Friday, May 25, 2018
Public safety

Legislator wants to put an end to red-light cameras

TALLAHASSEE — Red-light cameras are an issue that just won't disappear for lawmakers.

Two years ago, they passed a bill that legalized their use on Florida streets. Now, like last year, a bill is making its way through the Legislature that would eliminate them. On Thursday, a House committee narrowly approved a bill banning them by a 10-8 vote.

"The fact that it was such a close vote shows how divided the Legislature is on this issue," said Casey Cook, a lobbyist for the Florida League of Cities, which supports the cameras. "Every year we fight this bill, and every year it seems to come back."

The sponsor of this year's bill is Rep. Daphne Campbell, a Miami Democrat with credibility issues.

She and her husband were slapped last year with $145,000 worth in liens and her family has come under increased scrutiny for mortgage and Medicaid fraud. When the Times/Herald asked her recently if she was sponsoring HB 4011 because her husband's Honda Odyssey minivan had racked up five violations since 2010, she said she only knew about one violation and doubted the video and photographic evidence that the other violations had happened.

Campbell says she's pushing for a camera ban not because she's objecting to a program that has cost her household, but because she's doing her best representing her constituents. She says they want the cameras gone. Several of them called the Times/Herald last week to complain about the cameras after a story about her husband's violations was published.

Louis Toussaint was one of them. He said he wants to draw attention to the public unrest swirling about red-light cameras in Miami.

"I heard a lot of people complaining about the cameras," said the 75-year-old. "There's a general protest."

When asked who was complaining, however, Toussaint hesitated.

"I don't know, not everybody."

Well, who exactly?

"I cannot say," he said. "I speak for myself."

Turns out, Toussaint acknowledged, he called on behalf of Campbell.

But Campbell said she wasn't having people make phone calls.

"Lies, I haven't told anyone to call," Campbell said. "I'm too busy."

Campbell did enlist the support of another lawmaker, Rep. Carlos Trujillo, R-Miami. Unlike Campbell, no cars were registered at Trujillo's address that had racked up red-light camera violations.

Trujillo said he's been a longtime opponent of red-light cameras, having sponsored a similar bill banning them in 2010. He said he doesn't think red-light cameras make intersections safer. So far, there is no similar bill in the Senate.

Not all lawmakers share Campbell's beliefs..

Campbell told the House Economic Affairs Committee that she believed the cameras are placed in low-income areas and have become an extra burden on the poor and elderly. Campbell said evidence showing the cameras make streets safer is questionable and that cameras are popular only because they make money.

Rep. Ed Hooper, R-Clearwater, asked her if she had any evidence that the cameras were placed in low-income areas. Campbell explained that she has received many email complaints about the cameras, and that many people she met on the campaign trail criticized them.

Hooper stopped her and said that was only anecdotal evidence.

"I asked if you had any actual evidence, but it's obvious you don't," said Hooper, who later voted against the bill.

Campbell and opponents say the cameras have one main purpose: to make money.

Of the $158 collected from every citation, the state takes $83. The remaining $75 is split between the city and the camera vendor. If a ticket is unpaid after 30 days, it can increase another $110.

According to the Florida Department of Revenue, cities and counties collected $46.1 million while the state collected $51 million the past year. Miami's red-light cameras produced more than $9 million in fines, the most in the state.

Tampa's net revenues from the cameras totaled $2.3 million last year. Those are net revenues after the state's share and the city paid a $1 million fee to camera vendor American Traffic Solutions. St. Petersburg collected $707,226 for its coffers.

But the claim that cameras make dangerous intersections safer is still up for debate.

A report last year of accidents compiled by the state from 73 different law enforcement agencies found that more than half of Florida agencies, 41, say accidents are less frequent at intersections using red-light camera technology.

Crashes were more frequent in 11 of the 73 jurisdictions while the rest saw no change or didn't have enough information. Miami led the state in the number of violations, and reported a decline in crashes.

Crashes at intersections with red-light cameras fell by nearly a third the year after Tampa officials installed the technology, police records show. Yet in St. Petersburg, city records show that rear-end wrecks at intersections with red-light cameras spiked 44 percent between November 2011 and October 2012. Also, total crashes actually jumped 10 percent at intersections with cameras in the program's first year.

