Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Politifact: Ad that says Rand Paul has suggested $2,000 Medicare deductible is mostly true

The statement

Rand Paul "wants us to pay $2,000 just to get Medicare."

Jack Conway, in a campaign commercial

The ruling

In the Kentucky Senate race, Democrat Jack Conway is attacking Republican Rand Paul over Medicare deductibles.

The ad opens with footage of Paul: "The real answer to Medicare would be a $2,000 deductible."

Man: "A $2,000 deductible?"

Man: "Rand Paul wants us to pay $2,000 just to get Medicare?"

Woman: "That's crazy."

Woman: "I can't afford that."

Footage of Rand Paul: "The real answer to Medicare would be a $2,000 deductible."

Man: "I don't know what planet he's from."

The grainy footage of Paul comes from a talk he gave in Lexington, Ky., on June 19, 2009.

To see whether Conway's ad takes Paul's remarks out of context, we transcribed the portion of his speech in which he talked about Medicare.

"What's the problem in medicine?" Paul began. "No price fluctuation. If you're over 65 and go to a doctor in this country, you pay the exact same price with every doctor in the whole country. So when they want to blame … that on capitalism, we have to be smart enough and say, 'We don't have capitalism. We already have socialism.' "

He continued, "Medicare is socialized medicine. People are afraid of that because, 'Oh, you'll say you're against Medicare.' No, I say we have to do something different. We can't just eliminate Medicare. But we have to figure out how to get more to a market-based system. It's counter-intuitive to a lot of people, but you have to pay for things if you want prices to come down. So you really need higher deductibles. And the real answer to Medicare would be a $2,000 deductible, but try selling that one in an election. But … you have to pay for things. And when you do, …you also get rid of price controls. So you raise the deductible, you get rid of price controls, and you allow more competition. … There have to be ways to allow medicine to come down."

Paul has refined his policy toward Medicare. During an appearance on Fox News on Oct. 6, he said that he does not want to impose deductibles on current Medicare beneficiaries but rather on future beneficiaries, possibly starting with those who are currently 55 or younger.

We think the general impression the ad gives is that what Paul wants to do is slap seniors with a $2,000 deductible, though his plan is much more comprehensive. So the ad is somewhat misleading. That said, we see it as a relatively minor exaggeration. Paul has advocated for a $2,000 deductible in multiple settings, and on balance we rate the ad Mostly True.

Louis Jacobson, Times Staff Writer. Edited for print. For more, go to

Politifact: Ad that says Rand Paul has suggested $2,000 Medicare deductible is mostly true 10/12/10 [Last modified: Tuesday, October 12, 2010 8:59pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Bill Clinton coming to Miami Beach on Saturday for mayors' convention


    From our friends at the Miami Herald:

    Former President Bill Clinton gives the opening address to kick off a meeting of International Aid Groups at the InterAction Forum 2017 at the Washington Convention Center on June 20.
  2. Obama's secret struggle to punish Russia for Putin's election assault


    WASHINGTON — Early last August, an envelope with extraordinary handling restrictions arrived at the White House. Sent by courier from the CIA, it carried "eyes only" instructions that its contents be shown to just four people: President Barack Obama and three senior aides.

    Russian President Vladimir Putin, left, and Barack Obama shake hands at the COP21 UN Conference on Climate Change in Paris, France, Monday, Nov. 30, 2015. [Mikhail Klimentyev | Sputnik, Kremlin Pool Photo via AP]
  3. GOP's challenge: Finding votes for Senate health care bill (w/video)


    WASHINGTON — Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has finally unwrapped his plan for dismantling President Barack Obama's health care law. Now comes his next challenge — persuading enough Republicans to back the measure and avert a defeat that could be shattering for President Donald Trump and the GOP.

    Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., speaks to reporters at the Capitol after Republicans released their long-awaited bill to scuttle much of President Barack Obama's Affordable Care Act, at the Capitol in Washington, Thursday, June 22, 2017. He is one of four GOP senators to say they are opposed it but are open to negotiations, which could put the measure in immediate jeopardy. [Associated Press]
  4. Trigaux: Halfway through 2017, a closer look at six drivers of the Tampa Bay economy


    We're nearly halfway through 2017 already, a perfect time to step back from the daily grind of business and ask: How's Tampa Bay's economy doing?

    Is there one theme or idea that captures the Tampa Bay brand? Not really but here's one possibility. The fun-loving annual Gasparilla "Invasion" of Tampa is captured in this photo of 
The Jose Gasparilla loaded with pirates of Ye Mystic Krewe of Gasparilla on its way this past January to the Tampa Convention Center. In the future a vibrant downtown Tampa or St. Petersburg may be the better theme. [CHRIS URSO   |   Times]
  5. Harmeling first woman to receive lifetime honor at Sneaker Soiree in Tampa

    Human Interest

    TAMPA — For the last quarter-century, she has combined passion and meticulousness to keep the Gasparilla Distance Classic humming and evolving. Indefatigable and detailed, Susan Harmeling braces for every race-weekend contingency.

    Susan Harmeling gives a speech after accepting an award  during the annual Sneaker Soiree, at TPepin's Hospitality Centre, Thursday, June 22, 2017.