Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Is Brooksville's red-light program for public safety or generating revenue?

If you don't want to read what a blowhard columnist thinks about Brooksville's red-light camera program, at least pay attention to Bill Eppley.

"I have absolutely no problem with this ordinance as it relates to persons violating a red light and running directly through the intersection,'' he wrote to the city on Thursday.

But, he added, in the cases he's examined, drivers have merely rolled through right turns on red without coming to a complete stop.

"These are not issues that deal with public safety. I have reviewed all the tapes that have been presented to date and have not seen one instance where a traffic hazard was presented.

"The city's position is that this is a safety issue and not a revenue issue, when that is clearly not the case,'' Eppley wrote.

There's a reason Eppley's word on this subject should carry more weight than mine: Besides being a former city attorney, he was the hearing officer who reviewed the cases of all red-light runners who appealed their $125 tickets.

Notice the "was.'' The passages I quoted are from his letter of resignation. He also criticized an ordinance forbidding loud car stereos for its subjective enforcement and excessive fines — as high as $750 for repeat offenders.

"The fines are ridiculous,'' Eppley told me Thursday. "I just got fed up.''

In defense of the red-light program, police Chief George Turner said that the only people who pay are the ones who break the law.

Also, turning right on red without stopping can be just as dangerous as blowing through an intersection, Turner said. In fact, the only accident caused by a violation captured on film happened when a driver turning right struck a woman pushing a stroller across Dr. M.L. King Jr. Boulevard.

Finally, he said, state law doesn't distinguish between varying degrees of red-light running and imposes a much more serious penalty for the offense than the city code: $219 plus four points against a driver's license.

Okay, but here are few factors that make the cameras look like a sneaky new tax — an unfair one, too, because it can hit struggling families when they are least prepared to pay.

After the city gives a cut to the private company that installed the cameras, the tickets are expected to raise about $800,000 for Brooksville this fiscal year and seem to be part of a general ticket-writing, revenue-generating spree.

Putting aside the loud-stereo and red-light infractions, police officers wrote 1,198 traffic tickets from June to August of this year compared to 305 over the same period in 2008, an increase of 293 percent, according to a story by my colleague Joel Anderson.

Back to the camera program: An early analysis showed about 70 percent of the drivers were ticketed for failing to come to a complete stop while turning right.

In light of all this, I think Eppley had a good suggestion. Cut the fine for drivers who aren't really endangering others. Police officers who already review tape of every offense could make this judgment. So, Eppley said, could the hearing officer.

Otherwise, the law will lose the support of residents, he wrote:

"When ordinances only serve the government for the sake of sustaining government, (they) will not pass the test of public scrutiny.''

And he should know.

Is Brooksville's red-light program for public safety or generating revenue? 10/08/09 [Last modified: Thursday, October 8, 2009 7:16pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Estimated 5,000 people marvel at MOSI over solar eclipse

    Human Interest

    Packing pinhole cereal box viewers, cardboard glasses and curiosity, solar gawkers gathered outside Tampa's Museum of Science and Industry on Monday for a show that required no ticket.

    At center, Sophia Butter, 8, and Kristina Butera, both of Valrico, watch the sun through eclipse viewing glasses during a solar eclipse party Monday at the Museum of Science and Industry in Tampa. MOSI will reopen after renovations on November 18. [MONICA HERNDON   |   Times]
  2. Florida State sees plenty of upside in Dade City native Jacob Pugh

    College

    TALLAHASSEE — No, Florida State senior Jacob Pugh is not as versatile as teammate Derwin James.

     Florida State Seminoles linebacker Jacob Pugh (16) and Florida State Seminoles defensive end DeMarcus Walker (44) celebrate after sacking the Miami quarterback Saturday October 8, 2016 at Hard Rock Stadium in Miami Gardens.
  3. Tampa officer treated for knee injury after police truck, police SUV collide

    Accidents

    Times staff

    TAMPA — A Tampa police officer was treated and released for a knee injury when his unmarked police truck collided with a patrol SUV while the officers were tracking a stolen car, a police spokesman said.

  4. Waiting for the eclipse: 'Everyone thinks this is cool'

    Human Interest

    ST. PETERSBURG — Hunter Holland came to school Monday with a NASA space T-shirt and solar viewers in his button-up shirt pocket. But he'd rather be in Missouri.

    Jayda Hebert (front, center), 11, uses her protective glasses to watch Monday's solar eclipse with her cousin, Judah Adams (back left), 11, and her brother Jake Hebert (right), 9, while with their family at St. Petersburg Beach. "We're skipping school for the eclipse," her mom, Sarah Hebert, said. [DIRK SHADD   |   Times]
  5. Second person resigns from Hillsborough diversity council after Confederate activist appointed

    Blogs

    TAMPA — A second person has resigned symbolically from the Hillsborough County Diversity Advisory Council after the appointment of a known activist of Confederate causes to the panel. 

    Two people have resigned from the Hillsborough County Diversity Advisory Council after the inclusion of David McCallister, a leader of the local branch of the Sons of Confederate Veterans.