Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Police say former Pinellas woman, found dead in New York, could be victim of a serial killer

CLEARWATER — Amber Lynn Costello was "a kind, loving, beautiful person" who turned to Christianity to recover from a rough past, her close friend said.

She came to Pinellas County four or five years ago and soon immersed herself in activities at local churches, said M'rissa Rosenthal, 34, a member of Lion of Judah Foursquare Church in Dunedin.

Now, police think the petite 27-year-old may have been the victim of a serial killer.

Last month, they found Costello's body on a desolate beachfront strip in Long Island, N.Y. The bodies of three other women were found in the same marshy area. Authorities think the women, all in their 20s, may have been slain by the same person. All were prostitutes who advertised online, officials said.

No one has been arrested, and authorities are not saying whether they have any suspects.

Police identified Costello earlier this week, saying she was last seen in North Babylon, N.Y., on Sept. 2.

Five feet tall and 100 pounds, Costello grew up in the Wilmington, N.C., area, according to Cherie Malpass, 55, whose husband is Costello's cousin. When Costello was a young teen, she often visited Malpass' house and hung out with her daughter.

"She was hyper, happy and energetic," Malpass said. "She never did cause trouble or anything like that."

She was a sweet girl, Malpass said. "She just got mixed up with the wrong people."

Malpass said she was aware that Costello was in the escort business when she lived in North Carolina. But several years back, around 2006, Costello was adamant that she was turning her life around.

She got a job as a server at a diner. She said she was "with the Lord," was going to church and was in the choir, Malpass said.

Rosenthal said a couple at a North Carolina church supported Costello.

"She had a hard life. They really helped her. And then she moved here," said Rosenthal, who met Costello around 2006 at a church retreat. Costello's sister lived in St. Petersburg at the time, Rosenthal said.

Costello, who also attended First Assembly of God in Clearwater, helped in the church nursery, Rosenthal said.

"She had a heart for children," she said.

Costello took great joy in helping her friends, too. She handled all of the arrangements when Rosenthal's beloved grandfather died.

"She was by my side when my grandfather died, and she took care of everything that needed to be done for me that I could not do for myself," said Rosenthal, who lives in Clearwater.

Costello lived in St. Petersburg, in the High Point area near Largo and in Clearwater, records show.

She married Donald Costello in December 2007. The couple divorced last March. He did not return several messages for comment this week.

Costello's address in High Point matches the address of the former president of Private Playmates Escort Referrals. That company was dissolved in 2008 because it didn't file an annual report, state records show.

Rosenthal said Costello didn't mention anything about the escort business.

But she thought Costello may have gotten on the wrong path because she had been "victimized."

"She was seeking healing for that," Rosenthal said. "A lot of women that end up doing that have been abused. But that was not the heart of who Amber was as a person."

Rosenthal said she last heard from Costello in the summer of 2009.

In December 2009, Costello was arrested on suspicion of shoplifting a few items, including toothpaste, from a Pinellas Park Publix supermarket, police records show. She told police she was an assistant at the Clearwater Library, but the city doesn't have any record of her employment. There's still an active warrant for her arrest because she failed to show up for court on the petty theft charge.

Police in New York found the first woman's body in mid December near a beachfront highway that leads to Jones Beach State Park. The other three women were found two days later during a followup investigation.

Last week, authorities identified one of the victims: Megan Waterman from Scarborough, Maine. Two others along with Costello were identified Monday as Maureen Brainard-Barnes of Norwich, Conn., and Melissa Barthelemy of Erie County, N.Y.

"What happened was an awful, horrific tragedy, and I am praying that it stops here and that whoever did this is caught," Rosenthal said.

A reward of up to $5,000 is being offered for information leading to an arrest in this case. Detectives are asking anyone with information to contact the homicide squad at (631) 852-6392 or Crime Stoppers at 1-800-220-8477.

Information from the Associated Press was used in this report. Lorri Helfand can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 445-4155.

Police say former Pinellas woman, found dead in New York, could be victim of a serial killer 01/27/11 [Last modified: Thursday, January 27, 2011 7:42pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Senate to take up AUMF debate as Trump defends reaction to Niger attack


    WASHINGTON — The Senate Foreign Relations Committee is taking up a long-awaited debate about authorizing military force against the Islamic State as President Trump comes under unprecedented public scrutiny for his treatment of dead soldiers' families, following an ambush on troops helping to fight Islamic …

  2. In fear and vigilance, a Tampa neighborhood holds its breath


    TAMPA — There was a time, not long ago, when Wayne Capaz would go for a stroll at night and Christina Rodriguez would shop whenever she wanted. Michael Fuller would go to his night job as a line cook, not too worried about his wife at home.

    More than 50 people gathered and walked in the Southeast Seminole Heights community Friday to pay respects to the victims of three shootings. The crowd took a moment of silence at the corner of 11th Street and East New Orleans where Monica Hoffa was found dead. [JONATHAN CAPRIEL  |  Times]
  3. Fennelly: What's not to like about Lightning's start?

    Lightning Strikes

    BRANDON — No one is engraving the Stanley Cup. No one has begun stuffing the league MVP ballot box for Nikita Kucherov.

    The Lightning, with a win tonight, would match the best start in franchise history, 7-1-1 in the 2003-04 Cup season.
  4. Study: Pollution kills 9 million a year, costs $4.6 trillion


    NEW DELHI — Environmental pollution — from filthy air to contaminated water — is killing more people every year than all war and violence in the world. More than smoking, hunger or natural disasters. More than AIDS, tuberculosis and malaria combined.

    New Delhi’s landmark India Gate, a war memorial, is engulfed in morning smog on Friday.
  5. Quarterback Jameis Winston will start Sunday for the Bucs


    TAMPA — Jameis Winston hadn't thrown in practice since he injured his right shoulder in Sunday's loss at Arizona, and with that uncertainty, a wide line of TV cameras and reporters' cellphones were all out Friday morning, recording the moment as Winston tested his shoulder with his first throws early in …

    Despite a sore shoulder, Jameis Winston will be making his 38th consecutive start since being drafted first overall in 2015.