Monday, July 23, 2018
Public safety

Kidnapping victim had history of calls for help

TAMPA — Alisa Summers remembers the February night her estranged husband waved a machete at her, held her captive for hours and threatened to bind her with rope and tape.

She also remembers calling 911 as she fled to a nearby gas station. She stood in shock, she said, as Hillsborough County sheriff's deputies warned they could throw her in jail if she was filing a false report.

They knew she had asked for domestic violence protection from Trevor Summers on Halloween, she said, and they knew she had an evidence problem. They knew about the pending divorce and asked if her claims were an attempt to gain sole custody of the couple's five children.

But Trevor Summers, 39, said this week that his wife was telling the truth that night, according to court records.

His confession came only after deputies charged him with kidnapping his wife a week ago. He is being held in a Hillsborough County jail, with a bail hearing set for Monday, and faces a litany of charges including kidnapping and attempted murder.

"They messed up protecting me and my children," Alisa Summers, 37, said in an interview with the Tampa Bay Times. "The day I started saying 'this is domestic abuse,' I got out. I called 911 every time there was an issue, and I've hit a roadblock every single time."

Hillsborough sheriff's spokesman Larry McKinnon said he couldn't comment on Alisa Summers' interactions with deputies that night, Feb. 18, but said a report was filed and an investigation is still ongoing. No arrests were made because there was no proof, only her story and his rebuttals, followed by dueling requests for domestic violence protection.

Alisa Summers said she has done everything she could do to protect her family from her husband as he pitted her word against his with each call to authorities.

Neither Trevor Summers nor his parents could be reached for comment. An attorney name is not listed in his jail record.

However, public records document Alisa Summers' requests for help, as well as the court's dismissals. She never wanted to be a victim, she said, and still doesn't want to be viewed as one in the aftermath of her 54 hours in captivity with Trevor Summers, which ended Monday.

"I'll do whatever it takes, jump through whatever hoops they need me to, so this can finally be over," she said.

Her first call for help was to the Department of Children and Families on Oct. 30. She mentioned it the next day when she filed a domestic violence petition against Trevor Summers, describing his conduct that month.

On Oct. 11, he had refused to go to work, she wrote, because he suspected she was planning to leave. He prevented multiple attempts to escape, she wrote. She even tried "to get the attention of the man cutting our grass but he kept restraining me."

On Oct. 24, he came home early while she was calling a domestic violence shelter for help. She said he kept her from leaving, taking her keys and cellphone. When she ran outside, he pulled her back in, she wrote.

After a while, she convinced him to let her "cool off" and she left the home with the clothes on her back and four of her five children, she wrote.

On Oct. 28, he followed her car into the driveway of the friend's home where she was staying with her children.

Two days later, she awoke to flowers in the friend's mailbox.

A judge dismissed her permanent injunction request Nov. 10, citing a lack of evidence, and Alisa Summers filed for divorce a month later.

She and her children spent multiple nights in a domestic violence shelter, she told the Times. With help from friends and family she found a house and a job.

She and her husband have both sought counseling from Pastor Matthew Grise of RiverStone Community Church in Gibsonton, the pastor said. Alisa Summers also attended classes for survivors of domestic violence and for women going through a divorce.

"Trevor was more reserved, quiet, introverted, and Alisa was the extroverted one who thrived on relationships with other people," Grise said.

Alisa Summers' second domestic violence petition came Feb. 21, describing the Feb. 18 machete incident. She wrote that she went to Trevor Summers' home in Riverview to collect a $25,000 check and work on their marital settlement agreement.

When she gathered her belongings to leave that evening, he pulled out a machete and told her to sit on the bed and keep talking, court records show. It was an incident that he would deny for a month. He claimed it was a false report until this week when he was interviewed by detectives in the kidnapping case.

"Nobody dismissed the case," McKinnon said of the Feb. 18 report. "All the deputies had to go on were conflicting statements."

Alisa and Trevor Summers have been married since 2001.

She was 15 and a dancer on the color guard team when she first met the popular and outgoing boy two years ahead of her at Garnet Valley High School in Glen Mills, Penn.

They began dating when she was 19, and got married at 22.

He is the only real boyfriend Alisa Summers has ever had, she told the Times. When they met, she said, he was "spontaneous, very charming and so romantic.

"There was always something happening and life was always an adventure," she said.

Her parents weren't as impressed. They thought he was smooth talker who tended to exaggerate, said Alisa's mother, Donna Waryga, who calls her son-in-law "Teflon Trevor."

"He's gotten away with a whole lot for a really, really long time," Waryga said.

Shortly after getting married, her daughter became pregnant and left college just short of a business degree, her mother said. The family moved between Pennsylvania, Texas, California, Nevada and Florida, and babies kept coming.

Now, Alisa Summers faces a battle to reclaim them.

