Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Success of Florida's pension plan measured against moving target

When Florida's pension managers announce they have beaten their performance benchmarks, they often get a pat on the back from the boss.

Last year, the fund said it had the "greatest return over benchmark'' in 25 years. And in March, as consultants described how the fund had outperformed its benchmarks steadily over time, Gov. Rick Scott chimed in: "That's great.''

In public pension world, a benchmark is the standard that governors and taxpayers use to measure the fund's performance. They also use benchmarks to decide pay packages and bonuses.

The term comes from the marks surveyors chiseled in stone to show the exact latitude and longitude of a location.

But the benchmarks for Florida's pension fund are not etched in stone.

Florida's governor and other elected officials who oversee the pension fund have changed benchmarks more than 25 times since 1985.

Pension consultants say they review benchmarks for various types of investments every few years for "continued appropriateness.''

But critics say benchmark switching can also be a sign that the State Board of Administration, which manages pension investments, is trying to make mediocre returns look better than they are.

"Ambiguity in benchmarking is a common method for covering up underperformance,'' said Rick Ferri, founder of Portfolio Solutions in Troy, Mich. "If a plan keeps changing their benchmarks, or uses complicated and confusing benchmarks, then perhaps those who are questioning performance will go away scratching their heads.''

Mark Hebner, president of Index Fund Advisors in Irvine, Calif., says he thinks Florida's benchmarks are too easy.

"When managers beat easy benchmarks everybody looks good,'' he said.

Sydney P. Freedberg, Times staff writer

Success of Florida's pension plan measured against moving target 07/30/11 [Last modified: Saturday, July 30, 2011 8:17pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Woman killed in overnight Temple Terrace apartment fire, city says


    TEMPLE TERRACE — A woman died early Sunday as a result of a fire at an apartment complex, city officials said.

  2. Video: Indianapolis 500 drivers in fiery crash somehow walk away uninjured

    Auto racing

    Scott Dixon and Jay Howard avoided injury in a spectacular crash - or what Dixon labeled "a wild ride" afterward - during the Indianapolis 500 on Sunday.

  3. Homeland security chief defends Kushner's alleged proposal for 'back channel' to the Russians as 'a good thing"


    Homeland Security Secretary John Kelly, the lone administration official to speak out publicly about reports that Jared Kushner sought a back channel to communicate with the Russian government, defended the move, saying it was a "good thing" for the U.S. government.

    Jared Kushner, President Donald Trump's senior adviser and son-in-law, listens during a meeting with small business leaders at the White House on Jan. 30. [Washington Post photo by Jabin Botsford]
  4. After hard charging on health care in 2016, Marco Rubio is slow, careful


    As a presidential candidate, Marco Rubio pitched an Obamacare replacement and tore into Donald Trump for not having one. "What is your plan? What is your plan on health care? You don't have a plan," the Florida senator aggressively challenged in a February 2016 debate.

  5. Report: Florida counties part of liver disease cluster


    STUART — Four counties along Florida's Treasure Coast make up a cluster with high rates of both deaths from liver disease and algae blooms.