Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Woman asks to withdraw no-contest plea in beating death of Brooksville man

BROOKSVILLE — Facing 30 years in prison for the fatal beating and strangulation of a 68-year-old man, Treva Lynn Anderson had a change of heart.

Anderson no longer wants to settle for a no-contest plea. She would rather take her chances at trial.

During a court hearing this morning, Anderson will attempt to withdraw a plea of no contest to second-degree murder of Robert Rutherford of Brooksville. If her motion is denied by Circuit Judge Stephen Rushing, Anderson is scheduled to be sentenced Friday.

On May 28, Anderson, 24, pleaded no contest in the slaying of Rutherford. Assistant State Attorney Pete Magrino, the county's chief homicide prosecutor, agreed to reduce her first-degree murder charge and cap her sentence at 30 years instead of a life term as part of the deal.

But in the motion to withdraw the plea filed July 6, Anderson's public defender Tricia Jenkins wrote that Anderson agreed to the offer because she was frightened by the prospect of a trial, had limited experience with the judicial system, and was pressured into taking a plea by her mother.

Anderson now believes "she has a very strong defense to the charge of" murder, according to the motion.

Jenkins wasn't available for comment Tuesday.

Magrino asked Rushing to deny the motion in a response that he filed Tuesday. He notes that both sides negotiated the plea and that Anderson signed off on the agreement.

"If the judge grants it, we go back to Square One and she's looking at murder in the first degree," Magrino said. "If he denies it, I guess we have sentencing on Friday."

Authorities found Rutherford beaten and strangled in his home on Feb. 15 in the Julian Apartment complex on S Main Street. The medical examiner later determined "Bunk" or "Bunky,'' as he was known to his friends, died from repeated blunt trauma from a fire extinguisher to his head, and strangulation.

Hours after discovering his body, authorities arrested Anderson, who lives in Spring Hill. Rutherford frequently allowed young women, some of them drug addicts, into his home, according to a neighbor who said he refused to pass judgment on what she described as "unsavory characters."

Anderson's drug habit was escalating at the time of her arrest, court documents show. Three months earlier, she pleaded no contest and received a probationary sentence for filing a false police report. She claimed she was robbed when in fact she used the money to buy drugs.

Statements Anderson made to authorities suggest a variety of motives for the killing. She said he threatened to hurt her dog. She said he came after her with a knife. But the physical evidence said differently.

Rutherford's family didn't want to endure a trial laced with talk of drugs and prostitution. "They didn't want to see his reputation tarnished in any way, shape or form," Magrino said at the time.

Jenkins had indicated to the judge that she would ask for a lenient sentence given her client's rough upbringing.

Magrino said it's not all that unusual for a suspect to withdraw their plea before sentencing.

"I've had it happen in other cases in the past," he said. "I wouldn't say it's the norm but wouldn't say it's abnormal. It's somewhere in between."

Joel Anderson can be reached at or (352) 754-6120.

Woman asks to withdraw no-contest plea in beating death of Brooksville man 07/14/09 [Last modified: Tuesday, July 14, 2009 7:54pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Pasco targets repeat offenders with new code enforcement tactic

    Local Government

    HOLIDAY — The out-of-date and overpriced gasoline cost on the sign outside — $2.69 for a gallon of regular — is the first indication that business isn't booming.

    Basil A. Almamluk is the owner of the closed Pure Gas station in Holiday, which has emerged as a poster child for a new "high return'' county code enforcement effort. The property on Mile Stretch Drive is littered with discarded furniture and other trash. [Photo courtesy of Pasco County Sheriff's Office]
  2. Pasco tax roll shows increase, but so, too, are budget requests

    Local Government

    NEW PORT RICHEY — Pasco County's tax roll grew by more than 5 percent in 2016, but it's a figure that likely would require local government budget writers to trim proposed spending requests.

    OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times
New construction accounted for $693.5 million in taxable property values being added to the Pasco County tax rolls in 2016, according to preliminary estimates released by Property Appraiser Gary Joiner. Overall, the property tax roll grew more than 5 percent, according to the preliminary numbers.

  3. Tampa Bay Super Bowls: A brief history and some predictions for 2021


    At last, Tampa will host a Super Bowl again. It used to be that the Cigar City would host one a decade, but by the time February 2021 rolls around, it will have been 12 years since the epic showdown between the Steelers and Cardinals. Because it has been awhile, let's revisit those past Super Bowls while also peering …

    Santonio Holmes hauls in the game-winning touchdown in the Steelers' 27-23 Super Bowl XLIII victory over the Cardinals in 2009, the last time Tampa hosted a Super Bowl. [JAMES BORCHUCK | Times]
  4. Rays bats go silent in second straight loss to Angels (w/video)

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — Sure, Alex Cobb was to blame for the Rays' 4-0 loss on Tuesday.

    Derek Norris strikes out with the bases loaded as the Rays blow a golden opportunity in the seventh inning.
  5. Analysis: Manchester attack was exactly what many had long feared


    LONDON — For Britain's security agencies, London always seemed like the likely target. For years, the capital of 8 million with hundreds of thousands of weekly tourists and dozens of transit hubs had prepared for and feared a major terror attack.