Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Judge: Government not at fault in doctor's plane crash

On the morning of July 2, 2003, a Beechcraft Baron carrying four men from Tampa swooped toward the runway at Memphis International Airport. On the ground nearby was a 50-passenger jet.

"Caution, wake turbulence," an air traffic controller warned the Baron pilot.

The controller was referring to the twin whirlwinds coming from the wings of the jet, which was two minutes ahead of the Baron. Such winds can cause smaller planes to roll over.

The pilot acknowledged the warning. But his plane did roll, and it did crash, and the pilot, a prominent neurosurgeon named David Cahill, was killed. So was a passenger, John Murphy. Two other passengers — Chip Lomel and Ed Brown — were badly hurt.

The families sued the government for wrongful death, arguing that the air traffic controllers hadn't kept the two planes at a safe distance. On Thursday, U.S. District Judge Susan Bucklew sided with the government in a ruling that was both final and inconclusive:

Yes, the controllers failed in their duty, Bucklew wrote.

No, the families didn't prove that wake turbulence caused the crash.

But neither did the government prove pilot error.

Bucklew's 20-page opinion left open the question of why David Cahill's Beechcraft Baron landed upside down.

The men were headed to Memphis for a business meeting.

The jet was slightly less than 4 nautical miles ahead of the Baron. This was a violation of Federal Aviation Administration guidelines.

Air traffic controllers must make sure approaching aircraft of those sizes stay at least 4 nautical miles apart.

The jet landed on a parallel runway about 900 feet away. The Baron's initial approach looked good. Then a witness saw it snap to the left.

"Oh, my god," a passenger heard Cahill say.

Two years later, the National Transportation Safety Board determined that the crash was probably caused by wake turbulence. But by law, that report was not admissible in court, said the plaintiffs' attorney, John Murray.

The trial took place in February. The government called Dr. Kenneth Orloff, a former NASA research scientist, who analyzed radar data and testified that Cahill was out of position for landing.

A firefighter who treated one of the passengers said the passenger remembered Cahill saying something like, "We're out of position for landing, and we're going to abort."

Another government expert testified that it would have been scientifically impossible for the jet's wake turbulence to affect the Baron, given that the jet landed fully two minutes before the Baron did.

The judge concluded that even though the air traffic controllers "breached their duty," there was no proof they caused the crash.

Cahill, 51, was an experienced pilot. He had more than 3,000 total flight hours. He was not under the influence of drugs or alcohol. Visibility was good. There was no evidence of mechanical malfunction.

Thomas Lake can be reached at or (813) 226-3416.

Judge: Government not at fault in doctor's plane crash 04/10/08 [Last modified: Thursday, April 10, 2008 11:48pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Departing fifth graders at Booker T. Washington Elementary leave lessons for their peers


    TAMPA — Teaching kindergarteners how to make slime seems like a good idea — when you're 12.

    From left, Tayvon Scott, 6, Arion Taylor, 9, and Nazir Anderson, 6, play with globs of slime they created from a science experiment taught by the Darius Troupe, a fifth-grader at Booker T. Washington Elementary School in Tampa. Students at Booker T. Washington Elementary School spent a "Day of Service" teaching their peers in a class exercise on May 24, 2017. [OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times]
  2. Tampa is 15th-most popular city to move to with U-Haul


    TAMPA — If someone is moving between cities with a U-Haul truck, there's a fair chance they could be coming to Tampa. Rankings released Friday by U-Haul placed Tampa as the No. 15 city people are moving to with a U-Haul truck.

    Tampa is the No. 15 destination for people moving with U-Haul trucks. | Times file photo
  3. Bucs WR DeSean Jackson knows only one direction: full speed ahead


    TAMPA — DeSean Jackson is the "1."

    Actually, Jackson, the Bucs' latest weapon for quarterback Jameis Winston, with his blazing speed and game-changing splash plays, wears No. 11 in games.

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers wide receiver DeSean Jackson participates in an "open OTA practice" at One Buc Place, the team's training facility, in Tampa, Fla., on Tuesday, May 23, 2017.
  4. Karen Bail, who helped Gibbs kids get to Broadway, retires


    ST. PETERSBURG — When neatnicks retire, they leave no trace behind. Their desks are clean, like a runway after the plane has taken off.

    Retiring musical theatre teacher Karen Bail warms up seniors Jonathan O'Brien, left, as Juan Peron and Addam Setzer as Che Guevara before the dress rehearsal of Pinellas County Center for the Arts (PCCA) magnet program's production of "Evita" at Gibbs High School in St. Petersburg, FL,  April 24, 2017.  The Andrew Lloyd Webber musical ran for three days in April at the school and was PCCA's last play of the year. CHERIE DIEZ   |   Times
  5. Florida's economy growing faster than other big states and far better than U.S. overall


    When it comes to economic growth, Florida's running alongside the leading states and well ahead of the United States as a whole.