Wednesday, June 20, 2018
Public safety

Saving a life is a pure act of valor

Here's what Sgt. Scott Lamia has to say about seeing ugly confrontations end peacefully:

"It's extremely satisfying. . . . That's the main goal, to preserve life," said Lamia, 36, a 15-year veteran of the Hernando County Sheriff's Office.

"There isn't anything joyful about taking somebody's life. There's nothing good that comes out of it."

Lamia's reminder — which he's more qualified to deliver than just about anybody in the department — is sadly relevant these days.

In October, Hernando sheriff's Detective Rocky Howard and Tampa police Officer William Mechler shot and killed Inga Marie Swanson, a naked, disoriented woman who had threatened them with a gun that turned out to be broken and unloaded.

On Wednesday night, Deputy Ramona Fuhs shot and injured an 18-year-old high school senior who had attacked her as she tried to get out of her patrol car.

In Fuhs' case, we don't know enough to determine whether the shooting was justified. Howard and Mechler, who were off duty at the time of Swanson's shooting, were not only cleared of wrongdoing; last month Sheriff Al Nienhuis awarded them his agency's highest honor, the Medal of Valor.

I thought at the time this award undermined the lesson that should have been learned from Swanson's death — that killing a person in need of help is one of the worst imaginable outcomes.

I'm even more convinced of this now that I've read the Florida Department of Law Enforcement's report on the shooting. It doesn't show malice or negligence — just a messy, tragic incident in which no one appears especially heroic.

Swanson, as we've reported before, showed up near a home where Mechler and Howard were hanging out and tried to climb into a truck with a 5-year-old boy.

The boy's father, Eric Glass, cursed at Swanson, yanked her hard enough that she fell to the ground and later referred to her as a "crazy b----," one of the witnesses interviewed said.

When Mechler's friend — who is also Howard's brother-in-law — told them about the incident, he said, "Eric just threw some half-naked chick out of his car."

Howard did try to help Swanson after she had walked away. And when she returned with the gun and continued to advance toward him and several other people, he fired a relatively restrained three shots.

Mechler shot at her eight times, bringing the total number of bullets fired to 11, seven of which struck Swanson.

Howard handcuffed her and then went to a house to wash his hands with bleach, apparently as a precaution against disease. He then retrieved latex gloves from his vehicle before applying chest compressions and trying to "stop the blood coming out from where Swanson had been shot," according to his statement to FDLE investigators.

Lamia probably knows as well as anyone how Howard felt.

In October 2002, he shot and killed John Thomas Tenison, who had repeatedly violated a court order requiring him to stay away from his ex-wife's Spring Hill home.

Most deputies go their entire careers without firing their weapons. This was the third time for Lamia, though the first time one of his bullets had struck anyone.

He told investigators he had to shoot. Tenison had been trying to run him down with his car.

A witness said otherwise. And though a grand jury cleared Lamia of criminal charges, it called the death unnecessary. Richard Nugent, who was sheriff at the time, suspended Lamia from duty for 15 days and then assigned him to desk duty, where he remained for five years.

I should make it clear that Lamia's comments at the beginning of this column were not meant to second-guess any of his fellow deputies' actions. He doesn't even second-guess his own, saying only that he was an "extremely proactive officer."

But after looking at Lamia's record since his return to patrol and interviewing him on Wednesday, it seems to me that he's a different deputy.

He is a longtime member of the agency's crisis response team, which is responsible for using negotiations to resolve problems.

He did this well enough that when he was promoted to sergeant last summer, he became commander of the team.

And a week ago Friday, he was called to the home of a suicidal man in Royal Highlands.

The man was inside and didn't hit or directly point his weapon at deputies. But they could see through a window that he was holding a shotgun, and he told them he would use it if they tried to come inside.

"I assured him that we had no interest in coming inside," said Lamia, who was able to reach the man on his cellphone.

He listened to the man's complaints about the Sheriff's Office, which had issued him a traffic ticket a few years earlier that he was still mad about.

