Tuesday, August 21, 2018
Politics

The myth of female solidarity

The dream of female solidarity is, and always has been, a myth.

Hillary Clinton's campaign tried to tap into that dream. She dressed in white, evoking the suffragists and the hope of shattering the highest glass ceiling. She played up issues like child care and equal pay that polling showed had cross-party, cross-gender support. Her ads pounded away at Donald Trump's misogyny, hoping to lure women who would be reminded of all they had suffered in their own lives.

Fifty-three percent of white women voted for Trump.

The dream that women would vote for a woman overlooked the seductive pulls and interactions among party, class and racial identity that have long divided women as much as their gender was assumed to unite them.

"From the 19th century on, women saw themselves as different, cleaning up and perfecting the public sphere," said Theda Skocpol, a professor of sociology and government at Harvard. "The early suffragists believed as soon as the vote came in, women would show the same sense of solidarity. But that didn't prove to be true at all."

The first rule of political scientists who study gender is that party identification is the surest predictor of how someone will vote. And at the end of the day, Republican women voted Republican.

"Whether there's a D or an R in front of your name is way more a cue to the voters than the presence or absence of the Y chromosome," said Jennifer L. Lawless, a professor of government at American University.

Celinda Lake, a veteran Democratic pollster, said, "Democrats never win white women."

While Democrats have won some blue-collar white women in the past, in this election, class emerged as a powerful and divisive force that swung decisively Republican. All the talk about angry white men glossed over the fact that they were married to angry white women.

Education was the great divide, for women as for men. Trump won 62 percent of white women without college degrees; Clinton, 34 percent.

"Class shapes gender identity," said Nancy Isenberg, author of White Trash, which examined how elites have derided rural, working-class Americans from the Colonial era to this day. "I think a lot of people who support Trump think of themselves as being disinherited. They resent the fact that everything they believe in is mocked by the media elite, Hollywood, those boogeymen."

In the aftermath of the vote, the internet was flooded with plaintive and angry accusations of betrayal from African-Americans and Latinas who noted that they had voted for Clinton by large majorities.

"That sense of betrayal is sincere and comes from a place in which there was an optimism about solidarity from white-collar women," said Salamishah Tillet, an associate professor of English and Africana studies at the University of Pennsylvania. "It's not like black people or Latino people aren't sexist and patriarchal. But when we thought about our self and collective best interest, we voted for Clinton."

Racial fears and competition played a role for women as they did for men.

"There is a racial element to this," Isenberg said of the white working-class women's votes for Trump. "They do what's right. Go to church. Try to support their families.

"They turn around and the rug is being pulled out from them. Groups who they see as economic competition, African-Americans and immigrants, they're getting an advantage that is not extended to poor rural whites."

Comments
Are Democrats retaliating against Wengay Newton in re-election fight?

Are Democrats retaliating against Wengay Newton in re-election fight?

ST. PETERSBURG — Fallout from the 2017 mayoral race is stirring up emotions in the Democratic primary for state House District 70.Candidate Vito Sheeley is calling into question just how much of a Democrat incumbent state Rep. Wengay Newton really is...
Published: 08/21/18
Romano: Draining the swamp can be dangerous in Florida

Romano: Draining the swamp can be dangerous in Florida

Drain the swamp. That’s the rallying cry, right?More term limits, fewer career politicians. A ruling class of regular folks. There’s just one small problem. The average Floridian is more dangerous than whatever you’ll run into in a swamp. Other place...
Published: 08/21/18
As Trump fumes on Twitter, first lady warns of ‘destructive and harmful’ side of social media

As Trump fumes on Twitter, first lady warns of ‘destructive and harmful’ side of social media

As her husband continued to rip into his adversaries on Twitter, first lady Melania Trump on Monday warned that social media can be used in a "destructive and harmful" manner during remarks at a conference on preventing cyberbullying."In today’s glob...
Published: 08/20/18

Pasco Political Notebook for Aug. 24

Political NotebookMariano to discuss reelection campaignState Rep. Amber Mariano will speak to the Republican Club of Central Pasco Aug. 27 at Copperstone Executive Suites, 3632 Land O’ Lakes Blvd., Land O’ Lakes. Social time begins at 6:30 p.m., wit...
Published: 08/20/18
Romano: A fresh start for Florida to protect abused children

Romano: A fresh start for Florida to protect abused children

The worst job in Florida is available, once again.Mike Carroll has announced his pending resignation as secretary of the Department of Children and Families, giving someone else the privilege to be an underfunded, second-guessed punching bag. For no ...
Published: 08/18/18
Pinellas commission candidate faced stalking, abuse claims

Pinellas commission candidate faced stalking, abuse claims

ST. PETERSBURG — A political newcomer seeking a Pinellas County Commission seat has faced accusations of physical abuse and stalking from her former fiance, who twice sought court-ordered protection from her.Both allegations came after Democrat Amy K...
Published: 08/17/18

Two Seminole council members face challengers

SEMINOLE — Six candidates have filed to run for two open seats on the City Council.Incumbents Chris Burke, first elected in 2012, and Trish Springer, elected in 2015, face challenges from former council member Dan Hester, who served from 2005 to 2010...
Published: 08/16/18
In Republican race for Pinellas County Commission seat, Rep. Kathleen Peters outpacing field

In Republican race for Pinellas County Commission seat, Rep. Kathleen Peters outpacing field

As the Aug. 28 primary election approaches, three Republicans are battling to represent a Pinellas County Commission district that hasn’t witnessed a competitive contest for more than 15 years.State Reps. Larry Ahern of Seminole and Kathleen Peters o...
Published: 08/16/18
Romano: Con artist or Florida politician? You decide

Romano: Con artist or Florida politician? You decide

Decorum matters, and so the attorney’s language was appropriately measured.In seeking to have a constitutional amendment thrown off the ballot, a motion filed in Leon County used words such as "misleading’’ and "ambiguity’’ and "wordsmithing.’’That’s...
Published: 08/16/18
Veteran Hernando politicians take oversized contributions, run afoul of campaign finance laws

Veteran Hernando politicians take oversized contributions, run afoul of campaign finance laws

BROOKSVILLE — With primary Election Day at the doorstep, two Republican candidates vying for seats on the Hernando County Commission found themselves in uncomfortable spots over potential filings with the Florida Commission on Ethics.And a third Repu...
Published: 08/15/18