Friday, May 25, 2018
Public safety

Tampa Bay area one of worst for pedestrians, especially in poor neighborhoods

They never saw the Honda, and its driver never saw them. The sport utility vehicle smashed into Jayla Shubbar before she and her older sister reached the convenience store across the street.

State officials had been planning to install another crosswalk on that stretch of North Tampa's Busch Boulevard, an urban highway that cuts through the impoverished neighborhood where Jayla, 8, was struck that Saturday morning and died the next day. But they hadn't broken ground.

"We should be allowed to go around just as safely as anyone else," her mother, Darcien Shubbar, 33, said this week.

Her anguish epitomizes what researchers for Governing magazine found in a study this month — that the Tampa Bay area not only is one of the worst places in the nation to walk across the street, but also that the deadly danger gets far worse when pedestrians walk in poor neighborhoods.

In Hillsborough County, pedestrian deaths are nearly three times more likely to occur in the poorest areas than in the wealthiest, the study found.

The disparity was less pronounced in Pinellas County, but nonetheless, pedestrian deaths were nearly twice as likely to occur in its poorest areas.

According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the 2014 poverty level for an individual is $11,670 in earnings a year. For a household of four, it's $23,850.

People shy away from talking about issues like race or poverty in trying to come up with solutions to prevent so many pedestrian deaths, Shubbar believes.

"But if they don't want it to be a race thing or a poverty thing," she said, "then let it be a life thing."

•••

The reasons why this fatal disparity exists seem intractable.

The government for too long neglected poor neighborhoods, some politicians say, and developers skipped over them.

One of the most valuable government services for low-income residents, public transportation, can also lead to deadly consequences. Riders looking to catch a bus have been known to dart across straightaways such as U.S. 19 to reach bus stops, said Ken Jacobs, a traffic engineering section manager for Pinellas County.

"More affluent people have a car in the garage," he said. "They can jump in that car to get to their destination. But lower- and middle-income workers have to use more mass transit, and Pinellas County isn't necessarily laid out as well as it could be for mass transit."

Among Hillsborough politicians with poorer constituencies, the narrative is usually the same.

Part of the problem stems from thoroughfares cutting through densely populated, poorer areas.

"As more people move here, we've made it so that they move faster — right through poor neighborhoods," said Les Miller, a Hillsborough commissioner whose district includes some of the county's poorest communities.

He pointed out that on a long stretch of Hillsborough Avenue, there isn't a single pedestrian crosswalk. But there are small businesses and stores lining the road, and homes and apartments tucked behind the main avenue.

"You want development to come into the poor neighborhoods," Miller said. "But you also want to make sure that you include traffic patterns."

Tampa City Council member Frank Reddick has been outspoken about pedestrian deaths in poorer places like those he represents. He said he's working with city officials and the Florida Department of Transportation to pinpoint areas with the highest concentrations of fatalities.

Like Miller, he noted the dangers along Hillsborough Avenue. "We absolutely have a greater need for more sidewalks," he said.

The state Transportation Department is taking a multipronged approach, including teaching pedestrians traffic safety laws and analyzing crash sites to determine solutions, said Trenda McPherson, the department's bicycle and pedestrian safety manager.

In Pinellas, authorities have placed more than 40 rapid-flashing beacons in mid-block pedestrian walkways, particularly along Gulf Boulevard on the beaches, over the past year and a half. But many people cross a street that has no mid-block walkway to avoid walking 200 feet and back, Jacobs said.

In St. Petersburg, the city has waged a traffic-calming campaign for over a decade.

Devices such as speed humps and raised intersections are likely more prevalent "on the south side of the city than anywhere else," St. Petersburg City Council member Wengay Newton said.

"We have done a lot of proactive stuff, spending probably hundreds of thousands, if not millions," on traffic safety, including for pedestrians, he said.

"It's not going to stop you from getting hit by a car."

•••

Shubbar isn't angry at the driver who killed her daughter. "I've put myself in their situation, and I've forgiven them," she said.