Lamia let the man talk about his financial and psychological troubles and told him deputies could get him help. After Lamia learned that the man had served in the Air Force, they even chatted about their shared interest in airplanes.

Finally, by about 4 a.m., Lamia said, "I think I wore him down."

The man left his house with his hands up and his shirt raised to show he didn't have a pistol tucked in his waistband, Lamia said.

"I came up to say 'Hi' and shook his hand and patted him on the back to tell him everything would be all right."

For that, I'd say, Lamia deserves a medal.

Comments
Couple leased someone else’s home to 12 families at same time, Largo police say

Couple leased someone else’s home to 12 families at same time, Largo police say

LARGO — At least 12 families leased the same Largo home at the same time and lost as much as $4,300 each in a fraud scheme run by a couple who portrayed themselves as owners of the property, Largo police said.Police learned of the scheme Tuesday afte...
Updated: 7 minutes ago
St. Pete police investigating social media threat against Pride event

St. Pete police investigating social media threat against Pride event

ST. PETERSBURG — Police are investigating a threat against St. Pete Pride weekend based on a social media comment left on a Tampa Bay Times story.A Facebook commenter used an alias to post the threat on a story about a pop-up gay club planned for the...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Driver in fatal Tampa hit-and-run turns himself in

Driver in fatal Tampa hit-and-run turns himself in

TAMPA — The driver who was sought in a fatal hit-and-run on Sunday night has turned himself in.Police say Roger Herelle, 33, told detectives Wednesday he was involved in the crash that killed Sally Ann McClellan Webb, 58.Police had had been seeking t...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Five guns taken in 30 reported break-ins of unlocked cars in Clearwater

Five guns taken in 30 reported break-ins of unlocked cars in Clearwater

CLEARWATER — Thieves have made off with at least five guns after breaking into unlocked vehicles in recent days, police said Wednesday morning.Over the past three days, a group of people have been breaking into unlocked vehicles across the city. Clea...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Police investigating body found floating near Davis Islands

Police investigating body found floating near Davis Islands

TAMPA — Police are working to recover a body that was found floating in the water near the Davis Island Sea Basin on Wednesday morning.It is uncertain how the body ended up there, according to police.This is a developing story. Stay with tampabay.com...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Pasco Sheriff: Hudson man faces sexual battery charges

Pasco Sheriff: Hudson man faces sexual battery charges

HUDSON — A 33-year-old man is facing charges of sexual battery and rape after Pasco County Sheriff’s deputies said he assaulted a 14-year-old girl.Christopher Hall, who was 31 at the time of the incident, forced the victim into a bathroom, took off h...
Updated: 5 hours ago
SB traffic on I-275 slowed in St. Petersburg after car jumps median

SB traffic on I-275 slowed in St. Petersburg after car jumps median

ST. PETERSBURG — A car that is straddling the center concrete barrier is causing a visual slowdown Wednesday morning on Interstate 275.The incident occurred sometime around 7:30 a.m.The passenger side of the car can be seen hanging along the median o...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Hillsborough sheriff to announce results of construction fraud investigation

Hillsborough sheriff to announce results of construction fraud investigation

TAMPA — The Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office will provide details today of an investigation that led to the arrest of 15 unlicensed contractors.Sheriff Chad Chronister will brief reporters at 2 p.m. on what his office described as a "major constr...
Updated: 5 hours ago
New Port Richey man faces sexual battery charge

New Port Richey man faces sexual battery charge

NEW PORT RICHEY — A 33-year-old man was arrested Monday on a charge of sexual battery, accused of assaulting a 10-year-old girl.Jonathan Wells was booked into the Pasco County jail, where he was being held Tuesday without bail.The assault took place ...
Published: 06/19/18
St. Petersburg power outage affects thousands

St. Petersburg power outage affects thousands

More than 2,000 Duke Energy customers are without power after a cluster of storms rolled through earlier this afternoon, according to Duke Energy.The area without power stretches along 62nd Avenue N from 12th Street N to 30th Way N, according to the ...
Published: 06/19/18