Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

The new normal: Fighting state laws that defy common sense

Is anyone else starting to hate the phrase "the new normal" — as in, "Get used to this miserable state of affairs, because it's the new normal"?

The new normal is gas near four bucks a gallon. It's politicians pledging not to exercise the individual judgment we elected them for. It's jobs currently as uncommon as common sense.

Apparently, the new normal is also an elected official saying something that can't be true, except it is said with such confidence it surely must be true. (Or is that the old normal, with a modern Jabberwockian twist?)

Under Gov. Rick Scott, our state has adopted a new law requiring poor people to first pass a drug test before they can get cash welfare assistance.

Hey, in hard times like these, it's always nice to have somebody worse off to kick around, right?

So here is what the governor said after a legal challenge to this law was recently filed in federal court:

"Yawn," he said, the governor or a policy he supported having been sued 11 times thus far.

No, what he really said about a law that requires citizens to make a deposit in a cup to determine if they deserve help from their government was, "This is for the benefit of children. Welfare is for the benefit of children, and the money should go to the benefit of children. This makes all the sense in the world."

Well, sure it does. Who's against children?

Except … um … how exactly does putting up another obstacle for poor people, many who are trying to feed the very sort of children the governor mentioned, help children? How does a six-month ban on anyone who doesn't pass help put dinner on the table or school clothes on the backs of those children?

The new normal would have you disregard this little factoid: Only 2.5 percent of applicants have failed their drug test thus far. And studies indicate 8.7 percent of the general population uses drugs.

Another detail of the law: Welfare recipients, who by definition are struggling, must pay for the privilege of being tested and be reimbursed if they pass. Since, you know, they have so much ready cash lying around.

Those enthusiastic about this particular piece of legislation must be wincing about who ended up suing over it (besides, of course, the American Civil Liberties Union). Luis Lebron is a Navy vet from Orlando, a single father and college student who is caring for his young son and disabled mother, asking the country he served for a little help. He hardly sounds like your poster guy for potential welfare cheat or someone you'd like to hand one more humiliation and one more hoop to jump through.

The lawsuit's power is in the Fourth Amendment, which protects even poor people against "unreasonable searches" done without reasonable suspicion. Similar laws have bitten the dust, my personal favorite being from Georgia, the one about drug testing candidates for office. Even they deserve protection.

Those Scott suits targeting other eyebrow-raising policies are working their way through the courts. Just this week, a federal judge said contrary to the latest legislative logic (and the National Rifle Association), doctors do have a First Amendment right to ask their patients about guns. Scott of course vowed to appeal. And welcome to Florida's new normal.

The new normal: Fighting state laws that defy common sense 09/15/11 [Last modified: Thursday, September 15, 2011 11:24pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Joe Henderson: Other good works can't balance theft from vulnerable victims


    What price can you put on your good name?

    This renovated group home once was operated by HARC. The group's former CEO Richard Lilliston was credited with raising millions for the agency but has been sentenced to prison for stealing Social Security from clients with developmental disabilities. [Times file]
  2. Five reasons why Kentucky can beat Florida for the first time since 1986


    By Matt Baker

    GAINESVILLE — Florida's 30-game winning streak over Kentucky is one of the most impressive feats in the country.

    Florida Gators offensive lineman Martez Ivey (73) celebrates Florida Gators running back Mark Thompson's  (24) touch down in the first quarter, putting Florida on the board 6-0 during the game between the University of Florida and the University of Kentucky in Ben Hill Griffin Stadium on Saturday, Sept. 10, 2016, in Gainesville, Fla. Florida defeated Kentucky 45-7. ANDRES LEIVA   |   Times

  3. Once targeted by the Bucs, Dalvin Cook thrills for the Vikings


    How good would the Bucs be with running back Dalvin Cook?

    Minnesota Vikings running back Dalvin Cook (33) slips a tackle by Steelers strong safety Sean Davis (28) to score a touchdown Sunday in Pittsburgh. [AP photo]
  4. Review: More than 20 years later, 'RENT' still matters


    TAMPA — Two decades after Rent shook up Broadway with a starkly joyous musical that demanded to be recognized, a nostalgic tour is taking audiences back.

    The 20th anniversary tour of RENT, shown in 2016, comes to the David A. Straz Jr. Center for the Performing Arts Sept. 19-24, 2017. Photo by Carol Rosegg.
  5. Dennis Miller, headed to Tampa with Bill O'Reilly: 'We don't know each other that well'


    Dennis Miller often gets cast as the odd comic out these days.

    Dennis Miller will perform with Bill O'Reilly at the Spin Stops Here Tour at Amalie Arena in Tampa. [Spuffy Productions]