Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

DUI report: Dentist reached 89 mph before he hit pedestrians on Harbour Island Bridge

TAMPA — Seconds before crashing into pedestrians on the Harbour Island Bridge last fall, killing two, a Riverview dentist hit a top speed of 89 mph, prosecutors learned.

Matthew Moye's blood alcohol level — 0.13 percent — exceeded the level at which the state presumes impairment, records show.

"I'm the designated driver tonight," he said at the scene, according to a police dashboard camera. "I was driving those two girls around after having a party. I haven't had anything to drink."

Those were among the details included in documents, video and audio files released Monday by the Hillsborough County State Attorney's Office in the case against Moye, 35.

He is charged with causing the deaths of Douglas Kozar and Kate Kohlier, who were on a bridge sidewalk early Oct. 30 when Moye's 2011 Cadillac coupe spun out of control and hit them, authorities said. A third pedestrian broke an ankle jumping out of the way.

The three had just left work at the Marriott Waterside Hotel.

The records depict a bloody and chaotic scene.

Kohlier, 24, died of head injuries after she was slammed against the bridge's wall. The impact threw Kozar, 23, over the wall, and he landed in a "rope-like retaining fence," the Medical Examiner's Office reported. Heart lacerated, he died at the scene.

A data recorder that police recovered from the Cadillac put the car's speed at 89 mph seconds before the crash.

The speed limit on the bridge is 30 mph.

Twelve weeks earlier, Moye had been cited for driving 90 mph in a 45 mph zone. He pleaded no contest, paid $341 and attended the Advanced Defensive Driving School, county records show. That was his seventh speeding ticket, state records show.

The night of the fatal crash, Moye had two people with him in the car: his wife, Kelly, and a friend, Rachel Sady, both employees of his dental practice.

The three had attended a Halloween party at the Sheraton Hotel staged by 13 Ugly Men, a Tampa social and charitable group.

Moye's wife told investigators that the party was "lame" and that the three were headed to another party at Jackson's Bistro.

Officers noted that Moye wore black contact lenses as part of a Halloween costume. Outside the contacts, his eyes appeared red and bloodshot, the report said. His breath smelled of alcohol.

Moye refused to take a breath test, police reported.

At the scene, he was initially unaware anyone had been hurt. An officer wrote in his report that Moye became argumentative.

"Why do you keep looking at me?" Moye reportedly said. "I didn't do anything wrong. All I did was pass a cab and lose control."

Kelly Moye sat on a bench and complained about damage to the car, the report stated. It's unclear whether anyone told her about victims.

"I told Matt not to drive," she told police. "I told him he shouldn't of drove. But look at my car. … My poor hundred thousand car is totaled. I worked so hard for that."

Matthew Moye began to fight with police officers, hitting an officer's hand and pushing his chest, the report said. Officers wrestled him to the ground and put him in handcuffs.

His wife jumped on an officer's back and was also handcuffed, the report said. The passenger, Sady, was handcuffed after she tried to walk away. Neither woman has been charged.

In statements to detectives, the two said they did not remember much about the crash.

They said they had not seen Moye drink that night.

"Honestly, I drank more than probably everyone else in the car," Kelly Moye said, "so I really don't know what happened."

Her husband faces seven charges: two counts each of vehicular homicide, DUI manslaughter and DUI with property damage or personal injury, and one count of battery on a law enforcement officer.

No trial date has been set.

While the criminal case is pending, a judge ordered Moye not to drive or consume alcohol, and to remain home between the hours of 7 p.m. and 7 a.m.

He is still a practicing dentist with an active license.

At the crash scene, after he was read his rights, Moye complained, profanely, about his treatment by police and said he planned to sue, according to video.

His demeanor changed when, finally, an officer told him that two people had died in the accident.

"Are you serious?" Moye asked.

"I'm very serious," the officer responded. The officer started to explain that Moye would be required to submit to a blood draw.

"You're kidding me," Moye said.

The officer said he knew it was a shock.

"It's a HUGE shock," Moye said.

Staff writers Colleen Jenkins, Jessica Vander Velde and Alexandra Zayas and news researcher John Martin contributed to this report.

DUI report: Dentist reached 89 mph before he hit pedestrians on Harbour Island Bridge 02/28/11 [Last modified: Tuesday, March 1, 2011 1:06pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Criticism part of the game for Bucs' Gerald McCoy, who is chasing 'ghosts'


    Who crossed the line with their criticism of Gerald McCoy?

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers defensive tackle Gerald McCoy jokes with teammates during the first day of training camp at One Buccaneer Place in Tampa, Fla., on Friday, July 28, 2017.
  2. Police make arrest in murder of 20-year-old Tampa man


    TAMPA — A 20-year-old Tampa man has been arrested and charged with felony murder after a fatal shooting during a drug deal at a north Tampa apartment complex this week, records show.

  3. Tampa man arrested in fatal shooting at apartment complex


    TAMPA — A Tampa man faces a first-degree murder charge in a fatal shooting at a north Tampa apartment complex on Wednesday.

    Alexeis Perez, 20, faces a charge of first-degree murder in the fatal shooting of Antonio Roman on July 26, 2017, at Tzadik Oaks, 1250 E 113th Ave., in Tampa. [Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office]
  4. Wimauma motorcyclist killed in Hillsborough County crash


    A Wimauma motorcyclist was killed Thursday night in a crash in Hillsborough County, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.

  5. 3 wonderfully weird shows premiering next week: 'The Lowe Files,' 'What Would Diplo Do?' 'Comrade Detective'


    It seems like nothing is off limits on TV these days. Next week, three new shows air that I can't believe are really happening. They're all weird in their own ways, and I'm delighted. But let's be honest, at the point I'd probably watch a TV show about people coming up with TV shows. America has spoken, and we'll watch …

    Matthew, from left, Rob, and John Owen Lowe explore supernatural legends in A&E's new reality show "The Lowe Files."