Michael Van Sickler can be reached at (850) 224-7263 or [email protected]

Comments
Driver killed after colliding with dump truck in south Hillsborough

Driver killed after colliding with dump truck in south Hillsborough

WIMAUMA — A 30-year-old man died on Thursday after his sedan crashed head-on into a dump truck, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.The crash took place at about 6 p.m. on U.S. 301 near Lightfood Road.Gerardo Yslas of Immokalee was driving a 2012...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Police: Toddler injured in Bayshore racing incident has died

Police: Toddler injured in Bayshore racing incident has died

TAMPA — The 21-month-old toddler who was critically injured Wednesday when she and her mother were struck by a car racing on Bayshore Boulevard has died.The child, Lillia Raubenolt, was pronounced dead at the hospital on Thursday, police said.PREVIOU...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Bayshore race claims two lives: child dies day after mother’s death

Bayshore race claims two lives: child dies day after mother’s death

TAMPA — Jessica Raubenolt seized on the sunshine and blue sky at midday Wednesday to take her daughter out in the stroller for a walk along scenic Bayshore Boulevard. Visiting from Ohio, the family had been cursed by rain all week.At the same time, C...
Updated: 7 hours ago
One day after fatal accident, Tampa moves to lower speed limit on Bayshore Blvd

One day after fatal accident, Tampa moves to lower speed limit on Bayshore Blvd

TAMPA — City officials announced Thursday they are reducing the speed limit on Bayshore Boulevard, one day after a mother and her 21-month-old daughter were struck and fatally injured by a speeding car as they crossed the street.Starting today , city...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Pasco sheriff: Man stabbed driver, kicked officer

Pasco sheriff: Man stabbed driver, kicked officer

DADE CITY — A 42-year-old man was arrested Tuesday night after the Pasco County Sheriff’s Office said he jumped on top of a car, stabbed the driver multiple times and then kicked an officer.Roscoe James faces charges of attempted murder, two counts o...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Three men charged with street racing in Bayshore Boulevard crash are recent graduates of Tampa Catholic High School

Three men charged with street racing in Bayshore Boulevard crash are recent graduates of Tampa Catholic High School

TAMPA— The Catholic Diocese of St. Petersburg confirmed Thursday that the three men involved in the Bayshore Boulevard crash that killed an Ohio mother and critically injured her 21-month-old daughter are recent graduates of Tampa Catholic High Schoo...
Published: 05/24/18
GoFundMe page for woman killed on Bayshore has raised more than 10 times its goal

GoFundMe page for woman killed on Bayshore has raised more than 10 times its goal

TAMPA — Friends were hoping to use GoFundMe to raise $2,000 for the family of Jessica Raubenolt, who was struck and killed Wednesday while pushing her 21-month-old daughter in a stroller across Bayshore Boulevard.As of Thursday morning, more than $20...
Published: 05/24/18
Three arrested for street racing after mother fatally struck pushing stroller on Bayshore Boulevard

Three arrested for street racing after mother fatally struck pushing stroller on Bayshore Boulevard

TAMPA — The two cars raced each other along Bayshore Boulevard just before noon, witnesses told police. One was a black 2018 Mustang. The other a gold Nissan. They sped side-by-side, trading the lead, police said, despite the traffic and pedestrians ...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Clearwater deputy fire chief resigns as report on sick leave abuse is released

Clearwater deputy fire chief resigns as report on sick leave abuse is released

CLEARWATER — A months-long probe into abuse of sick leave within the fire department concluded this week with the resignation of a deputy chief and the release of an internal review.The city paid $93,816 in unearned or unauthorized sick time, benefit...
Published: 05/23/18
Updated: 05/24/18
Son tells NC police he found dog leash around neck of strangled Hillsborough developer Bill Bishop

Son tells NC police he found dog leash around neck of strangled Hillsborough developer Bill Bishop

After a prominent Hillsborough County developer died last month in North Carolina, word spread it was a heart attack that claimed his life.But records from that state show the death of William "Bill" Bishop was much more complicated.His 16-year-old s...
Published: 05/23/18
Updated: 05/24/18