Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Plant City police make arrest in 1979 killing

PLANT CITY — Orthneil Kelley doesn't remember much about his mother. And for many years, he knew just as little about how she died.

In the snippets of memory he did have, he was 4 years old and alone in their house on Ninth Street in Plant City. He could hear his infant brother crying.

That was in 1979. The relatives who raised him sheltered him from the details. It wasn't until 2006, when Kelley began researching his family history, that he learned his mother's death was Plant City's oldest unsolved homicide.

On Tuesday morning, nearly 35 years after the mystery began, police called Kelley. They had made an arrest.

New DNA evidence and interviews with witnesses were enough for authorities to charge Nathaniel Bigbee with first-degree murder in the death of Charolette Kelley, Plant City police Chief Ed Duncan said.

U.S. marshals arrested the 63-year-old Tampa man Monday night in Columbus, Miss., where he was visiting family.

For Kelley, 39, the arrest means justice for a mother he never knew, but whose absence he still feels.

"She made it happen," he said at a Tuesday news conference announcing the arrest. "Now she can get closure. Now she can rest."

On the evening of Sept. 17, 1979, neighbors were concerned when they heard her two children crying inside the Kelley home. They entered and found Orthneil, 4, and his 7-month-old brother alone.

Police did a brief search of the neighborhood, but the 25-year-old mother remained missing until a group of children came upon her body two days later in an overgrown canal behind her home. She had been strangled, police said.

Detectives interviewed a number of her acquaintances, including Bigbee. They considered him a suspect early in the investigation, Duncan said. But at the time, detectives didn't have enough evidence to support a criminal charge.

In 1980, the case turned cold. It remained largely untouched for much of the next 30 years.

Bigbee, meanwhile, piled up 11 arrests in Hillsborough and Alachua counties, state records show. He also did two prison stints: about 18 months in prison for burglary and larceny in the mid 1980s and 5 1/2 years beginning in 1988 for sexual battery.

In recent years, Bigbee lived in a small house on N 19th Street in the Belmont/Jackson Heights area, about two blocks west of Middleton High School.

Neighbors Fred and Whitney Mitchell remember Bigbee as a reserved man with a soft voice who would pass the time sitting on his back patio with a white dog. He told them he knew how to work on engines and had been married, but said his wife died of cancer about four years ago. He talked to Fred Mitchell about buying his truck so he could start a lawn service and volunteered to cut their grass, coming over early in the morning to do the job.

"It doesn't seem like him," Mitchell said of the murder charge. "It's kind of hard to believe."

Kelley, a civilian security specialist at MacDill Air Force Base, got a call from detectives in 2012. They told him they had a suspect, but shared few details. He kept waiting.

They kept in touch periodically, but he had no idea the case was going to be solved until he got the call Tuesday morning.

The case was sealed after forensic investigators were able to obtain DNA from bedsheets in the Kelley home, police said. They compared the DNA with a voluntary sample that Bigbee provided. It came back a match.

The DNA, coupled with interviews with witnesses who put Bigbee and Charolette Kelley together near the time of her disappearance, was enough for detectives to file the charge.

"I think I have seen him before," Kelley said after seeing Bigbee's mug shot. "But I don't necessarily recall being in his presence.

"He took something from me that other people have that I never got to enjoy," he said. "It has been a long time coming."

Times researcher John Martin and staff writer Richard Danielson contributed to this report. Contact Dan Sullivan at or (813) 226-3386. Follow @TimesDan.

Plant City police make arrest in 1979 killing 08/26/14 [Last modified: Tuesday, August 26, 2014 11:31pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. For starters: Rays at Pirates, with Blake Snell on the mound


    LHP Blake Snell returns to the majors for the Rays tonight after a six-week stint at Triple-A Durham, confident changes to his mechanics will lead to more strike-throwing and an increase in confidence will make him more successful.

  2. YouTube's Minecraft sensation Dan TDM brings live show to Clearwater


    Dan Middleton's YouTube channel has had more than 10 billion views since 2012.

    Dan Middleton's Dan TDM live tour is set to stop in Clearwater on Sunday. [Photo by Emily Herogian]
  3. Lightning's Mathieu Joseph on the rise at development camp


    BRANDON — The last 12 months have been quite the ride for Mathieu Joseph.

    Mathieu Joseph checks Carolina's Jake Bean during a preseason game in September in Tampa.
  4. Pinellas legislators talk governor's race, policy at delegation breakfast


    If anybody was expecting state Sen. Jack Latvala, R-Clearwater, to quit being coy and and announce his bid for the 2018 governor's race to the friendly crowd at Clearwater Regional Chamber of Commerce's annual legislative delegation breakfast Wednesday, they left disappointed.

  5. DOT shows alternatives to former Tampa Bay Express toll lanes


    TAMPA — State transportation officials are evaluating at least a half-dozen alternatives to the controversial Tampa Bay interstate plan that they will workshop with the community for the next 18 months.

    Florida Department of Transportation consultant Brad Flom explains potential alternatives to adding toll lanes to Interstate 275 during a meeting Wednesday at DOT's Tampa office. Flom presented seven diagrams, all of which swapped toll lanes for transit, such as light rail or express bus, in the I-275 corridor from downtown Tampa to Bearss Ave. [CAITLIN JOHNSTON | Times]