Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Carlton: Sounding a warning shot about 'stand your ground' bill

What could possibly be next for our "stand your ground" law that can make it legal to shoot first and ask questions later?

How about pending legislation that says if a shooting is justified under this troubling law, what happened can be erased from the public record?

If that's not enough to drop your jaw, it's only part of a bill sailing along in Tallahassee to extend "stand your ground" protection to someone who fires a warning shot. Because, hey, we can't have enough gunfire around here.

Tucked into that bill is an amendment that's practically a kiss blown to the powerful National Rifle Association. Should it pass, people whose charges are dropped by prosecutors or judges because of a "stand your ground" defense that says they were justifiably threatened can then get their entire "criminal history" records expunged.

Which means those arrest and court records would not be accessible to you, the public. A tragic incident in which someone was arrested after someone was hurt or killed would have no such record you could see. A person who was accused of that crime could say on an application for a job or a lease: No, never been arrested — even though he had.

People can already apply to have records for certain crimes expunged under very narrow circumstances. But this amendment — which involves charges of murder, manslaughter and assault — could erode some of the truest, most time-honored elements of our justice system:

Openness. Transparency. The right of citizens to see the system work for themselves instead of taking the authorities' word for it. (Nothing to see here, folks.)

A Times investigation of 200 such cases included many in which the person who shot, stabbed or otherwise injured or killed someone wasn't prosecuted because of a "stand your ground" defense. The report exposed how the law is applied inconsistently depending on where in Florida an incident happens, with differing outcomes. It showed some eyebrow-raising circumstances, such as victims shot in the back.

All of which should be open for you, the public, to consider.

By the way, if the NRA supported, say, a free lifetime Disney pass for anyone who successfully stood his ground, how fast do you suppose Florida legislators would make it happen? They are, after all, poised to pass a law forbidding disciplining schoolchildren who make play guns from Pop-Tarts.

On erasing those public (at least for now) records, consider the 2011 case of Greyston Garcia of Miami. He armed himself with a kitchen knife when someone was stealing the radio from his truck. He chased the fleeing burglar down. When the burglar swung a bag of stolen radios at him, Garcia blocked it and stabbed him to death. He did not call police. He went home and went to sleep. He later sold the stolen stereos. After testimony that the bag of radios could have done him serious harm, Garcia walked.

Are those details you would want to know in considering whether "stand your ground" should stand as is? And if it is a good law, wouldn't a public airing of its cases prove it?

How do you look at a law that can justify killing someone if you don't get to know what actually happened? But maybe that's the point. Nothing to see here, folks. Move along.

Carlton: Sounding a warning shot about 'stand your ground' bill 03/21/14 [Last modified: Friday, March 21, 2014 8:39pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Hernando County Sheriff's Office: Deputies shoot suicidal woman who brandished shotgun

    Crime

    BROOKSVILLE — Hernando County Sheriff's deputies shot a woman they believed to be suicidal after she pointed a shotgun at them Sunday, according to a police report.

  2. Trump administration disbands federal advisory committee on climate change

    National

    WASHINGTON - The Trump administration has decided to disband the federal advisory panel for the National Climate Assessment, a group aimed at helping policymakers and private-sector officials incorporate the government's climate analysis into long-term planning.

    President Donald Trump. [Associated Press]
  3. Blake Snell shines as Rays beat Mariners to end skid (w/video)

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — Blake Snell delivered the best outing of his young career and the Rays offense continued its home run-hitting ways for a 3-0 victory Sunday against the Mariners in front of 13,354 at Tropicana Field.

    Tampa Bay Rays third baseman Evan Longoria (3) with starting pitcher Blake Snell (4) after the top of the seventh inning of the game between the Seattle Mariners and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Fla. on Sunday, Aug. 20, 2017.
  4. No touchdown, but fun lesson for Bucs' Adam Humphries

    Bucs

    It didn't end up being a touchdown, but one of the Bucs' biggest hustle plays in Thursday's win over Jacksonville saw receiver Adam Humphries scoop up a loose ball just before halftime, after what looked like an incompletion but was correctly ruled a Jameis Winston fumble.

    Bucs WR Adam Humphries runs to the end zone with QB Jameis Winston trailing -- his alert play wasn't a touchdown because teammates cannot advance a fumble in the final two minutes of a half.
  5. Bucs' Demar Dotson should be back from injury next week

    Bucs

    The Bucs got good news on starting right tackle Demar Dotson, whose MRI showed only a mild right groin sprain and should be back at practice next week.

    Bucs tackle Demar Dotson, shown last year when he signed a three-year contract extension, should only miss a week of practice with his groin injury and can return healthy for the Bucs' season opener at Miami in three weeks. [Octavio Jones | Times]