Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

These pot searches by police don't pass the smell test

So you've got a big night planned with your friends.

You head to Ybor City in your fancy, tricked-out pickup truck and spend a few hours listening to music and soaking up the atmosphere.

All's well until you're ready to head home, and that's when you discover that someone broke into your locked truck and ransacked the interior.

You absolutely need to call the cops, right?

Just one problem.

It was a cop who broke into your truck.

Not some off-duty renegade or cop-gone-bad. This officer was part of a regular canine unit on patrol. The dog indicated it had picked up a marijuana scent from the passenger's side, and the officer used an unlocking tool to get into the truck.

When no marijuana was found, the officer wrote a note about what had happened and left it inside the truck.

This is all completely legal.

And just a little scary.

Police have been given authority by the U.S. Supreme Court to conduct vehicle searches without warrants, based on a trained dog's alert.

The federal case originated in the Florida Panhandle and was thrown out by the state Supreme Court before it was unanimously overturned in Washington last year.

So now we are left with stories such as the one described above involving Matthew Heller's truck in Ybor City in February. Tampa police acknowledge the basic facts of the incident, although there is a slight dispute about the aftermath.

Heller's attorney, Dominic Fariello, said there was minor damage inside the truck — apparently, some electronic equipment no longer works correctly — and said he sent a letter to Tampa police April 2 asking for an incident report.

A TPD spokeswoman said police have no record of any requests other than a call from Heller about 10 days ago. She said Heller was more concerned about the legality of the search and did not mention any damage to the truck.

But let's forget, for now, the possibility of damage and focus on the law itself.

Isn't it a little creepy to think that police can break into a vehicle based on a dog's signal? And not for a potentially dangerous bomb-sniffing case, but for a possible marijuana bust?

The scent of marijuana is often used by law enforcement as a justification for searches. The Pinellas County Sheriff's Office had a number of cases challenged in 2012 because detectives obtained warrants to search homes based on dubious claims of smelling marijuana from the sidewalk. A few weeks ago, Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Judge Michael Andrews threw out a drug case because he found that a St. Petersburg police officer's claim of smelling marijuana had stretched the limits of believability.

The attorney in Heller's case wonders whether his client was singled out because his truck is raised high off the ground, with a custom paint job and other pricey features.

"It sounds like they saw this vehicle and said, 'There's probably drugs in there. Let's go find them,' " Fariello said. "It's almost like they profiled his truck. I like to call it vehicular discrimination."

A police officer's job is not easy. Cops are often dealing with the most unhinged, unscrupulous and uncaring people in our midst. And there are times when extraordinary measures must be taken in the name of public safety.

But is it worth trampling the Constitution to investigate a suspected pot smoker?

These pot searches by police don't pass the smell test 06/02/14 [Last modified: Monday, June 2, 2014 7:39pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'Oh, my God, this is crazy!' The 911 calls as Hollywood nursing home residents died (w/video)


    One by one, the calls for help poured in from nurses at the Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills.

    The Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills, where 14 residents died during an air conditioning failure in the aftermath of Hurricane Irma, in Hollywood, Fla., Sept. 14, 2017. The police released 911 calls from a nursing home under investigation after some of its residents died in the post-hurricane heat. [Scott McIntyre | The New York Times]
  2. Neil deGrasse Tyson will speak at the Straz Center for the Performing Arts on Thursday. We talked to him ahead of time. Check out what he had to say. [Patrick Eccelsine/FOX]
  3. Conor Oberst, Johnnyswim concerts moved out of State Theatre over construction issues


    Two more concerts -- including one this weekend -- have been moved out of the State Theatre in St. Petersburg as the venue continues to experience scaled-down crowd capacity following recent construction.

  4. Hillsborough board to vote on new school start times


    TAMPA — The big issue at today's Hillsborough County School Board meeting will be the 2018-19 bell schedule. To save money and get students to school on time, …

    Hillsborough County School Board members tried to work out their differences at a training day in Temple Terrace on Oct. 11. Today, they will vote on revised school start times for 2018-19. [COLLEEN WRIGHT | Times]
  5. McCain condemns 'half-baked, spurious nationalism' in clear shot at Trump (w/video)


    PHILADELPHIA — An emotional Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., launched a thinly veiled critique of President Donald Trump's global stewardship Monday night, using a notable award ceremony to condemn "people who would rather find scapegoats than solve problems."

    Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., right, accompanied by Chair of the National Constitution Center's Board of Trustees, former Vice President Joe Biden, waves as he takes the stage before receiving the Liberty Medal in Philadelphia, Monday, Oct. 16, 2017. The honor is given annually to an individual who displays courage and conviction while striving to secure liberty for people worldwide. [Associated Press]