Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Spring Hill Fire Rescue rigmarole didn't have to be

You know those tragic, regrettable moments when our leaders have the chance to do something great and blow it?

One of them came along in April of 2007 when — happily unaware of how bad things could really get — county commissioners thought their relationship with the Spring Hill Fire Rescue Commission had reached an all-time, intolerable low.

With that in mind — and in an attempt to streamline operations — county Commissioner David Russell managed to bring the fire commission's very existence up for a vote. That's right, by a simple casting of three "yea" votes, the County Commission could have done away with the district, flat-out abolished it.

Russell didn't get those votes, of course, and we'll see why a little later. But, in the meantime, just think of the misery that could have been avoided: the pointless (always a handy word for describing this outfit) squabbling among fire commissioners, the court hearings, the referendums.

That includes the costly special mail-out election scheduled to begin in a couple of weeks. As you lucky folks in Spring Hill probably already know, you get to pay $150,000 to ask yourself the same question you said "no" to just last year: Do you want to authorize the district to levy a property tax to pay for fire and ambulance service?

Obviously, given the previous vote and the general popularity of taxes these days, this tax levy seems to have little chance of passing. Because fire commissioners recognize this, Spring Hill residents will have the additional privilege of paying up to $25,000 for education about the need for this taxing authority.

Or so-called education. As of Friday, the board planned to send out a brochure to residents that suggests that the county, if it were to assume control of the Spring Hill Fire Rescue District, would have "the authority to raise the ad valorem tax rate from 2.5 mills up to 10 mills" for fire service.

Not quite. That 10 mills (a mill is $1 of tax on every $1,000 of assessed property value) is the total cap on countywide taxes, not the amount that can be charged for fire service. This information (or misinformation) is repeated in a side-by-side comparison of costs also printed in the brochure.

This apples-to-oranges cap on the total county millage rate, 10, looks pretty frightening against the Spring Hill district's 2.5. It's doubly alarming because the line next to it says the homestead tax exemption would not be allowed. That's true of the $194.87 flat fee for homeowners that accounts for most of the Hernando County Fire District's revenue. It's obviously not true of the county's general fund tax rate.

So, apparently, somebody needs to tell the fire commission that spreading misleading information doesn't qualify as education.

Back to the 2007 vote. Then-county Commissioner Diane Rowden had previously said she would vote to abolish the district. She changed her mind when she saw a meeting room packed with Spring Hill firefighters and their supporters.

I don't think she did even them a favor in the long run. They do good work fighting fires and handling medical emergencies, and their reputation suffers because of their barely competent board.

How about the fire commission itself? Did it benefit? Well, that 2007 vote prompted it to seek full independence, which was granted by a referendum in 2008. And this led to the current predicament. Because of the vote not to give the district authority to levy taxes, it still relies on the county to do this for it on the strength of a temporary court order. And though nobody knows for sure what will happen if the next referendum fails and the court order expires at the end of September, it seems likely that through some emergency declaration on the state level, we'll get back to where we could have been four years ago, with the county in charge.

The Spring Hill fire board makes some strong arguments that its property tax rate is cheaper for most residents than the county's charges, but I'm not convinced it will be able to maintain services without additional fees of some description. Plus, it just makes sense that providing services would be cheaper, that administrative costs could be cut, if we made this one fire service rather than two. So, I'm not sure residents have benefitted either.

That's not to mention the other good thing that comes with making firefighting a simple county agency. It removes a lot of the political maneuvering and brawling that can only be described as — what else? — pointless.

Spring Hill Fire Rescue rigmarole didn't have to be 05/14/11 [Last modified: Saturday, May 14, 2011 9:58am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Pasco considers new tax districts for parks, libraries, public safety

    Local Government

    DADE CITY — Faced with growing costs amid an expected voter-endorsed tax cut, Pasco County is considering changing the way it pays for parks, libraries and public safety.

Pasco County is considering a new taxing district to finance an expansion and ongoing operations of the county's Department of Parks,Recreaton and Natural Resources. Shown is the Dick's Tournament of Champions at the the  Wesley Chapel District Park, the last district park developed by the county. It opened in 2007.
  2. Ruskin man sought in fatal stabbing of roommate


    RUSKIN — The Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office has issued an arrest warrant for the suspect who fatally stabbed his roommate in a Ruskin home on Monday afternoon.

    Angel Calix, shown during a June 2016 arrest, is wanted in the fatal stabbing of a Ruskin man on Oct. 23, 2017. [Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office]
  3. Romano: Why flood insurance might not be enough to save your home

    Local Government

    Irma is gone, and Maria never came.

    And yet this is as good a time as any to worry.

  4. Tampa's streetcar system looks to expand north through downtown


    TAMPA — The TECO Line Streetcar system that runs from Ybor City to the Channel District could be extended north through downtown all the way to Tampa Heights, according to the latest update of a $1.7 million study aimed at expanding the streetcar system.

    Riders take in the last few stops of the streetcar route in Ybor City during the tenth anniversary celebration of the TECO line streetcar system in Tampa in 2012. Now officials are looking for ways to expand the service north through downtown to Tampa Heights. [EVE EDELHEIT  |  Times]
  5. Interview: Steve Martin, Martin Short bringing 'best version' of their show back to St. Petersburg


    Hot celebrity-spotting tip: Stop by the Salvador Dalí Museum on Jan. 19. You might catch a glimpse of Steve Martin.

    Steve Martin, left, and Martin Short will bring “An Evening You Will Forget for the Rest of Your Life” to the Mahaffey Theater on Jan. 19.