Tuesday, February 20, 2018
Public safety

Red-light cameras are a plus for safety — if you get rid of the deceit

Let's be honest: It's hard to argue against the concept of red-light cameras.

It's a law-and-order issue. A right-and-wrong issue. Mostly it is a public safety issue, and there is virtually nothing you can say that trumps that argument.

You can manipulate and parse the accident data any way you choose, but the fundamental truth is drivers should be more cognizant of blowing through red lights.

So, no, I will not argue against the concept of red-light cameras.

Only the deceit involved.

Red-light cameras are big business. They provide revenue for state and local governments, as well as the private companies that develop and operate the cameras.

And there's nothing wrong with a contractor making a profit, nor a government entity issuing fines.

The problem is they are hiding behind the banner of public safety while stacking the deck to maximize profits.

"I don't support them at all,'' Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri said. "They were done for all the wrong reasons. I feel pretty confident saying they were done with revenues in mind.''

What are some of the non-public safety issues involved?

• Yellow lights that suspiciously turn red more quickly than the recommended guideline for an intersection. When a poorly timed yellow light was recently fixed in Oldsmar, the number of red-light infractions dropped in half the following month.

• When the Legislature tried to make it easier to contest violations, they made it easier for municipalities to increase revenues. Newly created hearing boards can now charge up to $250 in fees for failed appeals and are theoretically motivated to pay for their own existence by ruling against drivers.

• Contracts that are written in a way that smaller municipalities essentially face a quota to keep the cash flowing to camera vendors. So a rolling right-hand turn that a traffic cop would typically ignore is now routinely turned into a $158 violation.

For Gualtieri, the biggest problem is tickets are being issued in a vacuum. There is no nuance, no extenuating circumstances, no warnings. Just a video and a violation.

"Law enforcement officers use their own judgment and discretion every day, and that has been removed from the equation,'' he said. "There's a difference between an aggressive driver with a history of violations who is taking no responsibility and a mom in a minivan who is horrified that she just mistimed a yellow light.

"My biggest problem is the right-hand turns where there is no question of safety involved. That's just a 'gotcha' mentality, and I detest it, especially in law enforcement.''

Sen. Jeff Brandes, R-St. Petersburg, is also convinced revenues are at the heart of red-light cameras and recently filed a bill that would effectively repeal the law.

How likely is that?

Considering there is money to be made and lobbyists to be unleashed, the idea legislators would actually kill red-light cameras seems iffy at best.

And, when you get right down to it, there is still a legitimate argument to be made in the name of public safety.

So maybe what we need is a compromise. A more common-sense approach on right-hand turns. A more citizen-friendly appeals process. A little more scrutiny on vendor contracts. Less emphasis on money and more on safety.

Nothing wrong with knowing when to tap the brakes.

Comments
County gives initial support to adding deputies at Hernando elementary schools

County gives initial support to adding deputies at Hernando elementary schools

BROOKSVILLE — The Hernando County Commission on Tuesday informally supported adding as many as 10 school resource officers in county schools, including one for every elementary school, in an effort to bolster security in the wake of the deadly school...
Updated: 22 minutes ago
Next stop for Parkland school shooting survivors: the Florida Capitol

Next stop for Parkland school shooting survivors: the Florida Capitol

PARKLAND — Students who survived the shooting at Stoneman Douglas High School began a 400-mile journey to Florida’s capital Tuesday to urge lawmakers to prevent a repeat of the massacre that killed 17 students and faculty last week.Three buses carryi...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Man charged with killing wife who disappeared at sea

Man charged with killing wife who disappeared at sea

FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. -- A man who claimed his wife disappeared at sea when their boat collided with an unknown object near the Bahamas was charged Tuesday with killing her and intentionally trying to sink the vessel to cover his tracks.Lewis Bennett...
Updated: 1 hour ago
She drove drunk with a child in the backseat, deputies say. She said she ‘just got out of rehab’

She drove drunk with a child in the backseat, deputies say. She said she ‘just got out of rehab’

A Miami woman is accused of driving intoxicated with a child in the back seat of her car — and she told a Palm Beach County Sheriff’s deputy that she "just got out of rehab," according to arrest recordsStephanie Roque, 30, was traveling through Welli...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Neighbor stunned after woman, 71, raped in ‘safe’ Pasco neighborhood

Neighbor stunned after woman, 71, raped in ‘safe’ Pasco neighborhood

NEW PORT RICHEY— Iris Ramos couldn’t sleep Monday night.Ramos, 70, lives four doors down from a house at 7437 Heather St., where Pasco County deputies reported a home invasion and rape of a 71-year-old woman Monday morning. Ramos had helped the woman...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Investigators find insufficient evidence against former state fair executive director

Investigators find insufficient evidence against former state fair executive director

TAMPA — Charles Pesano may have used his position as executive director of the Florida State Fair to funnel business to his family’s company, get Tampa Bay Rays tickets and have a hot tub installed in his Valrico home, but there is no evidence he com...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Girl, 12, sister of murder victim, found safe after leaving Bradenton home

Girl, 12, sister of murder victim, found safe after leaving Bradenton home

BRADENTON — Jalyssa Shannon, the sister of 13-year-old Riverview murder victim Janessa Shannon, was found safe Monday evening after leaving her mother’s Bradenton home Sunday, authorities said.Jalyssa was found about 7 p.m., according to the Manatee ...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Young child struck by vehicle in Tampa

Young child struck by vehicle in Tampa

TAMPA — A young child was injured after being struck by a vehicle Thursday morning, according to police.The crash involved a pedestrian and a vehicle near Myrtle Street and Serena Drive around 7:45 a.m., police said.The child sustained non-life threa...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Most Americans say Trump, Congress not doing enough to stop mass shootings, Post-ABC poll finds

Most Americans say Trump, Congress not doing enough to stop mass shootings, Post-ABC poll finds

More than 6 in 10 Americans fault Congress and President Donald Trump for not doing enough to prevent mass shootings, according to a new Washington Post-ABC News poll, with most Americans continuing to say these incidents are more reflective of probl...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Romano: Until the Parkland shooting, lawmakers ignored requests for school safety funds

Romano: Until the Parkland shooting, lawmakers ignored requests for school safety funds

His words and his pleas are similar to what we’ve heard from others in recent days.Kids deserve to feel safe when they walk into a classroom in Florida. More security is needed. More boots on the ground would be helpful. Mostly, more money must be de...
Published: 02/20/18