Wednesday, June 20, 2018
Public safety

Savings tough to calculate in Florida prison privatization plan

TALLAHASSEE — As state lawmakers consider a massive expansion of prison privatization, one number dominates the debate: 7 percent.

That's how much savings the legislation requires of private prison operators compared to state-run prisons.

"I believe in it," says Senate President Mike Haridopolos, R-Merritt Island. "It's incumbent upon me to find the best deal for the taxpayer."

But that number is subjective, and the state's own analysts warn against comparing prison costs because no two prisons are alike and it's difficult to make precise cost comparisons between public and private prisons.

"You can make something look like a savings on paper," says Sen. Paula Dockery, R-Lakeland. "We're not saving money. Absolutely not."

Privatization has polarized the Legislature into two camps: One sees outsourcing as a proven way to cut costs; the other views it as a risky undertaking riddled with hidden costs.

Senate Bill 2038 would privatize 27 prisons and work camps in 18 counties from Charlotte County to the Keys. More than 4,300 state workers would lose their jobs, though many likely would be offered them back, at reduced pay and benefits, working for a private vendor.

Seven Florida prisons now are run by private, for-profit companies. They are in Bay, Columbia, Gadsden, Glades, Jackson, Palm Beach and Santa Rosa counties.

Supporters point to statistics showing that those prisons cost from 7 percent to 28 percent less to operate than state-run prisons.

But the 28 percent figure, at a 1,500-bed women's prison in Gadsden, is "artificially high," a state analysis said, because no state-run women's prison was comparable in size at the time.

An April 2010 report by the Legislature's independent research arm said savings were due to lower retirement benefits for private prison workers and higher costs for programs and overhead at state prisons, such as substance abuse treatment and transportation.

"While significant, these cost savings estimates are subject to caveats and should be evaluated cautiously," the report said.

The report said an apples-to-apples comparison of the cost of running public and private prisons is difficult because of the many factors involved: size, location, the design and age of the prison, the physical and mental health of the inmates, their custody level and the extent of programs available to inmates.

"Such adjustments to 'equalize' Florida's public and private prisons historically have been controversial," said the report by OPPAGA, the Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability.

Other factors figuring into the privatization debate include:

Leave payouts. Through Jan. 19, the prison system said, payouts of unused sick leave and vacation time to departed employees at South Florida prisons cost $19 million, more than the first year's total savings. The vendors will be asked to repay $8 million of those costs.

Bumping. The union contract for correctional officers allows outsourced officers to "bump" or take the jobs of those with less seniority, creating a ripple effect throughout the state.

Inmate transfers. Hundreds of felons classified as close management have been shifted out of South Florida to prisons upstate. That could make the region more attractive to for-profit prison firms because it could lower their security costs and make it easier for them to reach the 7 percent target savings.

South Florida prisons currently house 79 inmates classified as close management, typically inmates serving sentences from 15 years to life, who cost more money to supervise than less-dangerous prisoners because they are more prone to acts of violence.

The state says the transfers started in 2009 with the opening of a new, high-security prison in Suwannee County.

"I have no indication that they have been moved as it relates to privatization," Corrections Secretary Ken Tucker told a Senate committee last week. "The department would have no interest in making it less dangerous. … We're going to entrust private prisons with similar level of inmates."

Tucker said close-management prisons in Santa Rosa, Bradford, Union and Suwannee counties and a secure women's prison at Lowell all make more sense because they are cheaper to operate than older, inefficient prisons in South Florida.

Former Corrections Secretary James McDonough, who ran the agency under former Gov. Jeb Bush, says the privatization of South Florida is moving too fast.

"While the privatization idea at this scale may prove to be a positive, at the moment we have no analytical way of knowing that to be true," McDonough said.

"We should look before we leap."

Steve Bousquet can be reached at [email protected] or (850) 224-7263.

Comments
SB traffic on I-275 slowed in St. Petersburg after car jumps median

SB traffic on I-275 slowed in St. Petersburg after car jumps median

ST. PETERSBURG — A car that is straddling the center concrete barrier is causing a visual slowdown Wednesday morning on Interstate 275.The incident occurred sometime around 7:30 a.m.The passenger side of the car can be seen hanging along the median o...
Updated: 2 hours ago
New Port Richey man faces sexual battery charge

New Port Richey man faces sexual battery charge

NEW PORT RICHEY — A 33-year-old man was arrested Monday on a charge of sexual battery, accused of assaulting a 10-year-old girl.Jonathan Wells was booked into the Pasco County jail, where he was being held Tuesday without bail.The assault took place ...
Published: 06/19/18
St. Petersburg power outage affects thousands

St. Petersburg power outage affects thousands

More than 2,000 Duke Energy customers are without power after a cluster of storms rolled through earlier this afternoon, according to Duke Energy.The area without power stretches along 62nd Avenue N from 12th Street N to 30th Way N, according to the ...
Published: 06/19/18
Safety Harbor fire chief departs: ‘Take pride in the job’

Safety Harbor fire chief departs: ‘Take pride in the job’

SAFETY HARBOR — When Fire Chief Joe Accetta started working at the Safety Harbor Fire Department, Fire Station 53 was a double wide in the middle of a field now home to Mease Countryside Hospital.Now almost four decades of challenges and promotions l...
Published: 06/19/18
Deputies search for suspects in rapper XXXTentacion slaying

Deputies search for suspects in rapper XXXTentacion slaying

DEERFIELD BEACH, Fla. — Deputies were searching for suspects Tuesday after troubled rapper-singer XXXTentacion was fatally shot in the driver’s seat of a luxury electric sports car. The 20-year-old rising star, who pronounced his stage name "Ex Ex Ex...
Published: 06/19/18
Lakeland father, girlfriend face charges in death of 6-year-old girl

Lakeland father, girlfriend face charges in death of 6-year-old girl

A Lakeland man and his girlfriend face charges of first-degree murder and aggravated manslaughter in the death of his 6-year-old daughter last week.Larry Lewis Golden Jr., 26, Breonna B. Wren, 21, were arrested Friday and are being held without bail ...
Published: 06/19/18
Argument over dog leads to fatal shooting in Polk County

Argument over dog leads to fatal shooting in Polk County

A Fort Meade man was killed Monday night and two others were wounded after Polk County deputies say they approached a man while searching for a lost dog.The shooting occurred around 6:45 p.m. at the home of suspected shooter Charles Peddycoart, at 41...
Published: 06/19/18
Deadly Sunday for swimmers in bay area waters

Deadly Sunday for swimmers in bay area waters

Two people drowned and another suffered life-threatening injuries in the waters of Tampa Bay and the Gulf of Mexico on Sunday.Investigators said all three cases appear to be accidents, but the incidents stand as a reminder that summer, with vacation ...
Published: 06/18/18
Pinellas deputies arrest Mississippi man 31 years after sexual battery

Pinellas deputies arrest Mississippi man 31 years after sexual battery

SEMINOLE — She was 22 when deputies said a man forced her at knifepoint into the woods off Seminole Boulevard and sexually battered her in February 1987.The case went cold, but now the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office said it has arrested the man it ...
Published: 06/18/18
Tampa police seek driver who struck pedestrian and drove off

Tampa police seek driver who struck pedestrian and drove off

TAMPA — Police are seeking the public’s help in locating the driver who fatally struck a pedestrian on Sunday night and then drove off.The incident took place at 9:15 p.m. near the intersection of N Nebraska Avenue and E Linebaugh Avenue.No details a...
Published: 06/18/18