Wednesday, May 23, 2018
Public safety

Of manatee rides, second chances and a law on common sense

Regardless of how you feel about the crime of manatee riding — and for the record, I am firmly against it — on this we can probably agree:

What a 53-year-old woman named Ana Gloria Garcia Gutierrez did in the balmy waters off Fort De Soto Park when she was caught on camera astride a sea cow was hardly the equivalent of, say, robbing a bank.

Notable, yes. (That Woman Atop Manatee photo made CNN.) An act to be frowned upon and dealt with accordingly, sure. A teachable moment about wild things in our midst — we can only hope.

But no, she was not a suspected serial killer. So some were surprised when she was arrested at her job at Sears and jailed, that she had her mug shot taken and a bail amount set — all for a warrant on a second-degree misdemeanor charge of messing with a manatee.

Outrageous, no? Overkill, right?

In truth, people accused of low-level, nonviolent crimes — even people with no record whatsoever — are arrested and jailed in Florida every day. (An ex-police officer I know remembers people arrested on warrants for failing to have a fishing license.)

Does this make sense to you? Do first-timers accused of misdemeanors need to go to jail, to have a mug shot taken and an arrest on their record?

Then there's the part about how much it costs us taxpayers to book and process people who probably do not need to be off the streets in the name of public safety. Isn't there a better way?

Yes, as it turns out.

In the spirit of both efficiency and second chances, Florida allows a juvenile accused for the first time of a minor crime like petty larceny to get a civil citation instead of being arrested. If he does everything required — community service, restitution, apology, any treatment deemed appropriate — he avoids a record that could shadow him for the rest of his life.

Why not adults?

The Florida Smart Justice Alliance is pushing for just that. As the Times' Dan Sullivan reported, it's already in the works for police in Tallahassee and Leon County to be able to give grownup offenders tickets for minor crimes.

"The basic philosophy is in these fiscally constrained times, we can do better things with the money," says Smart Justice president Mark Flynn. A civil citation costs us $386 — compared with $5,000 for an arrest.

And apparently second chances work: Only 7 percent of kids who got tickets instead of being arrested in 2009-2010 got in trouble again within a year.

Doing the same for adults accused of, it's important to say again, specific low-level, first-time crimes seems a no-brainer. It's got something for everyone: fiscal watchdogs, idealists who believe in breaks, even zero-tolerance types, since people who don't do what's required after the ticket end up back in the system.

Local law enforcement sounds cautious on this, and they should, since keeping citizens safe is in their job description. Police, prosecutors and public defenders should put their heads together to make it work. Giving someone accused of a minor crime a way out — with an added perk of saving big bucks — sounds like common sense to me.

Not that there's much common sense in, say, deciding to ride a manatee. But that's what teachable moments — and second chances — are all about.

Comments
FDLE: Victim in $480,000 scam is heiress to Wrigley gum fortune

FDLE: Victim in $480,000 scam is heiress to Wrigley gum fortune

A woman state authorities say was scammed out of $480,000 by two of her employees is an heiress to the Wrigley chewing gum fortune.The Florida Department of Law Enforcement confirmed Tuesday that the victim in the case is Helen Rich, 69, formerly Hel...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Carlton: Lowering the American flag for the newly dead at school — again

Carlton: Lowering the American flag for the newly dead at school — again

In a scene repeated at public buildings across the country, the American flag in front of the library outside my office window was lowered to half-staff this week.This time for 10 dead in Texas.In February, the American flag was similarly half-staff ...
Published: 05/23/18
Police: St. Pete man who pried a safe out of the wall in custody

Police: St. Pete man who pried a safe out of the wall in custody

ST. PETERSBURG — It took more than an hour for a 25-year-old man to break into a restaurant, pry a safe out of the wall, drag it through the back and then wrestle it into his car, according to police.That was last week. Michael Murphy was arrested Tu...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Search underway for North Carolina man missing from Tampa-based Carnival Paradise

Search underway for North Carolina man missing from Tampa-based Carnival Paradise

The U.S. Coast Guard was searching Tuesday for a 50-year-old North Carolina man who reportedly fell off a Tampa-based cruise ship.The Coast Guard Key West received a call from the cruise ship Carnival Paradise about 10 a.m. saying the man, Brian Lamo...
Published: 05/22/18
Deputies: 10th-grader brings loaded gun to Bradenton high school

Deputies: 10th-grader brings loaded gun to Bradenton high school

A Bradenton Bayshore High School student faces charges after he brought a gun on campus on Tuesday, according to the Manatee County Sheriff’s Office.Around 11:45 a.m., school resource officers were alerted by school staff that the student, a 10th-gra...
Published: 05/22/18
Police swarm Panama City street in apparent shootout

Police swarm Panama City street in apparent shootout

PANAMA CITY BEACH — Multiple law enforcement agencies have surrounded a Panama City apartment building where an active shooter is barricaded inside.City spokeswoman Caitlyn Lawrence says it’s still an active situation. The suspect has been firing on ...
Published: 05/22/18
FedEx driver, 22, dies in crash on Interstate 4

FedEx driver, 22, dies in crash on Interstate 4

TAMPA — A 22-year-old FedEx driver died on Interstate 4 Tuesday when a tire blew out on his freight truck, which veered into the path of a Chevrolet Volt, state troopers said. Two teen girls in the Volt survived the 10:21 a.m. crash. A photo shows ci...
Published: 05/22/18
Crime in Florida, Tampa Bay region decreased in 2017, data show

Crime in Florida, Tampa Bay region decreased in 2017, data show

Crime in Florida reached a 47-year low in 2017, according to state figures released Tuesday and touted as a "major announcement" by a Republican governor determined to win a U.S. Senate seat. The state’s total crime rate dropped by 6 percent from 201...
Published: 05/22/18

FDLE: Pasco couple scammed elderly employer out of $480,000

TAMPA — A Pasco County couple face dozens of charges after the Florida Department of Law Enforcement said they stole more than $480,000 from their elderly employer.Chet Alan Ragsdale, 45, was arrested Monday on 28 counts of grand theft, 25 counts of ...
Published: 05/21/18
4 sinkholes open in The Villages retirement community

4 sinkholes open in The Villages retirement community

THE VILLAGES — Four sinkholes have opened up in a fast-growing retirement community in Florida, including one in front of a home that was abandoned months ago because of an earlier sinkhole. A spokeswoman for the Marion County Sheriff’s Office says t...
Published: 05/21/18