Thursday, November 23, 2017
Public safety

Motive still a mystery after Gulfport hardware store owner is accused of arson

RECOMMENDED READING


GULFPORT — David Cretella climbed out of the cab and walked into his hardware store.

The 64-year-old shop owner had been drinking at O'Maddy's that night. He likely didn't realize he was being watched — by the taxi driver waiting outside and by a surveillance camera mounted on a grocery store across the street.

After spending a few minutes inside, Cretella left and climbed back into his waiting taxi. It was 8:21 p.m.

A minute later, smoke started to pour out of Gulfport Hardware. Flames erupted at 8:23 p.m., about the same time a pair of police officers noticed the blaze and called firefighters.

A crowd started to build.

Marty Condon, who owns a sign shop a few doors away, said he rushed over after getting frantic calls from friends who saw the flames from the road. Others with businesses in the complex soon showed up.

"Dave was nowhere to be found," Condon said. "I thought to myself, 'well that's odd.' "

Barely 24 hours later, the Seminole resident was in handcuffs. The fire, investigators said, was no accident.

• • •

Every city takes pride in its local businesses. That might be even more true for Gulfport, a tiny beach community where everyone knows everyone.

A lot of people know David Cretella, who opened the Gulfport Hardware Store at 5006 Gulfport Blvd. S, in 2006.

People respected he was a little guy in a big business. He wasn't shy about competing with Home Depot or Lowe's. He would stock special tools local handymen needed, rescreen doors and windows or sell you a single screw if that's all you needed.

"He was kind of a folk hero, in that he was doing for the community," said Bob Newcomb, executive director of the Gulfport Chamber of Commerce, located a couple of doors down from the hardware store. "The very nature of that business is difficult. But he hung in there."

Cretella had many supporters — even the mayor.

"I encouraged people to shop local," said Mayor Mike Yakes, who said he stopped by about once a week. "And I admired him for what he was trying to do. . . . He'd ask people what they needed. If he didn't have it, he'd order it."

Yakes said he and Cretella talked often of their love for Gulfport, which he said the shop owner often described as "a good place to live, a good place to fish and a good place to do business."

• • •

The Oct. 18 fire shocked everyone. Cretella's subsequent arrest on a second-degree arson charge was even more shocking.

What would he have gained, they wondered? He didn't own the building. He lamented about his high insurance deductibles.

"It's just a terrible thing for him to do, it if he did it — which it sounds like he did," said Rick Yarrington, who's known Cretella for several years. "You wonder what troubles a man to commit a crime like that. Thank God no one was hurt or killed."

Authorities are confident in their case, said Gulfport police Sgt. Tom Woodman.

Several arson investigators sifted through the fire site. "They could not find anything that showed it was accidental," Woodman said.

Cretella, Woodman said, gave several inconsistent statements in interviews and said he couldn't remember certain aspects about what he did while in the store, according to court documents.

Fire investigators said they found two areas of origin. The rapid speed of the blaze also suggests it was intentionally set, they said.

Cretella told the Tampa Bay Times before his arrest that he was shocked by the damage.

"My stomach just fell about 3 feet down to my knees," Cretella said standing outside the shop the day after the fire. "I've been here for seven years, and I never . . . I've never had a fire before."

Two weeks later, Cretella told a Times reporter he had nothing more to say about the fire. He denied torching his business, and said investigators "did all the talking."

Records show he spent a night a jail, and is out on $10,000 bail.

"I just want to get back to work," Cretella said by phone Friday. "It was no reason for me to burn down the business in the peak of my season."

Those who know him aren't so sure.

They said Cretella made no secret of the fact that in recent months, business was slow.

Yarrington owns the Golf Shop down the street. He and Cretella often chatted about business, and how much they were looking forward to snowbird season.

"He would always ask how my business was," Yarrington said. "From the beginning, he seemed to always say business was slow."

Yakes said Cretella's inventory changed recently. He started stocking bigger items like wheelbarrows, generators and heavy duty tools. They seemed to sit on the shelves longer, the mayor said.

And yet, Yarrington said, Cretella was always expanding. When Cretella first opened his shop on Gulf Boulevard, he occupied one unit, said building owner Jim Defoe. By the time of the fire, he occupied three units and about 3,000 square feet of space.

Defoe, who was reluctant to talk about the fire, declined to say how much Cretella paid in rent or whether he was under any unusual financial strain.