Court records don't yet explain why she doesn't have them. Many questions remain unanswered.

Hundreds of pages of reports on the family are not public, either because they relate to child custody matters or because law enforcement investigations have not concluded.

During five hours in a closed court hearing Thursday, Alisa Summers and her attorney argued she should have custody. Her husband participated in the hearing by video conference from jail, according to the court administrator's office.

Her motion was denied, and the children are still in the care of Trevor Summers' parents, where they were placed by the state in a sheltering action after the parents disappeared.

The days that followed her kidnapping have been "disappointing," Alisa Summers said, but the legal battle is one she's determined to win.

"I'm still fighting for healing for myself and my children, for the life we had," she said. "I'm still fighting to be free."

Contact Anastasia Dawson at [email protected] or (813) 226-3377. Follow @adawsonwrites.

   
Comments
Man firing into Toronto cafes shoots 14 people, killing 2

Man firing into Toronto cafes shoots 14 people, killing 2

TORONTO — A man walked along a Toronto street firing a handgun into restaurants and cafes, shooting 14 people and killing two before dying after an exchange of gunfire with police. Police Chief Mark Saunders did not rule out terrorism as a motive, th...
Updated: 3 hours ago
In need of deputies, Hillsborough sheriff loosens college, tattoo and drug use rules for new hires

In need of deputies, Hillsborough sheriff loosens college, tattoo and drug use rules for new hires

TAMPA — After five years in the U.S. Marine Corps, Cody Gibb felt an urge to try something new. An uncle who retired from a career in law enforcement suggested he follow in his footsteps, and Gibb, a 24-year-old Brandon resident, liked the idea. "The...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Palmetto chief’s ‘puffy nipples’ comment prompts sexual harassment training

Palmetto chief’s ‘puffy nipples’ comment prompts sexual harassment training

PALMETTO — A Florida police chief and officers in his department are being ordered by city officials to undergo sexual harassment training following an investigation about inappropriate comments, including one the chief made about a female officer’s ...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Five times Florida’s ‘stand your ground’ law sparked controversy

Five times Florida’s ‘stand your ground’ law sparked controversy

Florida’s controversial self defense law is in the news again.The killing of Markeis McGlockton, who was shot by another man after the two argued over a parking space on Thursday, is just the most recent in a long succession of controversies over the...
Published: 07/23/18
Community holds vigil in Clearwater for man killed in parking lot dispute, protests ‘stand your ground’

Community holds vigil in Clearwater for man killed in parking lot dispute, protests ‘stand your ground’

Friends, family and supporters filled the sanctuary at Mt. Carmel Baptist Church on Sunday night calling for justice in the death of Markeis McGlockton last week.The vigil and protest, organized by the Clearwater/Upper Pinellas County Branch of the N...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Community holds vigil in Clearwater for man killed in parking lot dispute, protests ‘stand your ground’

Community holds vigil in Clearwater for man killed in parking lot dispute, protests ‘stand your ground’

Friends, family and supporters filled the sanctuary at Mt. Carmel Baptist Church on Sunday night calling for justice in the death of Markeis McGlockton last week. The vigil and protest, organized by the Clearwater/Upper Pinellas County Branch of the...
Updated: 4 hours ago
NAACP to hold vigil for man killed in ‘stand your ground’ shooting Thursday

NAACP to hold vigil for man killed in ‘stand your ground’ shooting Thursday

A local branch of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People is holding a vigil Sunday for a black man who was killed Thursday in what authorities are calling a "stand your ground" shooting.The vigil for the family of Markeis McGl...
Published: 07/22/18
Duck boat tragedy kills nine members of the same family

Duck boat tragedy kills nine members of the same family

BRANSON, Mo. - The Coleman family had initially thought of going on a vacation to Florida for their annual trip, but the drive was too long for some elderly relatives who wanted to join. The Colemans settled on going to Branson, a southwestern Missou...
Published: 07/22/18
Pasco Sheriff’s Office releases names of two killed in apparent murder-suicide Saturday

Pasco Sheriff’s Office releases names of two killed in apparent murder-suicide Saturday

NEW PORT RICHEY — The Pasco County Sheriff’s Office have released the names of two people killed in what investigators believe was a murder-suicide Saturday.At about 1 p.m. Saturday, Alisa Medovich, 23, of Holiday, was shot and killed by Mario Medina...
Published: 07/21/18
Updated: 07/22/18
Tampa police seek driver in fatal Saturday morning hit and run

Tampa police seek driver in fatal Saturday morning hit and run

Tampa police are looking for a motorist who they say killed a man in an early Saturday morning hit and run.About 2 a.m. Saturday, a 38-year-old man was hit by a car travelling east on the 3600 block of E Columbus Dr. in Tampa, according to a Tampa Po...
Published: 07/21/18