Saturday, November 17, 2018
Public safety

There’s no norm for how hot-car death cases play out, advocates say. What does that mean for Spring Hill baby case?

SPRING HILL — It’s been nearly a month since a baby died after he was left in a hot car, and officials still have not said if anyone will face charges related to the boy’s death.

History suggests an answer could come any day, according to an advocate who tracks hot-car deaths on a national scale. Or it could be months away.

"All of these cases, really, are handled so differently," said Amber Rollins, director of KidsAndCars.org, which focuses on injuries to children left unattended in or near cars.

Rollins said she knows of cases where parents or caretakers were arrested and charged within hours of a death, as well as at least one case where a parent was charged a year after his child died.

The Hernando County Sheriff’s Office spokeswoman on Friday responded to an inquiry into the Spring Hill incident with: "No updates."

Under Florida law, parents can face misdemeanor charges for leaving a child in a car unattended for more than 15 minutes — or for any time at all if the engine is running or the child is otherwise in danger. According to the same law, they could face felony charges if the child suffers bodily harm or disfigurement.

But parents face charges only about half the time, according to data tracked by Rollins. Advocates and neuroscientists argue that hot-car deaths often are the result of normal, tragic memory lapses, sometimes caused by a disruption in routine.

Rollins said charging decisions depend on myriad factors — including local law, political climate and who is in the prosecutor’s and sheriff’s offices — and not just the details of the case.

"You could literally have identical circumstances," she said, "and one case would have the most extreme charge possible and the other not at all."

The circumstances of 9-month-old Keyton O’Callaghan’s death on Aug. 17 are still muddy. His was one of more than 40 hot-car deaths of children nationwide this year, according to KidsandCars.org.

He was in the custody of his mother, 38-year-old Cami Lee Moyer, at the time of his death, according to the Sheriff’s Office. It’s unclear how long the baby was in the car in front of his mother’s home on Elgin Boulevard. Investigators have not released a cause of death or said how hot the car was inside.

Moyer has not responded to several attempts to contact her. The day of the boy’s death, his paternal grandfather said the situation was "about as bad as it gets."

Last week, he said he wouldn’t comment further until the investigation is finished.

Sheriff Al Nienhuis said last month his office wanted to give prosecutors "the most prosecutable case" possible. A woman who answered the phone at the office of assistant state attorney Peter Magrino last week said the case eventually would go to Magrino. He could decide whether or not to file charges, she said, but the Sheriff’s Office was still investigating and had not given it to the prosecutor.

Angela Galluzzo, a Spring Hill resident who doesn’t know Keyton’s family, organized a vigil for the boy last month after seeing his death on the news. She said she drives by the house every day while taking her own kids to school.

She and others in the community were outraged at the death and frustrated at the lack of charges, Galluzzo said.

Since the vigil, she said, much of the anger has subsided. She and others hope to put their energy toward advocating for legislation that could prevent such deaths.

She hopes the silence from the Sheriff’s Office suggests they’re building a solid case.

"I have a good feeling that’s why we’ve not heard a peep," she said.

Contact Jack Evans at [email protected] Follow @JackHEvans.

RELATED:In Spring Hill, 9-month-old baby boy dies after being left in car

Comments
Plant City police: Fleeing driver kills man as he walks to work

Plant City police: Fleeing driver kills man as he walks to work

The driver is in custody, but the fugitive who sparked Friday’s deadly incident is still being sought.
Updated: 6 hours ago
Pinellas deputies investigating death at Clearwater home

Pinellas deputies investigating death at Clearwater home

Deputies responded to a deceased person call about 9:30 p.m. Thursday at 1506 Meadow Dale Drive in unincorporated Clearwater.
Updated: 7 hours ago
Police didn’t think man was seriously injured in Pinellas Park crash. Hours later, he died.

Police didn’t think man was seriously injured in Pinellas Park crash. Hours later, he died.

A Seminole man died after he struck a traffic pole in Pinellas Park on Thursday morning.
Updated: 9 hours ago

DCF: No mistakes in case of 4-year-old girl whose mother drowned her

A review of the child protective investigation of the mother of Je'Hyrah Daniels says there was no evidence to show the girl was at risk of harm before her death.
Updated: 9 hours ago
Dragster driver Katarina Moller, 24, killed in crash at Sebring raceway

Dragster driver Katarina Moller, 24, killed in crash at Sebring raceway

24-year-old driver Katarina Moller of Sarasota died Thursday night. She was a popular racer at local short tracks and a jet dragster driver for Larsen Motorsports, according to track officials.
Updated: 10 hours ago
Hernando commissioner cuts deal on prostitution-related charges, walks away with a clean record and a $729 bill

Hernando commissioner cuts deal on prostitution-related charges, walks away with a clean record and a $729 bill

Nick Nicholson says he'll try to get his commission seat back.
Updated: 10 hours ago
Firefighters discover three murder victims in burning Tampa house

Firefighters discover three murder victims in burning Tampa house

Deputies are looking for a man caught on surveillance video carrying gas can outside the house. The bodies were found Thursday by firefighters.
Updated: 11 hours ago
White supremacist gang members in Tampa Bay charged in gun, drug ring

White supremacist gang members in Tampa Bay charged in gun, drug ring

Investigators say the suspects are connected to the Unforgiven and United Aryan Brotherhood gangs.
Updated: 11 hours ago
Review places no blame on child welfare system in fatal dog attack on Clearwater infant

Review places no blame on child welfare system in fatal dog attack on Clearwater infant

A review of 7-month-old Khloe Williams' contact with the child welfare system provides new details on her path to foster care and the tragic dog attack that killed her.
Updated: 12 hours ago
In Tampa, man embarks on life after years on death row

In Tampa, man embarks on life after years on death row

Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin knows what it's like to be accused. He spent 10 years on death row before new evidence, including DNA tests, helped set him free. Now he must adjust to life on the outside.
Published: 11/16/18