Since Jayla's death, the Transportation Department has installed a traffic sign along Busch Boulevard that flashes when a pedestrian presses the button. But ideally, there needs to be fewer lanes, a lower speed limit and a traffic light, Shubbar said.

"You can't call somebody a jaywalker," she said, "when the right solutions don't exist."

Times news researcher John Martin contributed to this report.

     
Comments
Five members of 69ers motorcycle gang indicted on federal charges

Five members of 69ers motorcycle gang indicted on federal charges

Last year three members of the 69ers Motorcycle Club gang were implicated in the execution of a rival gang leader in the middle of rush hour traffic in Pasco County.Now those three and two other 69ers members have been indicted on federal charges tha...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Student says science teacher tackled Indiana school shooter

Student says science teacher tackled Indiana school shooter

NOBLESVILLE, Ind. — A male student opened fire at a suburban Indianapolis middle school Friday morning, wounding another student and a teacher before being taken into custody, authorities said. Seventh-grader Ethan Stonebraker said the science teache...
Updated: 1 hour ago

Woman, dog die trying to cross U.S. 19 in Hudson

PORT RICHEY— An unidentified 45-year-old Colorado woman and her dog died early Friday morning when they walked into the path of two vehicles on U.S. 19, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.The woman was walking her dog around 5:40 a.m. across U.S...
Updated: 3 hours ago
A ‘coupon conundrum’ at a Largo Burger King landed him in jail

A ‘coupon conundrum’ at a Largo Burger King landed him in jail

LARGO— A flap over coupons led a Clearwater man to grab a Burger King employee and yank her over the counter, leading to his arrest, according to the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office.Miguel Latorre, 23, was trying to use several coupons to buy a Whop...
Updated: 3 hours ago
New signs indicate reduced Bayshore Boulevard speed limit after racing deaths

New signs indicate reduced Bayshore Boulevard speed limit after racing deaths

TAMPA — Two days after a mother and daughter were struck by a speeding car Bayshore Boulevard, killing both, city officials on Friday began implementing changes aimed at ensuring safety along the busy roadway.On Friday morning, workers began installi...
Updated: 3 hours ago
He is accused in 13 Gulfport vehicle burglaries. An ankle bracelet tipped police off.

He is accused in 13 Gulfport vehicle burglaries. An ankle bracelet tipped police off.

GULFPORT — An 18-year-old man, wearing an ankle bracelet, was arrested Thursday after he was accused of breaking into 13 cars in a one-block radius over the last week.Benjamin Langkamp Jr. faces 13 charges of vehicle burglary — each of which occurred...
Updated: 6 hours ago
Warrant issued for Tampa suspect in January slaying

Warrant issued for Tampa suspect in January slaying

TAMPA — Hillsborough County deputies have identified the suspect in the fatal shooting of a man in January.Deputies are searching for 23-year-old Javon Rakeem Turner, who is wanted in the death of 22-year-old Elijah Moore on Jan. 17.According to depu...
Updated: 6 hours ago
Two accused of turning St. Petersburg test drive into carjacking

Two accused of turning St. Petersburg test drive into carjacking

MADEIRA BEACH — Two men were arrested Thursday after a carjacking during a test drive led to a crash on Gulf Boulevard less than an hour later, according to the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office. According to deputies, 30-year-old Robert Gajate went t...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Carlton: Senseless death on a street like no other

Carlton: Senseless death on a street like no other

On a Wednesday morning, a mother and her little girl, not quite 2, went for a stroll along one of Tampa’s prettiest streets.It was nearly lunchtime when they were crossing back over Bayshore Boulevard, headed to the home nearby where they were stayin...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Bayshore race claims two lives: child dies day after mother’s death

Bayshore race claims two lives: child dies day after mother’s death

TAMPA — Jessica Raubenolt seized on the sunshine and blue sky at midday Wednesday to take her daughter out in the stroller for a walk along scenic Bayshore Boulevard. Visiting from Ohio, the family had been cursed by rain all week.At the same time, C...
Updated: 10 hours ago