how clerks are to proceed after Jan. 5 and could set Florida on a path where some clerks ignore Hinkle's ruling, believing it to only apply to Washington County.

Betsy White, one of several civil rights attorneys in Jacksonville representing two of the gay couples named in the federal lawsuit, insisted the clerks' law firm "is dead wrong," and that its opinion essentially encourages 66 separate lawsuits, one for each Florida county not named in the current suit.

If court clerks deviate from Hinkle's ruling, White said her firm is prepared to petition the federal court to force clerks statewide to comply with it. "This is an injunctive case. When injunctions are issued by a federal judge, they carry the weight of the federal law," she said.

Still some clerks say they feel uneasy going forward with the marriage licenses.

Hillsborough County Clerk Pat Frank said she has been told she could be prosecuted for malfeasance or misfeasance in office — a first-degree misdemeanor — if she marries same sex couples.

"I don't mind going to jail, I don't mind paying the thousand dollar fine," she said. "What I do mind is if the governor determines that it's malfeasance in office, he could suspend me, and I'm not about to allow that to happen. We're in the midst of an important transformation and I couldn't do that to my staff."

She also said that marrying couples under such uncertainty would likely complicate their situation.

Frank said she's hopeful that the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals or the U.S. Supreme Court will take up the issue so clerks can have clear guidance.

"This is the most obvious violation of civil rights," she said. "I can't see how a higher court can't identify this.

"Justice delayed," she said, "is justice denied."

Times staff writer Tony Marrero contributed to this report, which used information from the Associated Press.

Comments
Judge throws out Stormy Daniels' lawsuit against Trump

Judge throws out Stormy Daniels' lawsuit against Trump

A federal judge on Monday dismissed a lawsuit from adult film actress Stormy Daniels that claimed President Donald Trump defamed her when he suggested she had lied about being threatened to keep quiet about their relationship. Federal District Judge ...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Candidates for Pinellas commission race pause to help with natural disasters

Candidates for Pinellas commission race pause to help with natural disasters

As Election Day nears, the candidates for Pinellas County Commission have shifted from campaigning to helping residents deal with the aftermath of natural disasters.Democrat Amy Kedron held a town hall meeting and helped draft policies for businesses...
Published: 10/15/18
Trump calls on blacks to ‘honor’ him with votes, then praises Confederate general Robert E. Lee

Trump calls on blacks to ‘honor’ him with votes, then praises Confederate general Robert E. Lee

LEBANON, Ohio - President Donald Trump praised the Confederate general Robert E. Lee whilst asking African-American voters to "honor us" by voting for him at an Ohio rally which included an unexpected and provocative monologue on America’s Civil War ...
Published: 10/13/18
Carlton: Playing politics when a hurricane’s coming? There oughta be a law

Carlton: Playing politics when a hurricane’s coming? There oughta be a law

Maybe Florida needs a new law. The Disaster Decency Bill, we could call it.Because given the current political divide wider than the Gulf of Mexico, we might need it to mandate what has long been a tradition of coming together in the face of disaster...
Published: 10/12/18
MSNBC's Katy Tur hosting live panel with USF students during 'Battleground College Tour'

MSNBC's Katy Tur hosting live panel with USF students during 'Battleground College Tour'

MSNBC's Katy Tur will speak to USF students during a live panel in front of USF's Marshall Student Center on Friday from 2 to 3 p.m.
Published: 10/12/18
Monica Lewinsky comes to Tampa on Monday to talk #MeToo, media scrutiny

Monica Lewinsky comes to Tampa on Monday to talk #MeToo, media scrutiny

TAMPA — Monica Lewinsky, an anti-bullying social activist best remembered as the White House intern whose affair nearly brought down a presidency, will be in Tampa on Monday to deliver the keynote address at the 17th annual Franci Golman Rudolph Scha...
Published: 10/11/18
Updated: 10/15/18
Retired Tampa cop gunning for Hillsborough sheriff’s job touts outsider status

Retired Tampa cop gunning for Hillsborough sheriff’s job touts outsider status

One day this summer Gary Pruitt delivered a two-minute pitch to Plant City voters, describing what could change if he were picked to be Hillsborough County’s next sheriff. Among his promises: He would diversify the ranks. But the uniformed competitor...
Published: 10/11/18
Joe Henderson: It's getting easier getting to Tampa but try getting around once you're here

Joe Henderson: It's getting easier getting to Tampa but try getting around once you're here

If you haven’t been to Tampa International Airport in a while, do yourself a favor and go. The place is sleek, well organized, and has the look of an airport you might expect to see in some exotic city – which, I guess, we can say Tampa...
Published: 10/11/18
Carlton: Job one in Straz campaign to be Tampa’s mayor? Show up

Carlton: Job one in Straz campaign to be Tampa’s mayor? Show up

Tampa philanthropist and gazillionaire David Straz has gotten lots of deserved accolades for his acts of generosity over the years.His name graces the downtown performing arts center in lights and adorns the sign at a manatee hospital at Tampa’s zoo ...
Published: 10/10/18
Daniel Ruth: Whatever degree she may or may not have, mayor qualifies in chutzpah

Daniel Ruth: Whatever degree she may or may not have, mayor qualifies in chutzpah

Perhaps the tip-off Temple Terrace Mayor Mel Jurado's alleged doctoral degree was (ahem) about as worthless as a Venezuelan $1 bill was when she started pimping her dubious bona fides on her personalized license plate, "DRMEL." Really? Not....
Published: 10/10/18