"I believe he planned to stay," Defoe said.

In fact, Yarrington said, Cretella recently talked about opening a second shop on St. Pete Beach.

Defoe, who lives in St. Petersburg, said the fire will mean a hit to his personal investments, but that "he'll survive." Damage from the fire has been estimated at $600,000.

"I just have no clue," he said. "I don't understand the thinking behind any thing like this."

Times researchers Natalie Watson and Carolyn Edds contributed to this report.

Comments

Hernando deputies make arrest after finding body of dead woman Wednesday

BROOKSVILLE — Hernando County sheriff’s deputies arrested a 32-year-old man Wednesday who they say killed a woman.Joshua Carroll, 32, faces a charge of second-degree murder.Deputies found the body of the woman, who was not identified, at 15013 Old St...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Tampa husband gets life, wife 40 years for sexual assault on 7-year-old

Tampa husband gets life, wife 40 years for sexual assault on 7-year-old

TAMPA — The mother of a 7-year-old girl stood weeping in a federal courtroom, demanding lifelong prison sentences for the Tampa couple who sexually assaulted her daughter while the girl’s own father took videos and pictures. "I don’t want my child to...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Details emerge in suicide of Hernando school volunteer accused of sexual abuse

Details emerge in suicide of Hernando school volunteer accused of sexual abuse

A former Brooksville school volunteer accused of sexually assaulting teenage foreign exchange students who were under his care was found dead last week, a day before he was due in court on the charges.The body of Bruce McAllister was found at the bas...
Published: 11/22/17
Fire sends smoke through roof of Brass Flamingo adult club in Port Richey

Fire sends smoke through roof of Brass Flamingo adult club in Port Richey

PORT RICHEY — Crews from Pasco County fire rescue were battling a fire Wednesday morning that sent smoke pouring through the roof at the Brass Flamingo adult club, 9034 U.S. 19.The fire forced the closing of U.S. 19 but traffic was flowing again by 6...
Published: 11/22/17
Mountains beckon, but family sticks with beleaguered Seminole Heights for Thanksgiving this year

Mountains beckon, but family sticks with beleaguered Seminole Heights for Thanksgiving this year

TAMPA — Before the killings began, Bob and Vivian Fiallo envisioned having Thanksgiving at their North Carolina mountain getaway.Most years, the couple spends the holiday at their tidy, brick-faced home on North Olney Avenue, in the heart of Southeas...
Published: 11/22/17
Report: Pepin Academies director had alcohol in his system at time of fatal boating accident

Report: Pepin Academies director had alcohol in his system at time of fatal boating accident

CLEARWATER — The former Pepin Academies executive director who died in a watercraft and boat collision on Sept. 23 had a blood-alcohol level nearly twice the level at which the state presumes someone is impaired, a toxicology report showed. Just befo...
Published: 11/21/17
Pasco Deputies: Man climbs into bed with sleeping woman after multiple burglaries

Pasco Deputies: Man climbs into bed with sleeping woman after multiple burglaries

NEW PORT RICHEY — A man who ended a series of burglaries by breaking into the home of a sleeping woman, where he climbed into her bed, was arrested Monday afternoon, the Pasco County Sheriff’s Office said.Russel Smith, 42, now faces three felony char...
Published: 11/21/17

28-year-old man shot dead in Spring Hill home, deputies say

SPRING HILL — A 28-year-old man was shot and killed inside a Spring Hill home Monday night, according to the Hernando County Sheriff’s Office.Deputies responded to at least two separate 911 calls about 8:15 p.m., in which callers reported shots being...
Published: 11/21/17
Crime Stoppers, Straz Foundation still working out Seminole Heights reward money

Crime Stoppers, Straz Foundation still working out Seminole Heights reward money

TAMPA — You can collect $110,000 in reward money for information leading to an arrest in the Seminole Heights killings, but for now you’ll have to make two stops.The David A. Straz Foundation announced Monday it would contribute $10,000 to a reward f...
Published: 11/21/17

Crash involving bicyclist closes EB lanes on W Kennedy Boulevard in downtown Tampa

TAMPA — Eastbound lanes on W Kennedy Boulevard were reopened by 6:30 a.m. at S Parker Street in downtown Tampa after a bicyclist was struck early Tuesday morning.The crash occurred in front of the University of Tampa, according to broadcast reports.W...
Published: 11/21/17